Estimating SignalsWith Finite Rate of Innovation From Noisy Samples: A Stochastic Algorithm

Vincent Y. F. Tan, Vivek K GoyalINRIA 2009

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel stochastic algorithm, Gibbs sampling, to accurately reconstruct signals with a "finite rate of innovation" (FRI) from noisy measurements. This approach overcomes the instability and ill-conditioning issues faced by previous methods, particularly when dealing with real-world noisy data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem tells us that bandlimited signals can be perfectly reconstructed from uniformly sampled data. However, many real-world signals, like those containing sharp transitions or impulses, are not bandlimited but possess a "finite rate of innovation" (FRI). This means they can be described by a finite number of parameters per unit time. While methods exist to reconstruct such signals from noiseless samples, practical scenarios involve noisy measurements due to limitations in analog-to-digital converters. Existing techniques for noisy FRI signal reconstruction often struggle with instability and ill-conditioning, especially when using common signal acquisition kernels like the Gaussian kernel, which don't satisfy certain mathematical conditions (Strang-Fix). This paper tackles the challenge of robustly estimating the parameters of FRI signals from noisy samples.

Methods

The core of this paper is a stochastic algorithm based on Gibbs sampling. Gibbs sampling is a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method that allows for the estimation of parameters by iteratively sampling from their conditional probability distributions. The authors exploit this by breaking down the complex problem of estimating all signal parameters simultaneously into a series of simpler, conditional estimations.

Specifically, the algorithm proceeds in two main stages:

  1. Gibbs Sampling for Dirac Positions ($t_k$): The algorithm first estimates the locations of the "innovation points" (e.g., the time instances of Dirac impulses) using Gibbs sampling. This is crucial because the relationship between these positions and the observed noisy samples is highly nonlinear, making direct optimization difficult. The Gibbs sampler iteratively samples each $t_k$ given the current estimates of all other parameters and the data.
  2. Least-Squares Estimation for Weights ($c_k$) and Noise Variance ($\sigma_e^2$): Once the Dirac positions are estimated, the weights ($c_k$) associated with these impulses and the noise variance ($\sigma_e^2$) can be estimated more tractably using linear least-squares methods.

The paper also notes that the algorithm is designed to work with a Gaussian low-pass filter applied to the signal before sampling, and it uses a specific model for the noisy samples.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments are conducted using simulated data generated according to the described model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stochasticity as a Solution to Ill-Conditioning: The paper demonstrates that a stochastic approach (Gibbs sampling) can effectively circumvent the ill-conditioning that plagues deterministic methods for noisy FRI signal reconstruction. Instead of directly minimizing an error function, it explores the parameter space probabilistically.
  • Kernel Agnosticism: A significant advantage highlighted is that the Gibbs sampling algorithm's formulation does not depend on the specific form of the sampling kernel $h(t)$, unlike some prior methods. This allows for greater flexibility in signal modeling and acquisition.
  • Robustness to Noise: The proposed algorithm shows remarkable robustness to noise, outperforming traditional methods like the annihilating filter and root-finding approach, which are shown to be highly unstable in the presence of even small amounts of noise.
  • Efficient Parameter Estimation: By breaking down the estimation into conditional steps, the algorithm makes tractable the estimation of parameters that would otherwise be very difficult to recover from noisy data.

Key Results

  • Improved Reconstruction Accuracy: Numerical simulations show that the Gibbs sampling algorithm provides significantly better reconstructions compared to the annihilating filter and root-finding method, especially under noisy conditions. For instance, Figure 2(b) shows a much better reconstruction of the filtered signal $z(t)$ from noisy samples ($SNR = 10.2$ dB) compared to the failure of the other method in Figure 2(a) with much less noise ($SNR = 137$ dB).
  • Robustness to Initialization: The paper states that the Gibbs sampler algorithm is insensitive to initial parameter guesses, consistently converging to approximately optimal estimates from any starting point.
  • Accurate Noise Variance Estimation: The algorithm can also accurately estimate the noise standard deviation $\sigma_e$, which can be important for various applications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Load: The paper acknowledges that sampling the Dirac positions ($t_k$) via rejection sampling can be computationally intensive, suggesting that improving this aspect is a direction for future work.
  • Structured Priors: The authors suggest that a natural extension would be to incorporate structured priors on the parameters ($c_k, t_k, \sigma_e^2$), potentially leading to a hierarchical Bayesian formulation with greater flexibility in parameter estimation.
  • Computational Efficiency: While the algorithm is robust, further work could focus on optimizing its computational efficiency for real-time applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

International audience
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2009estimating,
  author = {Vincent Y. F. Tan and Vivek K Goyal},
  title = {{Estimating SignalsWith Finite Rate of Innovation From Noisy Samples: A Stochastic Algorithm}},
  booktitle = {INRIA},
  year = {2009},
}
Figure