Experimental and Explicit FE Studies on Flexural Behavior of Superposed Slabs

Qi Ye, Ping Zhang, Ke Ye, Wei Wang, Zeshen Li, Yueqing Gao, Tianyu Xie, Chaofeng LiangBuildings 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the flexural performance of concrete superposed slabs made with recycled brick and cement waste powders as partial cement replacements. Both experimental testing and explicit finite element (FE) simulations show that these recycled materials can produce slabs with performance comparable to conventional concrete, with one specific mixture even achieving nearly identical yield and ultimate capacities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction industry generates significant amounts of waste, including bricks and cement blocks. This paper addresses the challenge of sustainably managing this waste by exploring its use as a partial replacement for cement and fly ash in concrete production. Specifically, it focuses on recycled brick powder (PRB) and calcined recycled slurry powder (PCRS) to create concrete with favorable engineering properties. The research aims to understand the flexural behavior of superposed slabs made with this novel concrete, a common structural element in prefabricated construction, and to validate the use of explicit FE simulations for their analysis.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach: experimental testing and numerical simulation.

Experimental: * Material Preparation: Five different concrete mixtures were prepared, varying the proportions of PRB and PCRS as partial replacements for cement or fly ash. A control mixture using conventional concrete was also prepared. * Material Characterization: Uniaxial monotonic compression tests were conducted on concrete specimens to obtain stress-strain curves, which were then fitted to a constitutive model. * Slab Fabrication: Five physical superposed slabs were cast, each using one of the prepared concrete mixtures. * Flexural Testing: The slabs were subjected to a four-point bending test under a load-displacement hybrid control scheme to determine their load-deflection behavior, cracking load, yield load, and ultimate load.

Numerical Simulation: * FE Model Development: Three-dimensional finite element (FE) models of the superposed slabs were created using Abaqus software. The models incorporated the geometric dimensions and reinforcement configurations from the experimental slabs. * Constitutive Models: The concrete was modeled using a concrete damage plasticity (CDP) model, which accounts for material behaviors like strain hardening, strain softening, and unilateral effects. Rebar was modeled using an elastic-perfectly plastic model, and steel pads were treated as linear elastic. * Explicit FE Solver: An explicit FE solver was utilized to handle the strain-softening behavior of concrete, which can cause convergence issues with traditional implicit solvers. * Validation: The FE model's predictions were compared against the experimental results to validate its accuracy.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as distinct datasets. The study generated its own experimental data from the fabricated concrete specimens and slabs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Waste Valorization: PRB and PCRS can effectively replace cement and fly ash, contributing to sustainable construction practices and reducing carbon emissions.
  • Comparable Performance: Concrete incorporating PRB/PCRS exhibited flexural performance comparable to conventional concrete, suggesting these recycled materials are viable for structural applications.
  • Optimal Mixture: A specific mixture (1:1 PRB and PCRS replacing fly ash) showed the highest yield and ultimate bearing capacities among the recycled concrete slabs, closely matching the conventional concrete slab.
  • Explicit FE Simulation Efficacy: The explicit FE method proved to be a robust and accurate tool for simulating the complex flexural behavior of these slabs, including crack evolution and load-displacement responses.
  • Energy Time-History Insights: The simulation-based energy time-history curves provided valuable insights into the progression of cracking and failure mechanisms within the slabs.

Key Results

  • Flexural Performance: The flexural performance of PRB/PCRS recycled micro-powder concrete slabs was comparable to conventional concrete.
  • Highest Capacity Mixture: The slab with a 1:1 mixture of PRB and PCRS replacing fly ash achieved 99.3% of the conventional concrete slab's yield load and 98.4% of its ultimate load.
  • FE Model Accuracy: The FE simulations accurately predicted flexural performance, with maximum deviations of 8.9% for yield load and 6.5% for ultimate load compared to experimental results.
  • Crack Evolution: The simulation successfully captured the evolution of cracks and crushing zones, aligning with physical observations.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study acknowledges that the estimation of the cracking load (Fcr) using an empirical formula might lead to larger deviations compared to yield (Fy) and ultimate (Fu) loads. * The use of a hypothetical yet reasonable value for a material coefficient in the CDP model for concrete might introduce some deviation in the simulation results, particularly after the yield point. * The simulation's elevated loading rate might have contributed to differences in longitudinal crack patterns compared to physical tests.

Future Work: * Investigate the fire resistance and thermo-mechanical behavior of PRB/PCRS slabs under elevated temperatures. * Conduct parametric analyses on the flexural behavior of PRB/PCRS slabs by varying admixture ratios and replacement levels. * Develop more accurate constitutive models for PRB/PCRS concrete, potentially by refining the tensile behavior and constitutive parameters. * Experimentally determine the tensile strength (Ot) of PRB/PCRS concrete to improve the accuracy of cracking load predictions. * Explore the sensitivity of PRB/PCRS material properties to admixture dosage and composition. * Examine the flexural performance of larger-scale PRB/PCRS structural elements and their fire resistance and fatigue behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explores the use of recycled brick powder (PRB), derived from waste bricks, and calcined recycled slurry powder (PCRS), sourced from waste cement blocks, as partial replacements for cement and fly ash in concrete. These materials can be utilized to produce concrete with favorable engineering properties. Five concrete mixtures with varying PRB/PCRS proportions were prepared. Uniaxial monotonic compression tests were conducted to generate stress-strain curves for each mixture. Corresponding physical superposed slabs were fabricated, and finite element (FE) models were developed for each slab. Both physical testing and explicit FE simulations were performed to evaluate the flexural performance of the slabs. The results demonstrated that the flexural performance of the PRB/PCRS recycled micro-powder concrete slabs was comparable to that of conventional concrete slabs. Notably, the slab incorporating a 1:1 mixture of PRB and PCRS instead of fly ash exhibited the highest yield and ultimate bearing capacities, reaching 99.3% and 98.4% of those of the conventional concrete slab, respectively. The FE simulations accurately predicted the flexural performance, with maximum deviations of 8.9% for the yield load and 6.5% for the ultimate load. Additionally, the simulation-based energy time-history curve provides valuable insights into the progression of slab cracking. This study contributes to the advancement of research on the engineering and mechanical performance of concrete members incorporated with PRB/PCRS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ye2025experimental,
  author = {Qi Ye and Ping Zhang and Ke Ye and Wei Wang and Zeshen Li and Yueqing Gao and Tianyu Xie and Chaofeng Liang},
  title = {{Experimental and Explicit FE Studies on Flexural Behavior of Superposed Slabs}},
  booktitle = {Buildings},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/buildings15101758},
}
Figure