Experimental Demonstration of Delay-Bounded Wireless Network Based on Precise Time Synchronization

H. Tanaka, Yusuke Yamasaki, Satoshi Yasuda, Nobuyasu Shiga, Kenichi Takizawa, Nicolas Chauvet, Ryoichi Horisaki, Makoto Naruse

TL;DR

This paper presents the first experimental demonstration of CSMA/AP, a novel wireless MAC protocol designed for ultra-reliable, low-latency communications. By leveraging precise time synchronization via Wireless Two-Way Interferometry (Wi-Wi), CSMA/AP successfully achieves delay-bounded communication, even in dynamic and mobile environments, paving the way for critical applications in 5G and beyond.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing demand for low-latency and highly reliable wireless communication, particularly for critical applications like autonomous systems, remote surgery, and industrial automation (often categorized under URLLC in 5G and beyond), presents a significant challenge. Existing wireless MAC protocols, such as CSMA/CA, rely on probabilistic methods like random back-off to avoid collisions. While effective in low-traffic scenarios, these methods lead to unpredictable delays, especially under high load, making them unsuitable for applications requiring strict, deterministic latency guarantees. Other deterministic approaches often sacrifice throughput or scalability. This paper addresses the need for a wireless communication protocol that can guarantee an upper bound on communication delay, ensuring predictability and reliability.

Methods

The core of this work is the experimental validation of the CSMA/AP (Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Arbitration Point) protocol. CSMA/AP achieves its delay-bounded property by exploiting precise time synchronization among all network nodes.

  • CSMA/AP Protocol: Instead of random back-offs, CSMA/AP assigns periodic "Arbitration Points" (APs) to each terminal. During its AP, a terminal senses the channel. If clear, it transmits; otherwise, it waits for its next AP. This deterministic assignment ensures that a terminal will transmit within a predictable timeframe, thus bounding the maximum delay. The paper focuses on CSMA/AP-T, which relies solely on time synchronization.
  • Wireless Two-Way Interferometry (Wi-Fi): To achieve the necessary picosecond-level time synchronization, the researchers employed Wi-Wi. This technology uses a two-way exchange of time-stamped signals and carrier phase measurements to determine relative time differences and distances between nodes. Crucially, Wi-Wi is presented as a cost-effective solution using commercially available components.
  • Software-Defined Radio (SDR): The experimental network was built using SDR terminals operating in the 2.4 GHz band for data communication, synchronized by Wi-Wi modules operating in the 920 MHz band. This flexible platform allowed for the implementation and testing of the CSMA/AP protocol.
  • Experimental Setup: A star topology was used, with one terminal acting as a base station (BS) and two others as terminal stations (STA 1 and STA 2). Experiments were conducted in an anechoic chamber to minimize external interference.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments generated their own data through controlled transmissions and measurements within the laboratory setup.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wi-Wi is the critical enabler: The experiments unequivocally demonstrated that CSMA/AP cannot function without precise time synchronization. When Wi-Wi synchronization was disabled, communication performance degraded significantly, highlighting the protocol's fundamental reliance on this technology.
  • Mobility is accommodated: A key finding is that CSMA/AP, powered by Wi-Wi, can successfully handle mobile terminals. The system maintained reliable communication even when STA 1 moved along linear and circular paths, showcasing its adaptability to dynamic environments, a significant advantage over wired systems.
  • Synchronization stability matters more than individual clock stability: The Allan deviation analysis showed that while rubidium clocks are individually stable, synchronized Wi-Wi modules outperformed asynchronous rubidium clocks in terms of synchronization stability over longer timescales. This emphasizes that for CSMA/AP, the relative stability between nodes is paramount.
  • Wi-Wi's distance measurement capability is valuable: Beyond time synchronization, Wi-Wi also provides inter-device distance information. This was shown to be useful for understanding environmental factors (like radio wave reflection) and potentially for more advanced CSMA/AP variants (like CSMA/AP-TS).

Key Results

  • Successful delay-bounded communication: CSMA/AP was successfully implemented and demonstrated to provide collision-free and delay-bounded communication in a star-topology wireless network.
  • Robustness to mobility: The system maintained reliable communication (BER below 10⁻⁵) with a moving terminal, even when the terminal's distance from the base station varied.
  • Impact of synchronization: Experiments showed that when Wi-Wi modules were desynchronized, significant packet transmission errors occurred, and PPS (pulse-per-second) signals became asynchronous, leading to collisions or reversed transmission orders. Synchronized operation resulted in error-free communication after an initial adjustment period.
  • Wi-Wi synchronization performance: The Allan deviation analysis indicated that synchronized Wi-Wi modules achieved better synchronization stability than asynchronous rubidium clocks for timescales longer than 1 second.
  • Parameter sensitivity: The study identified that AP duration and AP offset parameters needed to be within a certain range (e.g., 5-10 µs) for reliable communication, with BER below 10⁻⁵.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited packet rate: The current SDR implementation limits the packet rate, which is a technical issue that needs improvement to support a larger number of terminals. This is identified as a key future technological target.
  • CSMA/AP-TS requires further study: The paper focused on CSMA/AP-T. The more advanced CSMA/AP-TS variant, which utilizes inter-terminal distance information, requires further experimental examination.
  • Autonomous user management: Adding and removing users autonomously from the network is another fundamental issue for future work.
  • Radio wave reflection: The study noted that radio wave reflections (particularly from the floor) could affect Wi-Wi's distance measurement accuracy and synchronization, leading to errors. This suggests a need for improved signal processing or environmental mitigation techniques.
  • Asynchronous PPS signals: In some desynchronized scenarios, PPS signals became asynchronous, leading to issues. The paper mentions that the reason for this phenomenon in the curved locus mobility experiment was not specified and will be examined in future studies.
  • Speed limit of mobile stations: The current Wi-Wi implementation has a speed limit of approximately 6 km/h, suitable for pedestrians. Higher speeds might require further advancements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low latency and reliable information transfer are highly demanded in fifth generation (5G) and beyond 5G wireless communications. A novel delay-bounded wireless media access control (MAC) protocol called Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Arbitration Point (CSMA/AP) was established to strictly ensure the upper boundary of communication delay. CSMA/AP enables collision-free and delay-bounded communications with a simple arbitration mechanism exploiting the precise time synchronization achieved by Wireless Two-Way Interferometry (Wi-Wi). Experimental demonstration and proving the feasibility in wireless environments are among the most critical steps before any further discussion of CSMA/AP and extension to various applications can take in place. In this work described in this paper, we experimentally demonstrated the fundamental principles of CSMA/AP by constructing a star-topology wireless network using software-defined radio terminals combined with precise time synchronization devices. We show that CSMA/AP was successfully operated, even with dynamic changes of the spatial position of the terminal or the capability to accommodate mobility, thanks to the real-time adaption to the dynamically changing environment by Wi-Wi. We also experimentally confirmed that the proposed CSMA/AP principle cannot be executed without Wi-Wi, which validates the importance of precise time synchronization. This study paves the way toward realizing delay-bounded wireless communications for future low-latency and highly reliable critical applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tanaka2022experimental,
  author = {H. Tanaka and Yusuke Yamasaki and Satoshi Yasuda and Nobuyasu Shiga and Kenichi Takizawa and Nicolas Chauvet and Ryoichi Horisaki and Makoto Naruse},
  title = {{Experimental Demonstration of Delay-Bounded Wireless Network Based on Precise Time Synchronization}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2022.3203997},
}
Figure