Experimenting with robotic intra-logistics domains

Martin Gebser, Philipp Obermeier, Thomas Otto, Torsten Schaub, Orkunt Sabuncu, Van Nguyen, Tran Cao Son

TL;DR

This paper introduces asprilo, a novel framework for benchmarking and experimenting with Answer Set Programming (ASP) approaches in complex, dynamic domains, specifically robotic intra-logistics. It provides a versatile generator, checker, and visualizer to create and analyze realistic scenarios, aiming to bridge the gap between current ASP capabilities and real-world applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors identify a critical bottleneck in the advancement of Answer Set Programming (ASP): the lack of complex, realistic benchmark scenarios. While ASP has made significant strides in performance and applications, existing benchmarks are often too simplistic, failing to capture the multifaceted nature of real-world problems like robotic intra-logistics. This domain, crucial for the "fourth industrial revolution," involves intricate challenges such as multi-agent planning, reasoning about actions, resources, and strategies. Without suitable benchmarks, it's difficult to effectively evaluate and compare different ASP techniques for scalability and effectiveness in these demanding environments.

Methods

The core of the asprilo framework is its comprehensive suite of tools:

  • Benchmark Generator: This component, implemented using multi-shot ASP and controlled by Python, creates diverse and scalable benchmark instances. It allows for configurable layouts, robot and shelf placements, order complexities, and other parameters, generating instances in a standardized object-attribute-value format.
  • Solution Checker: A modular ASP-based checker verifies the correctness of proposed solutions (plans) against specific scenario constraints, providing diagnostic feedback on violations.
  • Visualizer: This tool offers animation of solution candidates, allowing users to inspect plan execution step-by-step. It also includes a graphical scenario editor for creating and modifying benchmark layouts, making it easier to design complex environments.
  • Reference Encodings: The framework provides various ASP encodings for different asprilo domains, illustrating different ASP techniques and serving as starting points for further development.

The paper also explores different ASP encodings for representing grid positions (e.g., separate X/Y coordinates vs. combined coordinates) and their impact on performance.

Datasets

The paper introduces the asprilo framework itself as a source of benchmark datasets. It defines several problem domains (A, B, C, M, and combinations like AM, BM, CM) that abstract different aspects of robotic intra-logistics. These domains vary in complexity, from simple multi-agent pathfinding (M) to full-fledged delivery scenarios with product quantities (A). The benchmark generator can produce a wide variety of instances within these domains, with configurable sizes and complexities. The paper also provides links to experimental results and encodings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Need for Realistic Benchmarks: The paper strongly argues that the lack of complex, real-world-inspired benchmarks is a major impediment to ASP's adoption in industry. asprilo aims to fill this gap.
  • Intra-logistics as a Rich Testbed: The chosen domain of robotic intra-logistics is ideal because it naturally integrates multiple challenging AI problems (planning, reasoning, multi-agent coordination) within a single, coherent framework.
  • Modularity and Extensibility are Key: The design of asprilo emphasizes modularity (generator, checker, visualizer) and extensibility, allowing for the addition of new scenarios, encodings, and features.
  • Visualisation is Crucial for Debugging: The visualizer's animation capabilities are highlighted as indispensable for understanding and debugging complex plans, especially in dynamic, multi-agent scenarios.
  • Encoding Choices Matter: The experimental evaluation shows that different ASP encodings (especially for representing spatial information) can have a significant impact on performance, even for seemingly similar problems.

Key Results

The experimental evaluation, primarily on domain M and its extensions, revealed several key findings:

  • Encoding Impact: For simpler domains like M, a direct ASP encoding (using clingo) often outperformed encodings that split positional coordinates or used more complex constraint handling (clingcon, clingo[DL]).
  • Domain Complexity: As domains become more complex (moving from M to CM, BM, AM), the performance differences between encodings become more pronounced, with clingcon often showing advantages.
  • Task Assignment Improves Scalability: Decoupling task assignment from pathfinding significantly improved scalability, reducing the number of constraints and search space, especially for larger instances. This is a crucial insight for tackling real-world problems.
  • Timeouts are Common: For larger and more complex instances, timeouts (even at 1800s) were frequent, underscoring the computational challenges.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Current Focus: The current asprilo framework primarily focuses on static scenarios (orders are given initially). The authors acknowledge that real-world systems often deal with dynamic order arrivals.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest several promising directions:
  • Online ASP: Investigating online versions of the problem domains, where tasks arrive over time, leveraging multi-shot ASP.
  • Preferences and Uncertainty: Incorporating preferences, different types of orders, and uncertainty into the scenarios.
  • More Complex Scenarios: Extending the framework to include features like charging stations, supply management, and more sophisticated robot behaviors.
  • Integration with Other Solvers: Connecting the visualizer with other solving components over the network.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce the asprilo [1] framework to facilitate experimental studies of approaches addressing complex dynamic applications. For this purpose, we have chosen the domain of robotic intra-logistics. This domain is not only highly relevant in the context of today's fourth industrial revolution but it moreover combines a multitude of challenging issues within a single uniform framework. This includes multi-agent planning, reasoning about action, change, resources, strategies, etc. In return, asprilo allows users to study alternative solutions as regards effectiveness and scalability. Although asprilo relies on Answer Set Programming and Python, it is readily usable by any system complying with its fact-oriented interface format. This makes it attractive for benchmarking and teaching well beyond logic programming. More precisely, asprilo consists of a versatile benchmark generator, solution checker and visualizer as well as a bunch of reference encodings featuring various ASP techniques. Importantly, the visualizer's animation capabilities are indispensable for complex scenarios like intra-logistics in order to inspect valid as well as invalid solution candidates. Also, it allows for graphically editing benchmark layouts that can be used as a basis for generating benchmark suites. [1] asprilo stands for Answer Set Programming for robotic intra-logistics
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gebser2018experimenting,
  author = {Martin Gebser and Philipp Obermeier and Thomas Otto and Torsten Schaub and Orkunt Sabuncu and Van Nguyen and Tran Cao Son},
  title = {{Experimenting with robotic intra-logistics domains}},
  booktitle = {Theory Pract. Log. Program},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=8iBccyWPUtyJ},
}
Figure