Exploring Asymmetric Roles in Mixed-Ability Gaming

David Gonçalves, André Rodrigues, Mike Richardson, Alexandra A de Sousa, Michael Proulx, Tiago Guerreiro

Abstract

This research investigates how "asymmetric roles"—where players have fundamentally different tasks and information—can create engaging gaming experiences for mixed-visual-ability pairs. By designing interdependent roles that rely on different sensory strengths (visual vs. auditory) rather than simplifying a single gameplay loop, the researchers achieved "equity through inequality," fostering genuine collaboration and social inclusion.

Introduction: The Accessibility Gap

The digital gaming landscape is largely segregated by ability. Sighted players enjoy high-fidelity visual games, while blind players are often restricted to audio-only experiences. Current attempts at "accessible" gaming often fall into two traps:

  1. Simplification: The game is made so easy that it loses its challenge and appeal for sighted players.
  2. The "Assistant" Dynamic: The blind player is relegated to a secondary role where they feel "helped" rather than being a vital contributor.

The authors tackle the challenge of creating mixed-ability play that is balanced, challenging, and socially equitable. They ask: Can we design a game where a blind player and a sighted player are equally necessary to succeed, even if they are playing completely different versions of the same game?

Design Framework: Equity Through Inequality

The researchers employed an ability-based asymmetric design approach. Instead of making one interface accessible to everyone, they created two distinct roles for each game. This approach is grounded in five core concepts designed to ensure a balanced and engaging experience for both players.

Core design concepts for mixed-ability asymmetric play.

Game Implementation and Methods

Two game prototypes were developed to test these principles:

  • Rescue: Under Pressure (Submarine Game): The Pilot (Visual) moves the craft but can only see a small area. The Engineer (Auditory) uses a binaural soundscape (sonar) to detect treasure and monsters across the whole map.
  • Rescue: Mayday (Aircraft Game): The roles are flipped. The Pilot (Auditory) flies using an audio compass and danger sensors, while the Engineer (Visual) manages a map and air traffic control.
Visual interfaces for the submarine (A, C) and aircraft (B, D) game prototypes.

The team evaluated these games through a remote study with 13 mixed-visual-ability pairs (26 individuals total). Participants ranged from ages 16 to 53 and included 8 totally blind and 5 near-totally blind individuals. The study used "non-stranger" pairs (friends or family) to focus specifically on the impact of the game mechanics on social interaction.

Key Insights

  • Equity vs. Equality: Making a game equal (the same for everyone) often makes it inaccessible or boring. By making the game unequal by design, the authors created an equitable experience where both players felt like high-value contributors.
  • Disability Blurring: Sighted participants noted that during intense gameplay, they "forgot" they were playing with a visually impaired partner. The asymmetry shifted the focus from "disability" to "specialized role."
  • The Power of Information Gaps: By giving the blind player information that the sighted player lacked (e.g., sonar data), the blind player became the "expert" or "navigator," effectively dismantling traditional power hierarchies in assistive technology.
  • Challenge as a Feature: Participants gave the lowest scores to the statement "I was good at playing." In a research context, this is a success—it proves the games were legitimately difficult and required mastery, avoiding the "patronizingly easy" trap.

Results and Discussion

  • High Engagement: The submarine game was particularly successful, with an average UPEQ engagement score of 3.95/5.
  • Social Bonding: 19 out of 26 participants preferred the submarine game, citing the "intuitive" feel of the collaboration.
  • Competence and Autonomy: Quantitative data showed no significant difference in perceived competence between sighted and blind players, meaning the roles were well-balanced in terms of difficulty.
  • Qualitative Success: Participants reported that the games provided a rare opportunity to "share an adventure without limitations," highlighting the potential for these designs to reduce social isolation.

Conclusion and Future Work

While successful, the prototypes faced challenges such as task repetitiveness and the requirement for a sighted partner. Future work should explore adapting these asymmetric roles for two blind players or solo play with AI. The authors suggest applying this "ability-based design" to other areas, such as motor or cognitive impairments, to move the industry toward a more inclusive "Social Model" of gaming.

Summary updated

Abstract

The landscape of digital games is segregated by player ability. For example, sighted players have a multitude of highly visual games at their disposal, while blind players may choose from a variety of audio games. Attempts at improving cross-ability access to any of those are often limited in the experience they provide, or disregard multiplayer experiences.We explore ability-based asymmetric roles as a design approach to create engaging and challenging mixed-ability play. Our team designed and developed two collaborative testbed games exploring asymmetric interdependent roles. In a remote study with 13 mixed-visual-ability pairs we assessed how roles afected perceptions of engagement, competence, and autonomy, using a mixed-methods approach. The games provided an engaging and challenging experience, in which diferences in visual ability were not limiting. Our results underline how experiences unequal by design can give rise to an equitable joint experience.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{goncalves2021exploring,
  author = {David Gonçalves and André Rodrigues and Mike Richardson and Alexandra A de Sousa and Michael Proulx and Tiago Guerreiro},
  title = {{Exploring Asymmetric Roles in Mixed-Ability Gaming}},
  booktitle = {CHI - Proceedings of the CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=83JUB5lRzf},
}
Figure