Exhaustive Search of Ligand Binding Pathways via Volume-Based Metadynamics

Riccardo Capelli, Paolo Carloni, Michele Parrinello

Abstract

Determining the complete set of ligands' binding/unbinding pathways is important for drug discovery and to rationally interpret mutation data. Here we have developed a metadynamics-based technique that addressed this issue and allows estimating affinities in the presence of multiple escape pathways. Our approach is shown on a Lysozyme T4 variant in complex with the benzene molecule. The calculated binding free energy is in agreement with experimental data. Remarkably, not only we were able to find all the previously identified ligand binding pathways, but also we uncovered 3 new ones. This results were obtained at a small computational cost, making this approach valuable for practical applications, such as screening of small compounds libraries.

Introduction

In drug discovery, understanding the kinetics of ligand binding—specifically how a molecule enters and exits a protein's binding pocket—is as crucial as determining its final binding affinity. Standard Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations often fail to capture these "rare events" due to the long timescales involved. While enhanced sampling methods like Funnel Metadynamics have been developed, they often require a pre-defined pathway, potentially missing alternative "back-door" or "side-window" routes in flexible proteins. This study introduces a volume-based metadynamics approach designed to exhaustively map all possible binding pathways without prior knowledge of the protein's exit points.

Methodology

The researchers employed Well-Tempered Metadynamics (WT-MetaD), a method that uses a computational bias to prevent the system from getting stuck in local energy minima. The core innovation is the Volume-based approach:

  • Spherical Restraint: Instead of a narrow funnel, the protein is placed within a virtual sphere. A repulsive potential at the boundary keeps the ligand in proximity to the protein, ensuring frequent interactions.
  • Collective Variables (CVs): Simple spherical coordinates (ρ, θ, φ) track the ligand's position relative to the protein's center of mass.
  • Entropic Correction: A mathematical correction is applied to the final free energy to account for the artificial spherical constraint, aligning results with standard experimental conditions.

The system studied was the L99A variant of T4 Lysozyme (T4L) in complex with benzene, simulated in explicit water using the Amber14SB force field.

Results and Discussion

The volume-based approach successfully identified eight distinct binding pathways for benzene in T4L. This is a significant improvement over previous studies, which identified between one and five pathways using various force fields and sampling techniques.

Visualization of the eight identified binding and unbinding pathways (A-H) for benzene in T4 Lysozyme.

Of the eight pathways found, three (labeled F, G, and H) were previously unknown. Pathway H is particularly noteworthy as a "one-way" entrance; the protein's side chains (VAL149 and MET102) shift after the ligand enters, effectively locking the door and forcing the ligand to exit through a different route.

The method's robustness was demonstrated by testing various sphere radii (20 to 28 Å), which yielded consistent binding energies after entropic correction. The calculated binding free energy (ΔG_b^0) of -5.4 ± 0.4 kcal/mol aligns closely with the experimental value of -5.2 ± 0.2 kcal/mol.

Comparison of the number of identified pathways and simulation parameters across different computational studies.

Conclusion

The volume-based metadynamics approach provides an efficient and exhaustive means of mapping ligand binding kinetics. By discovering three new pathways in a well-studied system like T4L-benzene at a modest computational cost, this method proves its utility for practical drug discovery applications, such as screening compound libraries for favorable residence times and binding mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Determining the complete set of ligands' binding-unbinding pathways is important for drug discovery and for rational interpretation of mutation data. Here we have developed a metadynamics-based technique that addresses this issue and allows estimating affinities in the presence of multiple escape pathways. Our approach is shown on a lysozyme T4 variant in complex with a benzene molecule. The calculated binding free energy is in agreement with experimental data. Remarkably, not only were we able to find all the previously identified ligand binding pathways, but also we identified three pathways previously not identified as such. These results were obtained at a small computational cost, making this approach valuable for practical applications, such as screening of small compound libraries.
BibTeX
@article{capelli2019exhaustive,
  author = {Riccardo Capelli and Paolo Carloni and Michele Parrinello},
  title = {{Exhaustive Search of Ligand Binding Pathways via Volume-Based Metadynamics}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpclett.9b01183},
}
Figure