TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel method for studying the "inductive biases" of neural language models (like Transformers and LSTMs) by training them on carefully constructed artificial languages. They found that Transformers exhibit strong preferences for certain word orders, unlike LSTMs, but these preferences don't align with common patterns in natural languages.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Neural language models are incredibly powerful but also notoriously opaque – they're "black boxes." It's hard to understand why they work so well or what inherent assumptions (inductive biases) they make about language structure. This makes it difficult to predict how they'll perform on different languages or to improve their design. A key challenge in studying these biases is isolating specific linguistic features (like word order) from the myriad of other differences that exist between natural languages. For example, comparing English (SVO) and Japanese (SOV) is confounded by many other grammatical differences.
Methods
The authors propose using artificial languages to overcome the limitations of studying natural languages. They construct simple, context-free grammars that can be systematically modified by "switches." Each switch controls the ordering of specific grammatical constituents (e.g., subject and verb, noun and adjective). By flipping these switches, they can create parallel corpora where sentences differ only in the specific typological feature being investigated. This allows for a controlled, causal analysis of how language models respond to these variations.
They then train Transformer and LSTM models on these artificial languages and measure their performance using perplexity. To analyze the results, they employ a linear mixed-effects model to quantify the impact of each switch and their interactions on model perplexity. This approach allows them to disentangle the effects of individual grammatical features and their combinations.
Datasets
The paper does not use pre-existing datasets. Instead, they generate their own datasets using the artificial languages they construct. For each of the 64 possible grammars (derived from 6 binary switches), they generate 100,000 sentences. These sentences are then split into train, development, and test sets for model training and evaluation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Artificial languages are powerful tools for controlled linguistic analysis: By stripping away the complexities of natural languages, researchers can precisely isolate and test hypotheses about model biases.
- Transformers and LSTMs have fundamentally different inductive biases: This is a major finding. LSTMs appear largely agnostic to word order variations, performing similarly across all tested configurations. Transformers, however, show significant performance differences depending on the word order, indicating a strong preference for certain structures.
- Model biases don't necessarily reflect natural language tendencies: Surprisingly, the word order preferences observed in the Transformer models do not align with the prevalence of different word orders in attested human languages. For instance, they perform similarly on SOV (common) and OVS (rare) orders.
- Grammar engineering as a diagnostic tool: The paper demonstrates how deliberately designing grammars can serve as a valuable method for understanding and diagnosing the behavior of neural networks.
Key Results
- LSTMs: Showed very similar average perplexities across all 64 artificial grammars, indicating a weak inductive bias regarding word order.
- Transformers: Exhibited considerable variation in average perplexity across the different grammars, demonstrating a clear preference for certain word order configurations.
- No reflection of attested language tendencies: The Transformer's preferences did not correlate with the prevalence of word orders in natural languages. For example, they performed similarly on SOV (most common) and OVS (rare) grammars.
- Mixed-effects model analysis: Revealed that for Transformers, positive coefficients for switches generally meant worse performance with head-initial ordering, while negative coefficients indicated the opposite. Interaction terms showed that shared head-directionality between certain constituents could sometimes improve Transformer performance. For LSTMs, these coefficients were generally small, reinforcing their agnosticism.
Limitations and Future Work
- Simplicity of artificial languages: The authors acknowledge that their artificial languages are simple and may not capture the full complexity of natural language constructions. Future work could involve extending these grammars to test more complex hypotheses.
- Limited scope of typological variation: While their method allows for controlled variation, they note that not all attested language typologies (e.g., VSO languages) are represented by their switch configurations.
- Automated weight assignment: The probabilities for grammar rules were assigned manually. An automated method for this could be explored in future work.
- Further exploration of biases: The authors suggest that their methodology can be used to investigate other typological features beyond word order.
Summary updated