Estimating black carbon aging time-scales with a particle-resolved aerosol model

Nicole Riemer, Matthew West, R. A. Zaveri, R. C. Easter

Abstract

Understanding the aging process of aerosol particles is critical for assessing their chemical reactivity, cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) activity, radiative properties, and health impacts. This study investigates the aging of black carbon (BC) containing particles in an idealized urban plume using a novel approach: the particle-resolved aerosol model PartMC-MOSAIC. We present a method to estimate aging timescales using a criterion based on CCN activation. Our results reveal a distinct separation into a daytime regime, where condensation dominates, and a nighttime regime, where coagulation is the primary driver. For the chosen urban plume scenario, aging timescales vary between 0.06 and 10 hours during the day and between 6 and 20 hours at night, depending on the supersaturation threshold.

Introduction

Black carbon (BC), often referred to as soot, is a major contributor to global warming due to its ability to absorb solar radiation. When first emitted—primarily from combustion sources like diesel engines or biomass burning—BC particles are "fresh," meaning they are hydrophobic and do not easily seed clouds. Over time, these particles undergo "aging," a process where they acquire coatings of secondary species (such as sulfates or nitrates) or collide with other particles. This evolution changes their physical properties, eventually making them hydrophilic and allowing them to act as Cloud Condensation Nuclei (CCN).

The "aging timescale" ($τ$) is a vital parameter in global climate models. If this timescale is overestimated, models predict that BC stays in the atmosphere longer than it actually does; if underestimated, they predict too short a lifetime. Historically, climate models have relied on a constant "rule of thumb" (often roughly 30 hours). This study seeks to replace these ad-hoc values with physically grounded calculations derived from the detailed evolution of individual particles.

Methodology: The Particle-Resolved Approach

To capture the complexity of aerosol evolution, the researchers utilized PartMC-MOSAIC, a particle-resolved aerosol model. Unlike traditional models that treat aerosols as a "soup" of average concentrations, PartMC-MOSAIC tracks a population of approximately 100,000 individual particles within a Lagrangian air parcel (a moving volume of air).

Key Methodological Components:

  • Stochastic Simulation: The model uses Monte Carlo techniques to simulate random coagulation events and particle emissions, providing a realistic representation of particle-to-particle interactions.
  • Deterministic Chemistry: The MOSAIC code handles gas-phase chemistry and the condensation or evaporation of secondary species onto individual particles.
  • CCN-Based Aging Criterion: A particle is defined as "aged" once its chemical composition allows it to activate into a cloud droplet at a specific supersaturation threshold ($S_c$).
  • First-Order Fitting: To make the high-fidelity data useful for larger-scale climate models, the authors fit the complex individual-particle data to a traditional first-order bulk model to extract the aging timescale $τ$.

Simulation Setup

The study modeled an idealized urban plume scenario to serve as a benchmark. The input data included emission profiles from three distinct sources: meat cooking (100% organic), diesel vehicles (70% BC, 30% organic), and gasoline vehicles (20% BC, 80% organic). These emissions were introduced into a background aerosol of ammonium sulfate and primary organic aerosol, subjected to a 24-hour cycle of temperature, humidity, and mixing height typical of a polluted urban environment.

Key Insights and Results

1. The Day/Night Dichotomy

The study identified two distinct aging regimes driven by the diurnal cycle. During the day, aging is remarkably fast, dominated by the condensation of secondary species (specifically ammonium nitrate) resulting from photochemistry. During the night, when photochemistry ceases, aging slows significantly and is driven primarily by coagulation (particles colliding and merging).

2. Timescale Values

  • Daytime: Aging timescales ranged from 0.06 to 10 hours. This suggests that in urban environments, soot becomes CCN-active almost immediately during peak daylight.
  • Nighttime: Timescales were longer, ranging from 6 to 20 hours. Both regimes produced timescales significantly shorter than the ~30-hour constant frequently used in global models.

3. Mass vs. Number Discrepancy

The authors discovered that "mass-based" aging timescales are approximately five times shorter than "number-based" timescales. This occurs because larger particles, which carry more mass, tend to age and activate as CCN more quickly than smaller particles. This distinction is crucial for models that track aerosol mass versus those that track particle number.

4. Sensitivity to Supersaturation ($S_c$)

The perceived aging timescale is highly dependent on the chosen supersaturation threshold. If the criteria for "aging" require activation in subtle cloud conditions (low $S_c$), the aging appears much faster than if activation is only required for high-supersaturation environments.

Conclusion and Future Work

The findings suggest that current global climate models may be overestimating the atmospheric lifetime of black carbon in urban-influenced regions by using aging timescales that are too long. By explicitly calculating these values based on particle-resolved physics, this research provides a path toward more accurate climate forcing projections.

While the study provides a robust framework, it is limited by its focus on a single, highly polluted urban scenario ($N_{BC} ≈ 5000 \text{ cm}^{-3}$) and the exclusion of heterogeneous surface reactions. Future research will aim to apply this method to a wider variety of environments—such as biomass burning plumes or pristine marine air—to develop a comprehensive "lookup table" of aging timescales for use in global climate simulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the aging process of aerosol particles is important for assessing their chemical reactivity, cloud condensation nuclei activity, radiative properties and health impacts. In this study we investigate the aging of black carbon containing particles in an idealized urban plume using a new approach, the particle-resolved aerosol model PartMC-MOSAIC. We present a method to estimate aging time-scales using an aging criterion based on cloud condensation nuclei activation. The results show a separation into a daytime regime where condensation dominates and a nighttime regime where coagulation dominates. For the chosen urban plume scenario, depending on the supersaturation threshold, the values for the aging time-scales vary between 0.06 hours and 10 hours during the day, and between 6 hours and 20 hours during the night.
BibTeX
@article{riemer2009estimating,
  author = {Nicole Riemer and Matthew West and R. A. Zaveri and R. C. Easter},
  title = {{Estimating black carbon aging time-scales with a particle-resolved aerosol model}},
  journal = {Journal of Aerosol Science},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jaerosci.2009.08.009},
}

Loading related content...

Figure