Experimental study on the punching failure model of soft red rock subgrade by BPT-BVM methods and it’s assessment of the load bearing capacity

Jibin Chen, Qiang Pan, Yao Wei, Yibin Luo, Zhuangfu Zhao, Zhao Li, Yu BaiScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Current engineering standards in Southwest China often underestimate the bearing capacity of medium weathering mudstone foundations, leading to significant design redundancy. This study presents a comprehensive failure characterization of soft red rock in Chengdu using an integrated approach: Bearing Plate Tests (BPT) combined with Binocular Vision Measurement (BVM), uniaxial compressive strength tests, and trial trenching. By employing 3D imaging algorithms and Zhang's calibration method, the researchers modeled the rock's failure behavior. Results indicate that the characteristic load-carrying value of this layered isotropic mudstone ranges from 1500 to 2500 kPa—approximately 50% higher than local standards. Furthermore, the failure mechanism was identified as a "punching failure" rather than the traditionally assumed shear failure, characterized by a wave-peak displacement transfer. A new load-bearing capacity prediction model is proposed based on a revised uniaxial compressive strength reduction coefficient.

Introduction

In the rapidly developing urban centers of Southwest China, such as Chengdu, high-rise construction frequently relies on "medium weathering mudstone"—a type of soft red rock. Historically, the bearing capacity of these foundations has been determined using conservative regional guidelines or simplified laboratory-to-field reduction factors. However, empirical observations suggest these foundations possess significantly higher strength than theoretical models predict. This discrepancy results in "design redundancy," where developers incur unnecessary costs and carbon emissions for excessive foundation reinforcements. This research aims to bridge this gap by identifying the actual failure modes and establishing a more accurate mathematical model for bearing capacity.

Geological Context and Methodology

The study was conducted at the Science and Technology Innovation (STI) Park near XingLong Lake in Chengdu. The region is characterized by specific geological formations, including the Ziyang and Hejiang formations, which consist of layered soft red rock.

Geologic map showing the distribution of rock formations and the specific study site in the Chengdu region.

The experimental framework utilized a multi-pronged approach to capture both surface and subsurface behavior:

Location of the study area at XingLong Lake and on-site test points (1#, 2#, 3#) used for field verification and trial trenching.
  1. BPT-BVM Integration: The core innovation involved pairing standard Bearing Plate Tests (BPT) with a Binocular Vision Measurement (BVM) system. Two high-resolution cameras tracked 40–49 surface markers in real-time, using 3D imaging algorithms to monitor displacement patterns under load.
  2. Physical Verification: Following load tests, "trial trenches" were excavated to observe internal failure patterns directly and image the disrupted horizon.
  3. Laboratory Analysis: Uniaxial and triaxial compressive strength tests were performed on core samples to correlate small-scale lab results with large-scale field performance.

The researchers analyzed a substantial dataset comprising 100 on-site load tests across 25 different engineering projects in the Chengdu region to derive a new strength reduction factor ($\psi$).

Key Insights: The Punching Failure Mechanism

The study revealed that traditional geotechnical theories, such as the Hoek-Brown criterion which assumes shear failure along a wedge-shaped slip surface, do not accurately describe the behavior of layered mudstone. Instead, the rock exhibits a punching failure mode. In this scenario, the material directly beneath the bearing plate is crushed and displaced vertically, similar to a "cookie cutter" effect, with minimal lateral impact on the surrounding rock mass.

The BVM system captured a unique "wave-peak transfer" phenomenon in displacement. Rather than radiating outward uniformly, the increment of displacement moves in discrete waves as the load increases. This behavior is critical for understanding how stress is distributed in thin-bedded rock structures.

Results and Bearing Capacity Assessment

The investigation confirmed that local standards (typically recommending 800–1200 kPa) significantly undervalue the rock's strength. The actual characteristic values were found to be between 1500 and 2500 kPa.

A key finding was the variation in the strength reduction factor ($\psi$), the ratio between actual bearing capacity and laboratory compressive strength. While traditional guidelines suggest a maximum of 0.5, this study found values ranging from 0.36 to 0.80. By incorporating these findings into a new empirical model, the researchers achieved a prediction accuracy with less than 5% error compared to field tests.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a more realistic framework for assessing soft red rock foundations, potentially reducing construction costs and material waste. However, the authors note that mudstone is highly sensitive to environmental factors like water immersion and weathering. Future research will focus on how the strength reduction factor evolves under saturated conditions. While the BVM methodology is broadly applicable, the specific empirical formulas derived here are optimized for the layered isotropic rock of the Sichuan Basin and may require calibration for other geological settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recommended bearing capacity of medium weathering mudstone foundation is less than the capacity of the rock structure to withstand loads in Southwest China. A comprehensive failure characterization of medium weathering mudstone in Chengdu has been performed including bearing plate test (BPT), binocular vision measurement (BVM) test, uniaxial compressive strength test, trial trench test of shallow rock surface and 3D imaging in this paper. Failure behavior of rock has been modeled with 3D imaging algorithm that utilizes Zhang's calibration method in BVM system combination with trial trench test of shallow rock surface. The bearing capacity of medium weathering mudstone foundation were extracted from uniaxial experiments and BPT-BVM test by fitting relevant material properties to the data. The results revealed that: Bearing capacity of medium weathering mudstone of layered isotropic in Chengdu is undervalued. Specifically, the characteristic load carrying value is in the range 1500-2500 kP, that is 50% higher than in the local standard system. Failure process is different from Hoek-Brown Failure Criterion, presenting a wave peak transfer phenomenon of the increment displacement into the distance. Thus, it can be reduced to that of punching failures for thin bedded structures of Moudstone foundations. Compressive strength of soft rock proves to be main factor limiting the bearing capacity, a clear correlation between the uniaxial compressive strength reduction coefficient and the bearing capacity has been used to establish, leading to the proposal of a load bearing capacity prediction model.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2024experimental,
  author = {Jibin Chen and Qiang Pan and Yao Wei and Yibin Luo and Zhuangfu Zhao and Zhao Li and Yu Bai},
  title = {{Experimental study on the punching failure model of soft red rock subgrade by BPT-BVM methods and it’s assessment of the load bearing capacity}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-61838-1},
}
Figure