Estimation of the Time-Varying Reproduction Number of COVID-19 Outbreak in China

Chong You, Yuhao Deng, Wenjie Hu, Jiarui Sun, Qiushi Lin, Feng Zhou, Cheng Heng Pang, Yuan Zhang, Zhengchao Chen, Xiao‐Hua Zhou

Abstract

Background: The 2019-nCoV outbreak in Wuhan, China has attracted world-wide attention. As of February 11, 2020, a total of 44,730 cases of novel coronavirus-infected pneumonia associated with COVID-19 were confirmed by the National Health Commission of China. Methods: Three approaches—Poisson likelihood-based method (ML), exponential growth rate-based method (EGR), and stochastic Susceptible-Infected-Removed dynamic model-based method (SIR)—were implemented to estimate the basic and controlled reproduction numbers. Results: A total of 71 chains of transmission together with dates of symptoms onset and 67 dates of infections were identified among 5,405 confirmed cases outside Hubei as reported by February 2, 2020. Based on this information, we find the serial interval having an average of 4.41 days with a standard deviation of 3.17 days and the infectious period having an average of 10.91 days with a standard deviation of 3.95 days. Conclusions: The controlled reproduction number is declining. It is lower than one in most regions of China, but is still larger than one in Hubei Province. Sustained efforts are needed to further reduce the $R_c$ to below one in order to end the current epidemic.

Introduction

In the early weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic, the most vital question for epidemiologists was: How fast is it spreading, and are interventions working? This research, published in mid-February 2020, provides a rigorous statistical look at the initial outbreak in China. It focuses on estimating the reproduction number ($R$)—the average number of secondary infections produced by a single infected individual—to evaluate the effectiveness of public health interventions implemented in late January 2020.

Methods

The authors employed a "triangulation" approach, using three distinct statistical methods to ensure robust findings:

  1. Poisson Likelihood-based (ML): Uses daily new cases and the "serial interval" to estimate $R$.
  2. Exponential Growth Rate-based (EGR): Fits a regression line to the log-scale growth of daily cases.
  3. Stochastic SIR Model: Accounts for random variability in the data using the Iterated Filtering (IF2) algorithm.

Biological parameters were estimated from 5,405 cases reported outside Hubei, identifying 71 transmission chains and 67 cases with known infection dates. This focus on data outside Hubei provided more detailed and less overwhelmed datasets for calculating the serial interval and infectious period.

Key Insights and Ideas

Rapid Transmission Cycle

The researchers estimated a mean serial interval of 4.41 days, which is notably shorter than the estimated infectious period of 10.91 days. This suggests that individuals were likely transmitting the virus very early in their infection, potentially before the onset of significant symptoms.

The "Jan 29" Turning Point

By plotting new cases on a log scale, the authors identified a clear "kink" in the curve around January 29. Given the incubation period and reporting lags, this shift aligns with the strict containment measures implemented around January 19–20.

Logarithmic growth of new COVID-19 cases in China and regions outside Hubei, highlighting a change in trajectory around January 29.

Key Results

The study highlights a significant drop in the reproduction number across China following the implementation of control measures. While the basic reproduction number ($R_0$) was initially high, the controlled reproduction number ($R_c$) showed a marked decline.

Region $R_0$ (Jan 21–28) $R_c$ (Jan 29–Feb 5)
China (Overall) 3.02 – 5.40 1.65 – 2.30
Hubei Province 3.33 – 5.50 1.93 – 2.80
Other Provinces 2.68 – 5.10 1.07 – 1.20
Temporal trends of the controlled reproduction number (Rc) for China, Hubei, and other provinces.

The Hubei Anomaly

While $R_c$ dropped toward or below 1.0 in most provinces, Hubei’s $R_c$ remained significantly higher. The authors suggest this was due to the extreme density of cases and the initial strain on medical resources in Wuhan, which may have facilitated household or community transmission before isolation could be effectively implemented.

Limitations and Conclusion

The authors noted several challenges, including evolving diagnostic criteria that caused artificial surges in case numbers and potential data saturation in Hubei's overwhelmed medical system. Despite these hurdles, the study concludes that while interventions successfully flattened the curve in most of China, sustained efforts were required in Hubei to push $R_c$ below the critical threshold of 1.0 and end the epidemic.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background The 2019-nCoV outbreak in Wuhan, China has attracted world-wide attention. As of February 11, 2020, a total of 44730 cases of novel coronavirus-infected pneumonia associated with COVID-19 were confirmed by the National Health Commission of China. Methods Three approaches, namely Poisson likelihood-based method (ML), exponential growth rate-based method (EGR) and stochastic Susceptible-Infected-Removed dynamic model-based method (SIR), were implemented to estimate the basic and controlled reproduction numbers. Results A total of 71 chains of transmission together with dates of symptoms onset and 67 dates of infections were identified among 5405 confirmed cases outside Hubei as reported by February 2, 2020. Based on this information, we find the serial interval having an average of 4.41 days with a standard deviation of 3.17 days and the infectious period having an average of 10.91 days with a standard deviation of 3.95 days. Conclusions The controlled reproduction number is declining. It is lower than one in most regions of China, but is still larger than one in Hubei Province. Sustained efforts are needed to further reduce the R c to below one in order to end the current epidemic.
BibTeX
@article{you2020estimation,
  author = {Chong You and Yuhao Deng and Wenjie Hu and Jiarui Sun and Qiushi Lin and Feng Zhou and Cheng Heng Pang and Yuan Zhang and Zhengchao Chen and Xiao‐Hua Zhou},
  title = {{Estimation of the Time-Varying Reproduction Number of COVID-19 Outbreak in China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijheh.2020.113555},
}
Figure