Ethnic and locational differences in ecosystem service values: Insights from the communities in forest islands in the desert

Aida Cuní‐Sanchez, Marion Pfeifer, Rob Marchant, Neil BurgessEcosystem 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that ethnicity and location significantly influence how local communities in northern Kenya perceive and value ecosystem services (ES) from their forest islands. Understanding these nuanced cultural preferences is crucial for effective conservation and development planning, as a "one-size-fits-all" approach can disproportionately impact different groups.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the concept of ecosystem services (ES) has gained significant traction in research and policy, most assessments have focused on ecological or economic valuations. There's a notable gap in understanding the social dimensions of ES, particularly how cultural factors like ethnicity and local context shape people's identification and valuation of these services. This is critical because conservation and development initiatives are more likely to succeed if they are aligned with the existing values and practices of local communities. The paper aims to address this by investigating how ethnicity and geographic location influence ES perception and the selection of important plant species for provisioning these services in the unique environment of forest islands in the arid northern Kenyan desert.

Methods

The researchers employed focus group (FG) discussions with male elders from Samburu and Boran communities living near three forest islands in northern Kenya: Mt Nyiro, Mt Kulal, and Mt Marsabit. This qualitative approach involved:

  • Open-ended questions: To allow participants to freely identify and list all perceived ecosystem services.
  • Ranking of ES: Participants were asked to select the two most important ES and explain their reasoning.
  • Identification of key plant species: Participants identified the top three plant species for specific provisioning services like firewood, poles, food, medicine, and fodder.
  • Content analysis: To capture themes and tendencies in the verbal discussions.
  • Jaccard similarity coefficient: Used to quantitatively compare the similarity of plant species mentioned across different groups and locations.

The study also incorporated field observations and literature reviews to verify plant presence and local names.

Datasets

The study did not utilize pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generated primary data through focus group discussions with local communities. The "dataset" can be considered the transcribed and analyzed qualitative data from these discussions, along with field observations and botanical identifications.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water is universally paramount: Regardless of ethnicity or location, water was consistently identified as the most important ecosystem service, underscoring its critical role in the arid environment.
  • Ethnicity and location create distinct ES landscapes: The second most important ES varied significantly between ethnic groups and locations, highlighting that cultural background and proximity to specific forest types shape priorities. For instance, Boran prioritized firewood, while Samburu emphasized fodder for their cattle.
  • "Shelter during conflict" as a vital ES: This service, not typically captured in mainstream ES assessments, was identified by communities in areas prone to cattle rustling, demonstrating the importance of context-specific ES.
  • Cultural values influence plant selection: Beyond mere availability, cultural preferences and local knowledge dictate which plant species are preferred for specific ES. This was evident in the differing medicinal plant preferences between Boran and Samburu.
  • Methodology matters: The use of open-ended questions was crucial for uncovering ES like "shelter during conflict" that might be missed by more structured questionnaires.

Key Results

  • ES Identification: Seven ES were cited by all groups and locations, including water, micro-climate regulation, fodder, firewood, poles, honey/fruits, and medicine resources. However, specific ES like "tools plough" (Boran) and "aesthetic values" (Samburu) were unique to certain groups.
  • Plant Species Similarity: Jaccard similarity coefficients for preferred plant species were generally low (< 0.5), indicating significant differences in species selection between groups and locations.
  • Most Important ES: Water was the top ES for all. The second most important ES varied: firewood for Boran in Marsabit, fodder during droughts for Samburu in Marsabit, medicine resources for Kulal, and a more diverse set for Nyiro.
  • Plant Use Differences: For fodder, Boran preferred Olea europaea, while Samburu preferred Rinorea convallarioides. For medicine, Boran favored Euphorbia tirucalli, and Samburu preferred Toddalia asiatica. Notably, Boran were unaware of the medicinal properties of T. asiatica.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gender Representation: The study acknowledges that including only male elders might have introduced bias, as cultural norms in the area limit open female participation in such discussions. Future work could explore methods to include female perspectives.
  • Limited Sample Size for Boran: The number of focus groups for the Boran-speaking communities in Marsabit was smaller than for Samburu communities, which could affect the generalizability of findings for that specific group.
  • Dynamic Landscape: The paper highlights that the study area is undergoing rapid transformation due to large-scale infrastructural developments. This will likely increase population pressure and diversify demands on these fragile ecosystems, necessitating adaptive management strategies.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that understanding cultural preferences is vital for developing effective reforestation programs and promoting alternative livelihoods. They also emphasize the need for participatory approaches to conservation that recognize local contexts and values, moving beyond purely monetary valuations. The study's findings on "shelter during conflict" as an ES also point to the need for broader ES frameworks that capture a wider range of human-environment interactions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cunisanchez2016ethnic,
  author = {Aida Cuní‐Sanchez and Marion Pfeifer and Rob Marchant and Neil Burgess},
  title = {{Ethnic and locational differences in ecosystem service values: Insights from the communities in forest islands in the desert}},
  booktitle = {Ecosystem},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ecoser.2016.04.004},
}
Figure