Exact solution for Riemann problems of the shear shallow water model

Boniface Nkonga, Praveen Chandrashekar

Abstract

The shear shallow water model is a higher order model for shallow flows which includes some shear effects that are neglected in the classical shallow models. The model is a non-conservative hyperbolic system which can admit shocks, rarefactions, shear and contact waves. The notion of weak solution is based on a path but the choice of the correct path is not known for this problem. In this paper, we construct exact solution for the Riemann problem assuming a linear path in the space of conserved variables, which is also used in approximate Riemann solvers. We compare the exact solutions with those obtained from a path conservative finite volume scheme on some representative test cases.

Introduction: The Challenge of Non-Conservative Systems

In classical fluid dynamics, the Shallow Water equations are the standard for modeling rivers or coastal tides. However, these models typically ignore "shear"—the internal friction and velocity variations across the depth of the fluid. The Shear Shallow Water (SSW) model, derived by Teshukov, incorporates these effects, providing higher accuracy at the cost of significant mathematical complexity.

Unlike standard conservation laws (such as the Euler equations), the SSW model is a non-conservative hyperbolic system. These systems lack a unique definition for "weak solutions" (shocks) because jump conditions across a discontinuity depend on the specific "path" the state takes in phase space. This paper provides the first exact solution to the Riemann problem for the SSW model, creating a rigorous benchmark to evaluate numerical simulations.

Methodology: Constructing the Exact Solution

The authors solve the Riemann problem—an initial value problem with two constant states separated by a jump—by assuming a linear path in the space of conserved variables. This choice is strategic, as many modern numerical solvers (e.g., Roe or HLL-type schemes) implicitly rely on this linear path.

Wave structure of the Riemann problem for the SSW model, illustrating the characteristic waves including shocks, rarefactions, shear waves, and the central contact wave.

The construction of the exact solver involves several key theoretical steps:

  1. Spectral Analysis: Identifying six characteristic waves: two nonlinear waves (shocks or rarefactions), two shear waves, and two contact waves.
  2. Path-Conservative Framework: Utilizing the Dal Maso-LeFloch-Murat theory to handle non-conservative products across discontinuities.
  3. Riemann Invariants: Deriving explicit invariants for continuous rarefaction waves, including a specific "enstrophy" term.
  4. Generalized Rankine-Hugoniot Conditions: Formulating jump conditions for shocks that account for non-conservative terms.
  5. Exact Solver Construction: Reducing the problem to a 2x2 system of nonlinear equations for intermediate states, solved via a robust Newton-type algorithm.

Key Insights and Numerical Results

A major finding of this work is that the "exact" solution is inherently tied to the chosen path. This highlights a fundamental difficulty in non-conservative physics: mathematics alone cannot determine the "correct" path; physical principles, such as the vanishing viscosity limit, must provide the selection criteria.

Convergence and Numerical Dispersion

The authors observed that even "consistent" numerical schemes may not converge to the exact path-based solution at shocks. While HLL and HLLC solvers match the exact solution perfectly for rarefaction and contact waves, discrepancies appear at shock fronts. For instance, in a dam break test, the numerical solution for the Reynolds stress ($P_{11}$) deviated from the exact solution even with high mesh refinement (2,000 cells). The study suggests that numerical solutions in non-conservative systems are dominated by dispersion (producing "wave trains" or oscillations) rather than just dissipation, which can lead to a different limit than the analytical path-based solution.

Conclusion

This paper provides a solid mathematical foundation for the SSW model by proving the existence and uniqueness of the Riemann problem solution under specific conditions. By demonstrating that path-based jump conditions remain consistent with the total energy equation, the authors ensure the model is thermodynamically sound. Future work will focus on determining which path families actually correspond to real-world fluid behavior and analyzing the dispersive terms in numerical schemes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The shear shallow water model is a higher order model for shallow flows which includes some shear effects that are neglected in the classical shallow models. The model is a non-conservative hyperbolic system which can admit shocks, rarefactions, shear and contact waves. The notion of weak solution is based on a path but the choice of the correct path is not known for this problem. In this paper, we construct exact solution for the Riemann problem assuming a linear path in the space of conserved variables, which is also used in approximate Riemann solvers. We compare the exact solutions with those obtained from a path conservative finite volume scheme on some representative test cases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nkonga2022exact,
  author = {Boniface Nkonga and Praveen Chandrashekar},
  title = {{Exact solution for Riemann problems of the shear shallow water model}},
  booktitle = {ESAIM},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1051/m2an/2022032},
}
Figure