Exercise is associated with younger methylome and transcriptome profiles in human skeletal muscle

Sarah Voisin, Kirsten Seale, Macsue Jacques, Shanie Landen, Nicholas R. Harvey, Larisa M. Haupt, Lyn R. Griffiths, Kevin J. Ashton, Vernon G. Coffey, Jamie‐Lee M. Thompson, Thomas M. Doering, Maléne E. Lindholm, Colum P. Walsh, Gareth W. Davison, Rachelle E Irwin, Catherine McBride, Ola Hansson, Olof Asplund, Aino Heikkinen, Päivi Piirilä, Kirsi H. Pietiläinen, Miina Ollikainen, Sara Blocquiaux, Martine Thomis, Dawn K. Coletta, Adam P. Sharples, Nir Eynon

TL;DR

This study reveals that regular exercise and higher aerobic fitness are associated with a "younger" epigenetic and gene expression profile in human skeletal muscle. By analyzing a massive dataset of muscle samples, the researchers found that exercise training can reverse age-related molecular changes, while muscle disuse accelerates them, offering new insights into how physical activity promotes healthy aging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aging is characterized by a decline in muscle mass and function, leading to various adverse health outcomes. While exercise is a known intervention to combat this decline, the precise molecular mechanisms by which it influences muscle aging at the epigenetic and transcriptomic levels in humans remain unclear. Previous studies have been limited by small sample sizes, cross-sectional designs, or a focus on specific types of exercise or age groups. This paper aims to address this gap by conducting a comprehensive, integrative meta-analysis of human skeletal muscle data to understand how cardiorespiratory fitness (CRF), exercise training, and muscle disuse impact the methylome and transcriptome across the lifespan.

Methods

The researchers employed a large-scale data mining approach, combining their own data with publicly available datasets. Key methods include:

  • Meta-analysis: They performed random-effects meta-analyses to combine data from multiple cohorts for both DNA methylation (EWAS) and mRNA expression (TWAS) to identify age-associated changes. This approach allows for robust detection of small effect sizes, common in aging research.
  • Cross-sectional and Longitudinal Analysis: They tested associations between age-related molecular profiles and cardiorespiratory fitness (measured by VO2max) in a cross-sectional manner. For exercise training and muscle disuse, they utilized longitudinal interventional data.
  • Over-representation Analysis (ORA): This technique was used to identify biological pathways and human phenotypes that were significantly enriched among the age-related differentially methylated positions (DMPs) and differentially expressed genes (DEGs).
  • Multi-contrast Enrichment Analysis: This advanced method was used to integrate the effects of age, CRF, exercise training, and muscle disuse on transcriptomic profiles, allowing for a direct comparison of their impacts.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): PCA was used to visualize how individuals cluster based on their VO2max levels in relation to age-related molecular profiles.

Datasets

The study utilized a substantial collection of human skeletal muscle datasets:

  • DNA Methylation (DNAm): 1251 samples from 16 independent cohorts were used for age-related DNAm analysis.
  • mRNA Expression: 1925 samples from 21 independent cohorts were used for age-related mRNA expression analysis.
  • Interventional Studies: Data from six independent exercise training interventions (401 samples) and two meta-analyses of exercise training and muscle disuse were incorporated.
  • VO2max Data: Datasets with baseline VO2max measurements were used for cross-sectional analyses, including 439 samples for DNAm and 354 samples for mRNA expression.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather leverages existing, large-scale public repositories and collaborator data to perform a powerful meta-analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fitness as a Fountain of Youth (Epigenetically): The most striking insight is that higher aerobic fitness is directly linked to a "younger" molecular profile in skeletal muscle, both at the epigenetic (DNA methylation) and transcriptomic (gene expression) levels. This suggests that fitness isn't just about performance but also about maintaining cellular youth.
  • Exercise as a Reversal Agent: Exercise training doesn't just prevent aging; it actively shifts muscle molecular profiles towards a younger state. This implies a potential for reversing some of the molecular damage associated with aging.
  • Muscle Disuse as an Accelerant: Conversely, muscle disuse (simulated through immobilization) significantly "ages" the transcriptome, highlighting the critical role of activity in maintaining cellular health.
  • Mitochondrial Health is Key: The integrated analysis revealed that pathways related to mitochondrial function and energy production are particularly sensitive to aging and disuse, but are beneficially restored by exercise and higher fitness. This underscores the central role of mitochondria in muscle aging.
  • Epigenetic and Transcriptomic Harmony (and Discord): While there's overlap in genes affected by aging at both epigenetic and transcriptomic levels, the specific pathways impacted can differ, suggesting distinct but interconnected aging mechanisms.

