Exploiting Trust Degree for Multiple-Antenna User Cooperation

Mingxiong Zhao, Jong Yeol Ryu, Jemin Lee, Tony Q. S. Quek, Suili Feng

Abstract

In cooperative wireless communications, mobile users act as relays for one another to improve reliability and speed. However, most existing research assumes users are "perfectly altruistic," always willing to spend their resources to help neighbors. This paper introduces a framework that accounts for the "trust degree" ($\alpha$)—the probability that a mobile user will actually act as a relay. By jointly optimizing beamforming and power allocation across SISO, MISO, SIMO, and MIMO configurations, the authors demonstrate how social trustworthiness can be mathematically integrated into physical-layer signal processing to maximize expected data rates while strictly guaranteeing Quality of Service (QoS) for the helper node.

Introduction

Traditional cooperative communication models often ignore the social reality of mobile users, who may be selfish (to save battery) or malicious. The challenge addressed here is the gap between social behavior and physical-layer engineering. The authors define a trust degree $\alpha$ to quantify the likelihood of cooperation. The goal is to design transmission strategies that maximize the expected data rate for a user needing help, while ensuring that the "helper" user still meets their own QoS requirements.

System Model and Transmission Protocol

The proposed framework utilizes a two-slot transmission protocol to facilitate cooperation between two user pairs. As illustrated in the system model, the transmission is divided into two distinct phases.

The two-slot cooperative transmission protocol: (a) Source transmission in time slot $t_1$ with leakage to the potential relay; (b) Relay transmission in time slot $t_2$ splitting power between its own message and the forwarded message.

In the first time slot ($t_1$), the source user ($Tu_1$) transmits its message to its destination ($Ru_1$). During this phase, the potential helper ($Tu_2$) remains silent but may receive a "leakage signal" from $Tu_1$. In the second time slot ($t_2$), $Tu_1$ remains silent. If $Tu_2$ chooses to cooperate (with probability $\alpha$), it acts as a relay, splitting its transmission power: a fraction $1-\beta$ is used for its own message to $Ru_2$, while a fraction $\beta$ is used to forward $Tu_1$'s message to $Ru_1$.

Optimization Across Antenna Configurations

The researchers analyze four primary antenna configurations to determine optimal strategies:

  1. SISO (Single-Input Single-Output): The study derives the optimal power allocation for the helper node to balance relaying and its own transmission.
  2. MISO (Multiple-Input Single-Output): The authors prove that the optimal beamformer at the source is a linear combination of the direct channel and the relay channel, with weights optimized based on the trust degree.
  3. SIMO (Single-Input Multiple-Output): Due to the multiple antennas at the helper, the optimization problem becomes non-convex. The authors employ Semidefinite Relaxation (SDR) and a Block Coordinate Update (BCU) method to iteratively find the best beamforming vectors.
  4. MIMO (Multiple-Input Multiple-Output): This configuration combines insights from MISO and SIMO, using structured beamformer design and iterative algorithms to manage the complexity of multiple antennas at both ends.

A critical component of this methodology is Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC). If the helper's receiver can successfully decode the other user's message, it can "subtract" that interference, allowing more power to be allocated to cooperation without violating its own QoS.

Key Insights and Results

  • Trust-Aware Beamforming: The direction of a transmitter's beam shifts based on trust. High trust degrees encourage the source to steer its beam toward the relay to exploit cooperative gain, while low trust degrees necessitate steering toward the destination to ensure a baseline rate through direct transmission.
  • Performance Gains: Across all antenna configurations, the proposed trust-based strategies significantly outperformed "no cooperation" and non-optimized schemes. The expected achievable rate increases almost linearly with the trust degree $\alpha$.
  • MIMO Superiority: MIMO systems showed the highest resilience to low trust degrees. The extra degrees of freedom provided by multiple antennas allowed for superior interference management even when cooperation was unlikely.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research successfully bridges the gap between social trust and physical-layer optimization. While the current model assumes a static trust degree and perfect Channel State Information (CSI), it provides a robust foundation for future work. Future iterations may explore dynamic trust estimation and the complexities of multi-user networks with intricate social graphs.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhao2017exploiting,
  author = {Mingxiong Zhao and Jong Yeol Ryu and Jemin Lee and Tony Q. S. Quek and Suili Feng},
  title = {{Exploiting Trust Degree for Multiple-Antenna User Cooperation}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2017.2703871},
}
Figure