Exergame Experience of Young and Old Individuals Under Different Difficulty Adjustment Methods

Oral Kaplan, Goshiro Yamamoto, Takafumi Taketomi, Alexander Plopski, Christian Sandor, Hirokazu Kato

TL;DR

This study investigates how different difficulty adjustment methods in exergames affect the "flow" experience of young and older adults. The findings reveal that older adults generally experience less flow and have different preferences for difficulty adjustments compared to younger individuals, with biofeedback-based adjustments showing promise for both groups.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Physical inactivity is a major global health concern, and exergames (games that require physical activity) have emerged as a promising tool to encourage exercise. However, a critical aspect of designing engaging exergames is optimizing their difficulty to match the player's skill level, a concept known as "difficulty adjustment." While research has explored various dynamic difficulty adjustment methods, there's a significant gap in understanding how these methods impact different age groups, particularly older adults who may have unique physical and cognitive characteristics. This paper aims to bridge this gap by comparing the exergame experience of young and older individuals under four distinct difficulty adjustment strategies.

Methods

The researchers designed a custom exergame where players control an aircraft using arm gestures. They employed a within-subject, repeated-measures experimental design, meaning each participant experienced all four difficulty adjustment methods. The four methods tested were:

  • Constant Difficulty: The difficulty remains fixed throughout the game.
  • Ramping Difficulty: The difficulty gradually increases over time.
  • Performance-Based Difficulty: The difficulty adjusts based on the player's current score and performance.
  • Biofeedback-Based Difficulty: The difficulty is dynamically adjusted based on the player's heart rate variability (HRV).

To measure the player experience, the study utilized the Flow State Scale (FSS), a well-established questionnaire that assesses nine dimensions of flow, such as challenge-skill balance, sense of control, and autotelic experience. In addition to FSS scores, in-game data (score, arm movements, heart rate, HRV) and gameplay videos were recorded. Statistical analysis, including Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE) and pairwise comparisons with Bonferroni correction, was used to analyze the data.

Datasets

The study did not use pre-existing datasets. Instead, they collected data from 29 participants (15 young, 14 old) who engaged with their custom-designed exergame.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Age Matters: The study strongly suggests that age is a significant factor influencing exergame experience and preferences for difficulty adjustments. What works for young adults may not be optimal for older adults.
  • Flow is Age-Dependent: Older individuals were less likely to experience flow compared to younger individuals, even under similar difficulty adjustment conditions. This highlights the need for age-specific design considerations.
  • Biofeedback as a Promising Universal: Biofeedback-based difficulty adjustments emerged as a potentially effective method for both age groups, leading to better play experiences.
  • Performance-Based Limitations: Performance-based adjustments, while intuitive, were found to be less effective for older adults, suggesting they might be more suitable for younger players.
  • Constant Difficulty is Generally Suboptimal: The study found that constant difficulty adjustments consistently led to lower scores across multiple flow dimensions for both age groups, underscoring the importance of dynamic adjustments.
  • Metaphorical Design: The use of aircraft marshalling gestures as in-game controls, with a metaphorical link to real-world actions, was well-received by older participants and addresses the "chocolate-covered broccoli problem" in serious game design.

Key Results

  • Flow State Scale (FSS) Scores: Older individuals generally reported lower FSS scores compared to younger individuals.
  • Difficulty Adjustment Preference: Older individuals showed a preference for ramping and biofeedback-based adjustments, while performance-based adjustments were favored by younger individuals.
  • Challenge-Skill Balance: Both difficulty adjustments and age group had a significant effect on challenge-skill balance. Older individuals reported lower scores, and constant difficulty adjustments were significantly worse than performance-based and biofeedback-based for this group.
  • Unambiguous Feedback: Biofeedback-based adjustments led to significantly higher scores for unambiguous feedback compared to other methods. There was also a significant interaction effect, with older individuals experiencing lower unambiguous feedback under constant difficulty.
  • Sense of Control: Constant difficulty adjustments significantly reduced the sense of control for both age groups. There was a significant interaction effect, with young individuals reporting lower sense of control under constant difficulty compared to performance-based and biofeedback-based.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Homogeneous Old Individual Group: The older participants were primarily from the same nationality, which could introduce bias. Future work plans to replicate the study internationally.
  • Short-Term Design: The study used a short-term, repeated-measures design, which might not fully capture long-term effects or allow participants to fully adapt to and assess all dimensions of flow. Future work aims for longer-term studies.
  • Exergame Specificity: While the designed exergame adheres to recommendations, it's acknowledged that games with more sophisticated engineering might yield different results. Future research should explore various game genres.

Future work also includes investigating high-intensity aerobic exercises and massively multiplayer online gaming applications, as well as conducting long-term studies in elderly care centers and replication studies in other countries. The authors also suggest exploring the incorporation of proprioceptive feedback to enhance body awareness and flow experience.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kaplan2018exergame,
  author = {Oral Kaplan and Goshiro Yamamoto and Takafumi Taketomi and Alexander Plopski and Christian Sandor and Hirokazu Kato},
  title = {{Exergame Experience of Young and Old Individuals Under Different Difficulty Adjustment Methods}},
  booktitle = {Comput},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ZsJNFRKw3c9},
}
Figure