Error Rate Analysis of Amplitude-Coherent Detection over Rician Fading Channels with Receiver Diversity

Mohammad A. Al-Jarrah, Ki-Hong Park, Arafat Al-Dweik, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Abstract

Amplitude-coherent (AC) detection represents an efficient middle ground in receiver design, balancing the high performance of coherent systems with the reduced complexity of noncoherent architectures. This paper investigates AC detector design and Symbol Error Rate (SER) analysis for M-ary Amplitude Shift Keying (MASK) modulation over Rician fading channels. We derive optimum, near-optimum, and heuristic AC detectors and evaluate their performance against traditional coherent and noncoherent benchmarks. Furthermore, we provide two analytical approaches for SER derivation, including a closed-form expression for high-SNR asymptotic analysis. Our results indicate that AC detection is particularly robust against phase noise and performs comparably to coherent detection in high Rician K-factor environments.

Introduction

In digital communications, the choice of receiver architecture typically involves a trade-off between performance and complexity. Coherent detection offers superior accuracy but requires precise knowledge of the channel's phase— a task that is computationally expensive and often difficult to achieve in dynamic environments. Conversely, noncoherent detection is simpler to implement but suffers from significant performance degradation, especially when using higher-order modulations like MASK.

Amplitude-Coherent (AC) detection offers a "Goldilocks" solution by requiring only channel gain knowledge, omitting the need for phase estimation. While previous research has explored AC detection in Rayleigh fading environments, many modern communication scenarios—such as satellite-to-ground links and Free Space Optics (FSO)—are characterized by a strong direct line-of-sight component, modeled as Rician fading. This paper establishes a rigorous mathematical framework for AC detection in Rician environments, incorporating receiver diversity to combat signal fading.

Detector Design and Methodology

We analyze several variations of AC detectors designed for MASK modulation:

  1. Optimum and Near-Optimum Detectors: These are derived using Maximum Likelihood (ML) criteria. Since the exact mathematical derivation is often intractable, we utilize the Von Mises distribution to approximate phase statistics, leading to a near-optimum solution.
  2. Heuristic AC Detector (HACD): To facilitate hardware implementation, we propose a simplified detector that combines signals from multiple antennas based on channel gain and compares the result against fixed thresholds.
  3. Analytical Framework: The core of this research is the derivation of the SER for the HACD. We present two distinct approaches:
  4. Approach I: Employs series expansions of Bessel functions to create a tool for numerical evaluation.
  5. Approach II: Provides a closed-form analytical expression, which is further used to derive a simplified asymptotic formula for high Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) regimes.

To validate these theoretical models, we conducted Monte Carlo simulations using $10^7$ independent channel realizations.

Key Insights and Results

Phase Noise Resilience

One of the most significant findings is that the Heuristic AC detector is inherently immune to phase noise. In systems subject to frequency offsets or jitter, traditional coherent detectors often hit an "error floor" where performance ceases to improve regardless of increased power. In contrast, the AC detector continues to improve with SNR, eventually outperforming coherent detection in high-noise scenarios.

The Role of the Rician K-Factor

The Rician K-factor represents the ratio of power in the direct line-of-sight path to the power in scattered paths. Our analysis shows that as the K-factor increases, the performance gap between the low-complexity AC detector and the complex coherent detector virtually disappears. For high K-factors and a limited number of receiving antennas, the two methods achieve near-parity.

Performance and Diversity Gains

For modulation orders $M > 2$, the HACD significantly outperforms optimum noncoherent detectors. The study also quantifies the benefits of receiver diversity ($N$). At an SER of $10^{-5}$, the performance gap between coherent and AC detection is restricted to approximately 1.4 to 2.0 dB, depending on the number of antennas. Furthermore, the derived asymptotic formula from Approach II proved highly accurate at high SNRs, providing a reliable tool for system performance prediction without the need for exhaustive simulations.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work demonstrates that Amplitude-Coherent detection is a robust and efficient alternative for Rician fading channels, particularly when phase estimation is difficult or when the system is subject to phase noise. While the optimum AC detector matches coherent performance, its high complexity makes the heuristic version a more practical choice for most scenarios.

Future research may explore constellation optimization—adjusting signal levels to account for the specific shapes of probability density functions—to further reduce error rates. Additionally, investigating the impact of imperfect channel gain estimation would provide further insights into the real-world deployment of AC frameworks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Amplitude-coherent (AC) detection is an efficient detection technique that can simplify the receiver design while providing reliable symbol error rate (SER). Therefore, this work considers AC detector design and SER analysis using M-ary amplitude shift keying (MASK) modulation over Rician fading channels. More specifically, we derive the optimum, near-optimum and a suboptimum AC detectors and compare their SER to the coherent, noncoherent and the heuristic AC detectors. Moreover, the analytical SER of the heuristic detector is derived using two different approaches for single and multiple receiving antennas. One of the derived expressions is expressed in terms of a single integral that can be evaluated numerically, while the second approach gives a closed-form analytical expression for the SER, which is also used to derive a simple formula for the asymptotic SER at high signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs). The obtained analytical and simulation results show that the SER of the AC and coherent MASK detectors are comparable, particularly for high values of the Rician K-factor, and small number of receiving antennas. Moreover, the obtained results show that the SER of the optimal AC detector is equivalent to that of the coherent detector. However, the optimal AC detector complexity is prohibitively high, particularly at high SNRs. In most of the scenarios, the heuristic AC detector significantly outperforms the optimum noncoherent detector, except for the binary ASK case at low SNRs. Moreover, the obtained results show that the heuristic AC detector is immune to phase noise, and thus, it outperforms the coherent detector in scenarios where system is subject to considerable phase noise.
BibTeX
@article{aljarrah2020error,
  author = {Mohammad A. Al-Jarrah and Ki-Hong Park and Arafat Al-Dweik and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Error Rate Analysis of Amplitude-Coherent Detection over Rician Fading Channels with Receiver Diversity}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=laj4zJ7ykb},
}
Figure