Key Results

  • Age-Related Changes: Identified 3168 differentially methylated positions (DMPs) and 330 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) associated with age in human skeletal muscle.
  • Fitness Association: Found significant associations between VO2max and age-related molecular profiles, with higher VO2max linked to younger profiles.
  • Exercise Training Effects: Identified 40 age-related DEGs that were significantly altered following exercise training, shifting towards a younger profile.
  • Muscle Disuse Effects: Found that 68 age-related DEGs were significantly altered following forced immobilization, accelerating transcriptomic aging.
  • Blunted Response in Older Adults: A subset of age-related DEGs showed a blunted response to exercise training in older individuals, suggesting that the benefits might be less pronounced with extreme age.
  • Mitochondrial Pathway Enrichment: Multi-contrast enrichment analysis revealed that mitochondrial and metabolic pathways were consistently inhibited by age and disuse, but enhanced by CRF and exercise training.

Limitations and Future Work

  • DNAm Data Bias: The DNAm cohorts included a majority of healthy, young/middle-aged, male individuals, limiting the ability to confidently extrapolate DNAm results to all populations, particularly older or diseased individuals.
  • Cell Type Proportions: The study acknowledges the challenge of distinguishing between changes intrinsic to muscle cells versus changes due to shifts in cell type proportions. Future studies using cell sorting or single-cell methods are suggested.
  • Epigenetic Clocks: The authors explain their decision not to use epigenetic clocks due to limitations in muscle-specific clocks, poor calibration of pan-tissue clocks in muscle, and the fact that clocks only capture a small portion of the aging methylome.
  • Functional Outcomes: The study focused on molecular changes and could not directly assess the functional impact of these OMIC changes on muscle structure or quality. Future work combining OMIC data with functional measurements and Mendelian randomization analyses is proposed to establish causality.
  • Specific Exercise Regimes: While the study examined exercise in general, it suggests that future research could explore whether specific training regimes (e.g., endurance vs. resistance) lead to unique anti-aging effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Exercise training prevents age-related decline in muscle function. Targeting epigenetic aging is a promising actionable mechanism and late-life exercise mitigates epigenetic aging in rodent muscle. Whether exercise training can decelerate, or reverse epigenetic aging in humans is unknown. Here, we performed a powerful meta-analysis of the methylome and transcriptome of an unprecedented number of human skeletal muscle samples (n = 3176). We show that: (1) individuals with higher baseline aerobic fitness have younger epigenetic and transcriptomic profiles, (2) exercise training leads to significant shifts of epigenetic and transcriptomic patterns toward a younger profile, and (3) muscle disuse "ages" the transcriptome. Higher fitness levels were associated with attenuated differential methylation and transcription during aging. Furthermore, both epigenetic and transcriptomic profiles shifted toward a younger state after exercise training interventions, while the transcriptome shifted toward an older state after forced muscle disuse. We demonstrate that exercise training targets many of the age-related transcripts and DNA methylation loci to maintain younger methylome and transcriptome profiles, specifically in genes related to muscle structure, metabolism, and mitochondrial function. Our comprehensive analysis will inform future studies aiming to identify the best combination of therapeutics and exercise regimes to optimize longevity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{voisin2023exercise,
  author = {Sarah Voisin and Kirsten Seale and Macsue Jacques and Shanie Landen and Nicholas R. Harvey and Larisa M. Haupt and Lyn R. Griffiths and Kevin J. Ashton and Vernon G. Coffey and Jamie‐Lee M. Thompson and Thomas M. Doering and Maléne E. Lindholm and Colum P. Walsh and Gareth W. Davison and Rachelle E Irwin and Catherine McBride and Ola Hansson and Olof Asplund and Aino Heikkinen and Päivi Piirilä and Kirsi H. Pietiläinen and Miina Ollikainen and Sara Blocquiaux and Martine Thomis and Dawn K. Coletta and Adam P. Sharples and Nir Eynon},
  title = {{Exercise is associated with younger methylome and transcriptome profiles in human skeletal muscle}},
  booktitle = {Aging},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1111/acel.13859},
}
Figure