Abstract
We consider a class of pure black hole microstates and demonstrate that they can be made escapable by turning on certain double trace deformations in the CFT. These microstates are dual to BCFT states prepared via a Euclidean path integral starting from a boundary in Euclidean time. These states are dual to black holes in the bulk with an End-of-the-World brane; a codimension one timelike boundary of the spacetime behind the horizon. We show that by tuning the sign of the coupling of the double trace operator to the boundary conditions on the brane the deformation injects negative energy into the black hole causing a time advance for signals behind the horizon. We demonstrate how the property of escapability in the considered microstates follows immediately from the traversability of deformed wormholes. We briefly comment on reconstruction of the black hole interior and state dependence.
Introduction: Probing the Unreachable
In the study of quantum gravity and the AdS/CFT correspondence, the interior of a black hole is a notoriously difficult place to probe. Classically, the event horizon acts as a point of no return, leading to the famous black hole information paradox: if information is truly lost, it violates the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics. While recent breakthroughs demonstrated that two-sided black holes (wormholes) could be made traversable, the case for single-sided black holes—the kind that might actually form from collapsing matter—remained more mysterious. This research explores whether a "pure state" black hole can be made escapable, allowing for the reconstruction of events behind the horizon.
Theoretical Framework: BCFT and ETW Branes
The authors utilize the framework of AdS/CFT correspondence, specifically focusing on black hole microstates dual to a Conformal Field Theory with a boundary (BCFT). These states are prepared via a Euclidean path integral, which can be visualized as a conformal mapping from a plane to a strip.
In the bulk gravitational description, this boundary extends into the spacetime as an End-of-the-World (ETW) brane. This brane acts as a physical, codimension-one timelike boundary located behind the black hole horizon. Effectively, the ETW brane acts like a mirror, allowing a single-sided black hole to be treated mathematically as "half" of a two-sided traversable wormhole.
The Mechanism: Negative Energy Injection
To make the black hole interior escapable, the researchers introduce a double-trace deformation to the boundary theory. This involves adding a specific interaction term to the CFT Hamiltonian. By carefully choosing the sign of the coupling constant ($g$) relative to the boundary conditions on the ETW brane (e.g., Dirichlet or Neumann), the deformation injects negative energy into the bulk.
This negative energy violates the Average Null Energy Condition (ANEC), which typically prevents escape from a black hole. The injection causes a "time advance": instead of a signal being delayed indefinitely by the horizon, it receives a "push" that allows it to cross the horizon and reach the boundary in finite time. This mechanism provides a mathematical window to reconstruct operators located deep inside the black hole interior using only boundary data.
Key Results and Limitations
The study successfully proves that for a class of pure microstates, a signal can escape the interior if the deformation is activated at the appropriate time. However, several critical constraints were identified:
- State-Dependence: The deformation required is not universal; it must be tailored to the specific microstate (the "key" must match the "lock" of the brane's boundary conditions).
- The Scrambling Limit: Escapability is restricted to "young" black holes. As the state thermalizes, the required deformation becomes increasingly complex. Beyond the "scrambling time" ($T_c$), the probe approximation breaks down, and backreaction on the geometry likely prevents information retrieval.
- The Trans-Planckian Problem: For information that has been inside for a long duration, the relative boost between the escaping signal and the brane becomes so high that it may trigger the formation of a new horizon, shielding the information once again.
Conclusion
By demonstrating that pure boundary-state black holes can be made escapable, this work bridges the gap between theoretical wormhole traversability and the physics of single-sided black holes. While challenges remain regarding late-time information and full gravitational backreaction, the results offer a robust path forward for understanding bulk reconstruction and the resolution of the information paradox in pure states.
Summary updated