Exploring Value and Ethical Dimensions of Disruptive Technologies for Learning and Teaching

Terje Väljataga, Kai Pata, Andrea Annus, Michelle Andrade Calisto, Águeda Gómez Cambronero, Elmar Eisemann, Athina Kasini, Ricardo Marroquim, Inmaculada Remolar, László Szécsi, Amir Zaidi, Rubén García-Vidal

Introduction

As disruptive technologies such as Artificial Intelligence (AI), Virtual Reality (VR), and Augmented Reality (AR) rapidly integrate into modern classrooms, social and ethical norms are struggling to keep pace. While these tools offer innovative ways to learn and engage, they simultaneously introduce significant threats to privacy, equity, and human cognition. A critical gap exists in current educational technology (EdTech) development: a lack of practical, evidence-based methods to measure and evaluate the "value dimensions" of these technologies during their design and implementation phases. Most innovation is currently driven by technical capability rather than ethical intentionality. This paper introduces a structured workshop-based method designed to help students, teachers, and developers verbalize and negotiate the values that should guide the future of educational technology.

The Value Elicitation Workshop

To address this gap, researchers developed the Value Elicitation Workshop as part of the Horizon Europe e-DIPLOMA project. This method was implemented across seven European countries (Spain, Netherlands, Italy, Hungary, Cyprus, Bulgaria, and Estonia) to gather diverse stakeholder perspectives. The approach utilizes two primary tools:

  1. Value Cards: A set of 45 cards, each defining a specific value (e.g., Privacy, Productivity, Autonomy). These provide a shared vocabulary for participants who may not have formal training in ethics.
  2. Learning Scenarios: Four fictional but "grounded" short stories describing technology use in specific educational tasks, such as AI-supported progress tracking in physics or telepresence robots in foreign language courses.

One of the most provocative scenarios involved using VR for fire extinguisher training, which allowed participants to visualize the practical and ethical implications of immersive simulations.

Figure 2: Overview of the VR fire extinguisher training scenario, including the learning objectives and application description.

During the workshops, mixed-stakeholder groups—including students, lecturers, and educational technologists—selected up to eight cards per scenario. They documented how those values related to the technology, either as a present feature to be protected or a missing requirement to be addressed.

Findings: The Complex Landscape of EdTech Values

The study generated 187 entries, identifying 58 distinct values. The results highlight a significant degree of "Value Ambivalence," where the same technology is perceived as both a benefit and a risk depending on the context. For instance, Accessibility was the most frequently cited value (selected 13 times), viewed as a benefit for remote learning but a hindrance in AR scenarios where physical teacher-student interaction was diminished.

Figure 5: Frequency of value selection across the four learning scenarios, highlighting the prominence of Accessibility, Flexibility, and Trust.

Key insights from the data include:

  • Contextual Confidentiality: Participants viewed confidentiality as a threat in data-heavy digital systems but as a promise in private teacher-facing AI dashboards.
  • Technology-Specific Concerns: Scenarios involving AI and robots triggered more concern-related values, such as Trust, Vulnerability, and Equity, compared to VR and AR scenarios.
  • Flexibility as a Universal Requirement: "Flexibility" was the only value chosen across all four distinct learning scenarios, suggesting it is a core expectation for any disruptive educational tool.

Discussion and Future Directions

Thematic analysis of participant explanations yielded 11 core themes, including Risk (control, personal data) and Group Dynamics (collaboration, peer interaction). While the study provides a robust "birds-eye view" of the impact of technology, the authors acknowledge limitations in sample size within individual countries, which prevents definitive conclusions about cultural differences in value prioritization.

Future work will focus on a deeper analysis of these "value spaces" to uncover complex patterns and translate these qualitative insights into actionable policies for developers and policymakers. The ultimate goal is to ensure that disruptive technologies are deployed in schools with a clear understanding of their ethical threats and societal responsibilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Disruptive technology has become an integral part of our lives, and it has brought about a significant transformation in the way we interact, communicate, and share information, also in the field of education. Innovation in technology needs to be based on ethics and values of the intended result. As the use of disruptive technology continues to grow, so does the need to understand and consider ethical and value dimensions. How can disruptive technology be developed and used in an ethical way for learning and teaching? What are the values the development and implementation of disruptive technology for education should take into account? How to measure and evaluate values and ethical dimensions of disruptive technology for educational purposes? Are some of the important questions to address. This workshop paper presents a method for eliciting values and ethical dimensions of learning scenarios with disruptive technologies in vocational and higher education settings and illustrates its implementation in the context of the Horizon Europe e-DIPLOMA project. The workshop method, combining value cards and learning scenarios with disruptive technologies, was implemented in seven different countries. The preliminary results of the workshops are presented. The method has the potential to draw peoples’ attention to prospective value concerns and ethical aspects necessary for understanding and acknowledging the consequence of implementing disruptive technologies in education.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{valjataga2023exploring,
  author = {Terje Väljataga and Kai Pata and Andrea Annus and Michelle Andrade Calisto and Águeda Gómez Cambronero and Elmar Eisemann and Athina Kasini and Ricardo Marroquim and Inmaculada Remolar and László Szécsi and Amir Zaidi and Rubén García-Vidal},
  title = {{Exploring Value and Ethical Dimensions of Disruptive Technologies for Learning and Teaching}},
  booktitle = {"MIS4TEL (Workshops)},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-42134-1\_11},
}
Figure