Evaluation of Spudcan Penetration/Extraction Behavior in Uniform Sand and Clay

Jin-Kwon Yoo, Duhee Park, Jae‐Mo KangJournal of the Korean Geotechnical Society 2017 · DOI

Abstract

This paper presents a comprehensive laboratory study on the influence of spudcan geometry on penetration and extraction behavior in uniform sand and clay. Using 1g laboratory-scale experiments, the researchers tested four distinct footing shapes (T1–T4) to evaluate how features such as central spigots and surface slopes affect performance. The study validates existing empirical formulas for shallow penetration depths while highlighting soil-dependent geometric effects. Key findings reveal that spigots significantly impact bearing capacity in sand but have negligible effects in soft clay, and that upper surface slopes are critical for reducing extraction resistance.

Introduction

Offshore jack-up rigs utilize massive steel footings known as spudcans to provide a stable foundation on the ocean floor. These footings must be pushed deep into the seabed to achieve the required bearing capacity and eventually pulled back out when the rig relocates. Predicting these forces is complex due to the non-planar geometries of spudcans, which often feature conical shapes and sharp central "spigots" to aid stability. While standard geotechnical formulas exist for shallow foundations, spudcans often operate in transitional zones where these models may diverge. This study addresses the lack of comparative data on how specific geometric features perform across different soil types, specifically uniform sand and soft clay.

Methodology

The experimental program involved 1g laboratory-scale penetration and extraction tests conducted in a controlled environment to observe scale and shape effects.

Soil Properties

Two primary soil types were utilized for the test beds:

  • Jumunjin Sand: A standard Korean silica sand prepared at 60% relative density ($G_s = 2.65$, internal friction angle $\phi = 39^\circ$).
  • Kaolinite Clay: Consolidated in four stages to reach an undrained shear strength ($S_u$) of approximately 10 kPa ($G_s = 2.60$, Liquid Limit = 44.94%, Plastic Limit = 29.38%).

Spudcan Geometries

Four distinct model geometries were tested at two different scales (widths of 50–63 mm and 100–126 mm):

  • T1 & T2: Rectangular footings featuring varying top and bottom slopes.
  • T3: A flat rectangular footing serving as a baseline.
  • T4: A circular, conical footing with a sharp central spigot, modeled after the industry-standard "UWA spudcan."
The four spudcan geometries (T1-T4) evaluated in the laboratory tests.

Experimental Setup

Tests were performed in a large soil tank (100 cm diameter, 100 cm height) equipped with a pressurization system and piezometers to monitor soil conditions. The measured bearing capacities were compared against classical empirical equations (Terzaghi, Meyerhof, Hansen, Vesic) and modern offshore guidelines (SNAME 2008, InSafeJIP 2011).

Experimental setup showing the pressurization system and the 100 cm x 100 cm soil tank.

Results and Discussion

Penetration Behavior

At shallow depths ($H/D < 1.0$), experimental results showed strong agreement with SNAME and InSafeJIP empirical formulas. However, as penetration depth increased, the bearing capacity followed a non-linear path, leading traditional linear empirical formulas to over-predict soil strength.

In sand, the sharp spigot of the T4 model significantly altered bearing capacity compared to flat-bottomed models. Conversely, in soft clay, the spigot's influence was negligible, suggesting that total cross-sectional area is the dominant factor in cohesive soils. Furthermore, a "scale effect" was observed in sand, where bearing capacity did not increase linearly with area, likely due to changes in failure mechanisms relative to grain size.

Extraction Behavior and Back-flow

The geometry of the upper surface was found to be more critical for extraction than for penetration. Steeper upper slopes significantly reduced the "suction" and soil resistance during pull-out. In clay, the bearing capacity often reached a plateau due to "back-flow," where displaced soil flows back over the spudcan, effectively changing the surcharge and resistance profile. For large-scale models in sand, the flat-bottomed T3 required the highest extraction force, whereas the sloped T1 and T2 models were easier to remove, highlighting the importance of geometry in decommissioning.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research highlights that spudcan geometry must be optimized based on the target soil type and decommissioning requirements. While spigots aid stability in sand, they offer little benefit in soft clay. Additionally, incorporating sloped upper surfaces can facilitate easier extraction, a vital consideration for offshore operations.

The study's 1g environment, while useful for comparative geometry, does not perfectly replicate the high-stress environments of the deep seabed typically studied in centrifuge tests. Furthermore, real-world seabeds are often complex, multi-layered systems. Future research should investigate multi-layered soil conditions (e.g., sand over clay) and the impact of combined environmental loading (wind and waves) to better simulate real-world offshore conditions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{yoo2017evaluation,
  author = {Jin-Kwon Yoo and Duhee Park and Jae‐Mo Kang},
  title = {{Evaluation of Spudcan Penetration/Extraction Behavior in Uniform Sand and Clay}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Geotechnical Society},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7843/kgs.2017.33.3.17},
}
Figure