Establishing and Maintaining a Reliable Optical Wireless Communication in Underwater Environment

Ibrahima N'Doye, Ding Zhang, Mohamed-Slim Alouini, Taous-Meriem Laleg-Kirati

Abstract

Maintaining high-speed data transmission in underwater environments is a significant challenge due to the physical limitations of traditional communication methods. This paper proposes a robust trajectory tracking system for Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs) to maintain a stable Underwater Wireless Optical Communication (UWOC) link with a moving surface vessel. By defining a geometric "connectivity cone" and implementing a Nonlinear Proportional Derivative (NLPD) controller, the research demonstrates a 70% improvement in tracking accuracy over traditional methods. The system effectively manages nonlinear underwater dynamics, solar background noise, and turbulent currents to ensure a reliable 10 Mbps communication link.

Introduction

Underwater communication typically relies on acoustic systems, which are slow and high-latency, or Radio Frequency (RF) waves, which suffer from rapid absorption in saltwater. Underwater Wireless Optical Communication (UWOC) has emerged as a high-bandwidth, low-latency alternative. However, UWOC requires a precise Line-of-Sight (LoS) between the transmitter and receiver.

Figure 1: Physical setup of the AUV and surface ship communication system, illustrating the world {W} and body {B} coordinate frames.

The primary challenge is the "pointing and tracking" problem. As both the surface ship and the submerged AUV move independently, maintaining the optical link becomes difficult. External factors such as solar background noise in shallow waters and unpredictable ocean currents further complicate the task of keeping the AUV within the receiver's narrow field-of-view.

Methodology

The Connectivity Cone

To ensure reliable communication, the authors define a "connectivity cone" ($\mathcal{C}$). This geometric volume represents the region where the optical receiver's field-of-view, target bit rate (10 Mbps), and Bit Error Rate (BER) requirements are met. As long as the AUV remains within this cone, the high-speed link is maintained.

Figure 3: (a) Visual representation of the connectivity cone C. (b) Relationship between the log bit rate (log B) and distance, showing the maximum distance required to maintain the desired 10 Mbps rate.

Nonlinear Control Strategy

Traditional Proportional Derivative (PD) controllers often struggle with the nonlinearities and external disturbances inherent in underwater environments. The researchers developed a Nonlinear Proportional Derivative (NLPD) controller. This controller utilizes a saturation function to dynamically adjust control gains, providing enhanced robustness against model uncertainties and environmental forces. The stability of this closed-loop tracking system was mathematically verified using Lyapunov-based analysis to ensure asymptotic convergence to the desired trajectory.

Key Results and Discussion

The proposed system was evaluated through high-fidelity MATLAB/Simulink simulations, comparing the NLPD controller against standard PD strategies under various stress conditions:

  • Tracking Performance: In nominal conditions, the NLPD controller achieved a tracking accuracy improvement of over 70% compared to the standard PD controller.
  • Environmental Robustness: When subjected to simulated ocean currents and measurement noise, the NLPD controller maintained a 35% to 40% performance advantage. Notably, the NLPD controller remained effective even with a 20% error in the AUV's mass parameters, demonstrating significant resistance to "model mismatch."
  • Link Stability: While the standard PD controller frequently allowed the AUV to drift out of the connectivity cone—resulting in data loss—the NLPD controller successfully kept the vehicle within the beam, ensuring a steady 10 Mbps bit rate.

Conclusion

This research provides a mathematical and algorithmic framework for maintaining stable UWOC links between moving platforms. By prioritizing the geometric constraints of the communication channel within the control loop, the NLPD controller offers a practical solution for high-speed underwater data transfer. Future work will focus on validating these simulation results through real-world ocean testing and addressing intermittent localization data in practical maritime environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper proposes the trajectory tracking problem between an autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV) and a mobile surface ship, both equipped with optical communication transceivers. The challenging issue is to maintain stable connectivity between the two autonomous vehicles within an optical communication range. We define a directed optical line-of-sight (LoS) link between the two-vehicle systems. The transmitter is mounted on the AUV while the surface ship is equipped with an optical receiver. However, this optical communication channel needs to preserve a stable transmitter-receiver position to reinforce service quality, which typically includes a bit rate and bit error rates. A cone-shaped beam region of the optical receiver is approximated based on the channel model; then, a minimum bit rate is ensured if the AUV transmitter remains inside of this region. Additionally, we design two control algorithms for the transmitter to drive the AUV and maintain it in the cone-shaped beam region under an uncertain oceanic environment. Lyapunov function-based analysis that ensures asymptotic stability of the resulting closed-loop tracking error is used to design the proposed NLPD controller. Numerical simulations are performed using MATLAB/Simulink to show the controllers' ability to achieve favorable tracking in the presence of the solar background noise within competitive times. Finally, results demonstrate the proposed NLPD controller improves the tracking error performance more than $70\%$ under nominal conditions and $35\%$ with model uncertainties and disturbances compared to the original PD strategy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ndoye2021establishing,
  author = {Ibrahima N'Doye and Ding Zhang and Mohamed-Slim Alouini and Taous-Meriem Laleg-Kirati},
  title = {{Establishing and Maintaining a Reliable Optical Wireless Communication in Underwater Environment}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=bSGqGDkllt},
}
Figure