Evaluation on the resistance to aphids of wheat germplasm resources in China

Haibo Zhou, Julian Chen, Cheng DengFa, Frédéric Francis, Yong Liu, Jingrui Sun, Huang Ying, Xiaosong Wang, Xingwang Liu, Xiaoming Liu, Ji, Zeng ongAFRICAN 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluated over 200 wheat germplasm lines in China for resistance to aphids, finding that most lines were susceptible. However, they identified two lines (Lantian20 and Lantian22) exhibiting consistent resistance across multiple locations and years, highlighting their potential for breeding programs aimed at developing aphid-resistant wheat varieties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wheat aphids, including species like Sitobion avenae, Schizaphis graminum, and Rhopalosiphum padi, pose a significant threat to global wheat production, causing substantial economic damage. The overuse of synthetic pesticides to combat these pests raises concerns about environmental pollution and human health. Consequently, there's a critical need to identify and utilize host plant resistance as a sustainable and environmentally friendly pest management strategy. This paper addresses the challenge of systematically evaluating a diverse collection of wheat germplasm for aphid resistance, a crucial step in breeding programs that aim to develop more resilient wheat cultivars.

Methods

The researchers employed a field-based evaluation of over 200 wheat germplasm lines across five experimental stations in China over two years (2009-2010). The core of their methodology involved a "fuzzy recognition technique" for assessing aphid infestation levels, which was applied by six experienced investigators. This technique, combined with a standardized rating scale (Table 1) and an evaluation index (R) derived from Painter (1951) (Table 2), allowed for a quantitative assessment of resistance. The experimental design utilized a randomized complete block design with three replications for each variety. To ensure consistent aphid pressure, a susceptible control variety (Beijing 837) was planted strategically throughout the experimental plots. No pesticides or herbicides were used to avoid confounding factors.

Datasets

The study utilized a collection of over 200 wheat germplasm lines sourced from the main wheat-producing areas of China. These lines were recommended by various agricultural institutions, including the Institute of Plant Protection, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, and Northwest A&F University. A susceptible wheat variety, c.v. Beijing 837, was used as a control.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Widespread Susceptibility: The vast majority of tested wheat germplasm lines showed susceptibility to aphids, with no immune or highly resistant lines identified. This underscores the challenge in finding natural resistance within the current germplasm pool.
  • Promising Resistant Lines: Despite the overall susceptibility, the identification of two lines, Lantian20 and Lantian22, exhibiting continuous resistance across multiple locations and years is a significant breakthrough. This consistency is vital for practical breeding applications.
  • Environmental Influence on Resistance: The study observed that the resistance of the same wheat germplasm lines could vary across different experimental stations. This highlights the complex interplay between genetics and environmental factors in expressing aphid resistance, suggesting that resistance might not be a fixed trait but can be influenced by local conditions.
  • Value of Fuzzy Recognition: The paper validates the fuzzy recognition technique as a valuable method for evaluating aphid resistance in wheat germplasm, suggesting its utility for future screening efforts.

Key Results

  • Resistance Distribution: On average, across all tested germplasm lines, the distribution of resistance levels was: resistant (9.30%), lowly susceptible (23.15%), moderately susceptible (42.32%), and highly susceptible (25.23%).
  • Moderately Resistant Lines: In 2009, five moderately resistant wheat germplasm lines were identified in Jiangyou: Lantian18, Lantian20, Lantian22, Lantian00-30, and Shanmai175.
  • Consistently Resistant Lines: Two wheat germplasm lines, Lantian20 and Lantian22, demonstrated continuous resistance to wheat aphids across all five experimental stations over the two-year study period.
  • Location-Specific Resistance: Several other lines showed consistent resistance within specific locations over the two years, such as Lantian-18, Lantian-20, Lantian-22, Mianmai-37, Mianmai-185, Hanmai-111, Linzao51329, and Changwu134 in Sichuan, and seven lines in Hebei.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the resistance observed in the identified lines requires further confirmation regarding the expression of these traits. Future research should focus on understanding the genetics and inheritance of aphid resistance in these newly identified sources. Additionally, exploring the potential of these germplasm lines to confer resistance against future biotypes of wheat aphids is crucial. The study also noted the variability in resistance expression across different experimental stations, suggesting that further investigation into the environmental factors influencing resistance is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

A collection of more than 200 wheat lines from the main wheat-producing areas of China was evaluated for resistance to wheat aphids, using fuzzy recognition technique in five field experiments over 2 years. The results show that susceptibility to wheat aphids was exhibited in most of the lines tested, and no immune and highly resistant lines to wheat aphids was observed. The average percentage of wheat germplasm lines with resistant, lowly susceptible, moderately susceptible and highly susceptible to aphid were 9.30, 23.15, 42.32, and 25.23%, respectively. 5 moderately resistant wheat germplasm lines to wheat aphids (Lantian18, Lantian20, Lantian22, Lantian00-30 and Shanmai175) were found in Jiangyou experimental station in 2009. More importantly, 2 wheat germplasm lines (Lantian20, Lantian22) with the continuous resistance to wheat aphid in the five experimental stations over 2 years were discovered. Although, resistance of wheat germplasm lines had a close relation to their genetics and inheritance, we also found that the resistance of the same wheat germplasm lines was varied in different experimental stations. It would be helpful to make wheat germplasm selections for breeding programs, especially if they have unique genes that may provide resistance to future biotypes of wheat aphids. A valuable method for evaluating the potential of aphid-resistance for wheat germplasm lines was also confirmed.   Key words: Wheat germplasm lines, aphid, resistance identification.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2011evaluation,
  author = {Haibo Zhou and Julian Chen and Cheng DengFa and Frédéric Francis and Yong Liu and Jingrui Sun and Huang Ying and Xiaosong Wang and Xingwang Liu and Xiaoming Liu and Ji and Zeng ong},
  title = {{Evaluation on the resistance to aphids of wheat germplasm resources in China}},
  booktitle = {AFRICAN},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.5897/ajb11.1184},
}
Figure