Evidence of Bulk Proton Insertion in Nanostructured Anatase and Amorphous TiO 2 Electrodes

Nikolina Makivić, Jae‐Young Cho, Kenneth D. Harris, Jean‐Marie Tarascon, Benoı̂t Limoges, Véronique BallandChemistry 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Crystalline structures and lattice water molecules are believed to strongly influence the ability of metal oxides to reversibly and rapidly insert protons in aqueous batteries. In the present work, we performed a systematic analysis of the electrochemical charge storage properties of nanostructured TiO2 electrodes composed of either anatase or amorphous TiO2 in a mild buffered aqueous electrolyte. We demonstrate that both materials allow reversible bulk proton insertion up to a maximal reversible gravimetric capacity of ∼150 mA·h·g–1. We also show that the TiO2 crystallinity governs the energetics of the charge storage process, with a phase transition for anatase, while having little effect on either the interfacial charge transfer kinetics or the apparent rate of proton diffusivity within the metal oxide. Finally, with both TiO2 electrodes, reversible proton insertion leads to gravimetric capacities as high as 95 mA·h·g–1 at 75 C. We also reveal two competitive reactions decreasing the Coulombic efficiency at low rates, i.e., hydrogen evolution and a nonfaradaic self-discharge reaction. Overall, this work provides a comprehensive overview of the proton-coupled electrochemical reactivity of TiO2 and highlights the key issues to be solved to truly benefit from the unique properties of protons as fast charge carriers in metal oxides.

Introduction

Aqueous batteries offer a non-flammable and environmentally friendly alternative to traditional energy storage technologies. Protons ($H^+$) are ideal charge carriers due to their small size and rapid transport kinetics. However, a central debate in materials science concerns the structural requirements for bulk proton insertion. While it was previously assumed that only layered or hydrated metal oxides could facilitate bulk storage, this study investigates whether non-layered materials like titanium dioxide ($TiO_2$) can support similar mechanisms.

Experimental Methods

The study utilized Glancing Angle Deposition (GLAD) to create highly reproducible, nanostructured thin films of $TiO_2$. This method allowed for the comparison of two distinct atomic arrangements: a disordered amorphous phase and a highly ordered crystalline anatase phase.

Cross-sectional SEM image (B) showing the columnar nanostructure of the TiO2 films produced by Glancing Angle Deposition.

Characterization involved in situ Raman spectroscopy to monitor chemical changes during cycling and electrochemical modeling to extract internal diffusion coefficients.

Results and Discussion

Bulk Proton Storage and Crystallinity

Both anatase and amorphous $TiO_2$ achieved a reversible capacity of ~150 mAh/g, matching the theoretical limit for a one-electron transfer ($Ti^{4+}$ to $Ti^{3+}$). This result confirms that protons penetrate the entire bulk of the material.

High-resolution TEM image (I) of the anatase phase, showing the (101) lattice fringes with a spacing of 0.35 nm.

The study found that while crystallinity dictates the thermodynamics—anatase undergoes a sharp phase transition while the amorphous phase behaves as a solid solution—it has little impact on the speed of proton diffusion. Both materials exhibited similar diffusion coefficients ($D_{H,in} \approx 3-4 \times 10^{-15} \text{ cm}^2/\text{s}$).

Rate Capability and Efficiency

The nanostructured architecture enabled exceptional rate capability, with capacities reaching 95 mAh/g at a current density of 11 A/g (75 C). This suggests that the small feature size is more critical for high-power performance than the long-range atomic order. However, low-rate performance was limited by the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and self-discharge. The application of a Nafion coating successfully improved Coulombic efficiency by acting as a protective barrier.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that bulk proton insertion is possible in non-layered $TiO_2$ regardless of crystallinity. The findings highlight the importance of nanostructuring for rapid kinetics and suggest that future efforts should focus on surface engineering and electrolyte optimization to minimize parasitic side reactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Crystalline structures and lattice water molecules are believed to strongly influence the ability of metal oxides to reversibly and rapidly insert protons in aqueous batteries. In the present work, we performed a systematic analysis of the electrochemical charge storage properties of nanostructured TiO2 electrodes composed of either anatase or amorphous TiO2 in a mild buffered aqueous electrolyte. We demonstrate that both materials allow reversible bulk proton insertion up to a maximal reversible gravimetric capacity of ∼150 mA·h·g–1. We also show that the TiO2 crystallinity governs the energetics of the charge storage process, with a phase transition for anatase, while having little effect on either the interfacial charge transfer kinetics or the apparent rate of proton diffusivity within the metal oxide. Finally, with both TiO2 electrodes, reversible proton insertion leads to gravimetric capacities as high as 95 mA·h·g–1 at 75 C. We also reveal two competitive reactions decreasing the Coulombic efficiency at low rates, i.e., hydrogen evolution and a nonfaradaic self-discharge reaction. Overall, this work provides a comprehensive overview of the proton-coupled electrochemical reactivity of TiO2 and highlights the key issues to be solved to truly benefit from the unique properties of protons as fast charge carriers in metal oxides.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{makivic2021evidence,
  author = {Nikolina Makivić and Jae‐Young Cho and Kenneth D. Harris and Jean‐Marie Tarascon and Benoı̂t Limoges and Véronique Balland},
  title = {{Evidence of Bulk Proton Insertion in Nanostructured Anatase and Amorphous TiO <sub>2</sub> Electrodes}},
  booktitle = {Chemistry},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.chemmater.1c00840},
}
Figure