Erland Samuel Bring's "Transformation of Algebraic Equations"

Yang‐Hui He, John McKay, Alexander Chen

TL;DR

This paper presents the first English translation of Erland Samuel Bring’s 1786 Latin treatise, a landmark in algebraic history. It details Bring's method for reducing a general quintic equation to a simple trinomial form ($x^5 + px + q = 0$), a feat achieved decades before the more famous works of Jerrard, Abel, and Galois.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For centuries, the "Quintic Problem"—finding a general formula to solve fifth-degree equations—was the Holy Grail of algebra. While we now know, thanks to Abel and Galois, that a general solution using only radicals is impossible, 18th-century mathematicians focused on "transformations."

The goal was to take a messy general equation: $$x^5 + ax^4 + bx^3 + cx^2 + dx + e = 0$$ and transform it into a simpler "canonical" form by eliminating as many intermediate terms as possible. The challenge was doing this without inadvertently requiring the solution of an even higher-degree equation in the process. This paper translates Bring's original proof that the $x^4, x^3,$ and $x^2$ terms can be eliminated simultaneously using only quadratic and cubic auxiliary equations.

Methods

The paper is a modern mathematical translation. The authors take Bring’s 18th-century Latin and notation and map it onto modern algebraic language. The core technique discussed is the Tschirnhaus Transformation.

  1. Linear Substitutions: Bring starts by showing how a simple substitution ($z = y - a$) can remove the second term of any equation.
  2. Subsidiary Equations: To remove multiple terms, Bring introduces higher-degree subsidiary equations (e.g., $z^2 + bz + a + y = 0$).
  3. Elimination Theory: By substituting these into the original equation and using "the power of transformations," Bring sets up a system of equations for the parameters ($a, b, c, \dots$).
  4. Strategic Reduction: The "trick" lies in choosing the form of the subsidiary equation such that the resulting equations for the parameters do not exceed degree three, ensuring they remain solvable by standard methods of the time.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a work of pure mathematics and historical translation, it does not rely on empirical datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Bring-Jerrard Form: Bring successfully reduced the quintic to $x^5 + px + q = 0$. This specific trinomial form is now essential in the study of elliptic functions and modular forms.
  • Bring’s Curve: The conditions required to perform this reduction define a complex algebraic curve of genus 4 in $\mathbb{P}^4$. This curve is a "complete intersection" of three homogeneous polynomials of degrees 1, 2, and 3. It is mathematically famous for having the largest possible symmetry group ($S_5$) for a curve of its genus.
  • Defending Complex Numbers: A fascinating section of the treatise (Section IV) finds Bring defending the use of complex numbers. Contemporaries argued that a real root couldn't be "determined" by complex ones. Bring used Cardano’s formula for cubics to demonstrate that imaginary parts can cancel out to reveal a perfectly real solution, effectively arguing for the mathematical legitimacy of the complex plane.
  • Historical Priority: The paper highlights that Bring achieved this reduction in 1786, long before G. Jerrard (who usually gets the credit) rediscovered it in the 19th century.

Key Results

  • Simultaneous Elimination: Bring proved that for a quintic, one can eliminate the $z^4, z^3,$ and $z^2$ terms simultaneously.
  • The "Bad Becomes Worse" Paradox: Bring noted that while removing $M$ terms usually requires solving an equation of degree $M$, clever substitution can sometimes bypass this. However, he correctly intuited that removing three terms from a quartic (4th degree) actually leads to a 6th-degree equation, illustrating the limits of the method.
  • Accessibility: By providing this translation, the authors make a foundational text accessible to modern researchers who may be interested in the deep connections between Bring's curve and modern physics (like $E_8$ Lie groups and Moonshine theory).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this is a translation of a historical document; therefore, it reflects the mathematical limitations of 1786. Bring himself noted that his method could not remove all intermediate terms to solve the quintic directly (which we now know is impossible due to the structure of the Galois group $S_5$).

The translators suggest that the "wider significance" of Bring's work was only appreciated much later by mathematicians like Hermite and Klein. They point toward future work in exploring the connection between Bring’s curve and "dessins d’enfants," sporadic groups, and modular groups—areas where this 230-year-old algebra still resonates in modern theoretical physics and geometry.

Summary updated

Abstract

We translate Erland Samuel Bring's treatise Meletemata quaedam Mathematica circa Transformationem Aequationum Alebraicarum (Some selected mathematics on the Transformation of Algebraic Equations) written as his Promotionschrift at the University of Lund in 1786, from its Latin into English, with modern mathematical notation.Bring (1736 - 98) made important contributions to algebraic equations and obtained the canonical form x^5+px+q = 0 for quintics before Jerrard, Ruffini and Abel. In due course, he realized the significance of the projective curve which now bears his name: the complete intersection of the homogeneous Fermat polynomials of degrees 1,2,3 in CP^4.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2022erland,
  author = {Yang‐Hui He and John McKay and Alexander Chen},
  title = {{Erland Samuel Bring's "Transformation of Algebraic Equations"}},
  booktitle = {inSTEMM},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.56725/instemm.v1is1.7},
}

Loading related content...

Figure