Abstract
In virtual reality (VR) education, especially in creative fields like film production, avatar design and narrative style extend beyond appearance and aesthetics. This study explores how the interaction between avatar gender, the dominant narrative actor's gender, and the learner's gender influences film production learning in VR, focusing on gaze dynamics and gender perspectives. Using a 2x2x2 experimental design, 48 participants operated avatars of different genders and interacted with male or female-dominant narratives. The results show that the consistency between the avatar and gender affects presence, and learners' control over the avatar is also influenced by gender matching. Learners using avatars of the opposite gender reported stronger control, suggesting gender incongruity prompted more focus on the avatar. Additionally, female participants with female avatars were more likely to adopt a "female gaze," favoring soft lighting and emotional shots, while male participants with male avatars were more likely to adopt a "male gaze," choosing dynamic shots and high contrast. When male participants used female avatars, they favored "female gaze," while female participants with male avatars focused on "male gaze". These findings advance our understanding of how avatar design and narrative style in VR-based education influence creativity and the cultivation of gender perspectives, and they offer insights for developing more inclusive and diverse VR teaching tools going forward.
Introduction
Virtual Reality (VR) is increasingly utilized to teach technical skills such as cinematography and lighting. However, the impact of the virtual environment—specifically the user's avatar—on their creative "voice" remains under-explored. In film theory, the "male gaze" typically refers to a perspective that objectifies subjects, focusing on action and physique, whereas the "female gaze" emphasizes emotional intimacy and reciprocity. This research investigates whether the Proteus Effect—where a user's behavior shifts to match their avatar's characteristics—can serve as a pedagogical tool to help students recognize and overcome narrative biases.
Methods
The researchers developed Film DanceStudio, a VR environment built in Unity where users control cameras and lighting to film a 45-second dance sequence. The study employed a $2 \times 2 \times 2$ factorial experimental design with 48 participants, varying user gender, avatar gender, and narrative actor gender (male-led vs. female-led sequences). Participants completed a 15-minute tutorial followed by a 12-minute filming task. The resulting films were evaluated by industry experts who coded shots for "Male Gaze" (e.g., high contrast, wide action) versus "Female Gaze" (e.g., soft lighting, facial close-ups).
Key Insights and Results
Productive Discomfort and Presence
Contrary to the assumption that matching avatars increase immersion, this study found that gender-incongruent avatars (e.g., a male user in a female avatar) led to a heightened sense of presence and self-awareness. Participants reported observing their movements more closely because the virtual body felt distinct from their own, resulting in more deliberate creative choices. Statistical analysis confirmed a significant interaction between user and avatar gender on self-presence ($p = 0.049$).
The Proteus Effect in Cinematic Style
The Proteus Effect was evident in the participants' artistic output. Male students using female avatars were significantly more likely to adopt "female gaze" techniques, such as focusing on emotional nuances and employing soft lighting. Conversely, the "narrative lead" also significantly influenced style; a narrative led by the opposite gender could shift a user's filming style even when using a gender-matched avatar.
Cinematic Style Shifts
- Male User/Male Avatar/Male Narrative: Produced works almost exclusively classified as "Male Gaze."
- Male User/Male Avatar/Female Narrative: More than half of the works shifted toward a "Female Gaze" despite the male identity.
- Female User/Female Avatar/Female Narrative: Primarily produced "Female Gaze" content.
Expert validation achieved substantial inter-coder agreement ($\kappa = 0.78$), confirming that these shifts in lighting and framing were objectively observable.
Discussion and Future Work
The findings suggest that VR can serve as a "perspective playground," allowing students to systematically swap identities and narrative roles to dismantle unconscious biases. However, the study is limited by a small sample size ($N=48$) and a binary focus on gender. Future research should include non-binary and androgynous avatars and explore collaborative VR environments where multiple users must negotiate creative decisions across different identities.
Summary updated