Exploiting Semantic Contextualization for Interpretation of Human Activity in Videos

Sathyanarayanan N. Aakur, Fillipe D. M. de Souza, Sudeep Sarkar

Abstract

This paper introduces a framework for video interpretation that leverages ConceptNet, a commonsense knowledge base, to move beyond simple label detection. By modeling activity understanding as an energy minimization problem within Grenander’s Pattern Theory, the system infers complex semantic relationships and fills in missing contextual information, significantly reducing the need for massive, manually annotated datasets.

Introduction

While deep learning has made significant strides in identifying objects and actions in videos, it often fails to grasp the underlying semantic structure of an event. Most current models operate as "black boxes," requiring millions of labeled examples to learn basic real-world logic—such as the fact that eggs are typically poured into pans or bowls rather than onto trees. This research addresses three major hurdles: the "data hunger" of traditional models, the difficulty of handling "long tail" rare activities, and the "semantic gap" between a list of labels and a coherent, human-understandable story.

Methodology

The proposed framework is grounded in Grenander’s Pattern Theory, which treats concepts (actions and objects) as "generators" connected by "bonds" or semantic relationships.

The proposed framework for video interpretation using ConceptNet and energy-based inference.

The interpretation process follows several key steps:

  1. Feature Extraction and Concept Proposal: Initial detections of actions and objects provide "grounded" generators based on visual evidence.
  2. ConceptNet Integration: The system queries ConceptNet—a graph of over 3 million real-world facts—to find "contextualization cues." For instance, if an "egg" and "pouring" are detected, ConceptNet helps infer a "plate" or "bowl" as a likely context.
  3. Energy Minimization: The model employs a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling process to find the most "stable" interpretation. It seeks a configuration that balances the confidence of visual detectors with the semantic logic provided by the knowledge base.
  4. Template-Based Output: To communicate its findings, the system maps the resulting semantic graph into a natural language template to generate captions.

Experimental Evaluation

The authors evaluated their approach on three diverse benchmarks: Charades (daily indoor activities), Microsoft Visual Description (MSVD) (captioning quality), and Breakfast Actions (kitchen activities).

On the Charades dataset, the "PT + ConceptNet" approach achieved a 32.56% mAP (Mean Average Precision), significantly outperforming state-of-the-art LSTM-based models (17.80%) and Asynchronous Temporal Fields (22.40%). On MSVD, the system produced competitive results with a 42.98% BLEU score, proving that a knowledge-based approach can rival end-to-end neural networks that require much more training data.

Key Insights

A primary finding of this research is the effectiveness of common sense as a "correction" mechanism. The model can arrive at a correct interpretation even when initial machine-learning classifiers are noisy or incorrect. For example, if a classifier mistakenly labels a "teabag" and "stirring," contextual cues from ConceptNet can steer the final interpretation toward the correct "add" action.

Semantic relationships from ConceptNet (a) and an example inferred semantic graph (b).

Furthermore, the model can transcend its training vocabulary by using the external knowledge base to infer "ungrounded" concepts. It also demonstrates remarkable resilience to class imbalance, maintaining stable performance across categories regardless of the number of training samples available.

Conclusion

While the current system relies on fixed templates for language generation and is dependent on the quality of initial detections, it provides a robust foundation for complex reasoning tasks. Future work will focus on increasing linguistic variety and exploring the use of these semantic graphs for tasks like Visual Question Answering (VQA), where reasoning about the "why" behind an activity is essential.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{aakur2017exploiting,
  author = {Sathyanarayanan N. Aakur and Fillipe D. M. de Souza and Sudeep Sarkar},
  title = {{Exploiting Semantic Contextualization for Interpretation of Human Activity in Videos}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/CVF Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure