Abstract
This research measures the epidemiological and economic impact of COVID-19 spread in the US under different mitigation scenarios, comprising of non-pharmaceutical interventions. A detailed disease model of COVID-19 is combined with a model of the US economy to estimate the direct impact of labor supply shock to each sector arising from morbidity, mortality, and lock down, as well as the indirect impact caused by the interdependencies between sectors. During a lockdown, estimates of jobs that are workable from home in each sector are used to modify the shock to labor supply. Results show trade-offs between economic losses, and lives saved and infections averted are non-linear in compliance to social distancing and the duration of lockdown. Sectors that are worst hit are not the labor-intensive sectors such as Agriculture and Construction, but the ones with high valued jobs such as Professional Services, even after the teleworkability of jobs is accounted for. Additionally, the findings show that a low compliance to interventions can be overcome by a longer shutdown period and vice versa to arrive at similar epidemiological impact but their net effect on economic loss depends on the interplay between the marginal gains from averting infections and deaths, versus the marginal loss from having healthy workers stay at home during the shutdown.
Introduction
During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, policymakers faced a grueling "dual-crisis": a public health emergency and a massive economic contraction. Most existing research at the time focused either on the spread of the virus or on macroeconomic shocks, but rarely both in a coupled, granular way. This paper addresses the challenge of quantifying how non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs)—like lockdowns and social distancing—simultaneously reduce infections and trigger labor supply shocks. Specifically, the study examines how these shocks ripple through the economy due to the interdependencies between 71 different industrial sectors, accounting for the fact that some jobs can be done from home while others cannot.
Integrated Modeling Framework
The researchers built a multi-layered simulation system to capture the feedback loops between public health and the economy. The framework consists of four primary components:
- Social Contact Network: A synthetic population based on US Census data where agents interact at home, work, and school.
- Epidemiological Model: An age-stratified SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered) model calibrated with CDC parameters to track health states, including hospitalization and ventilation.
- Economic Model (DIIM): The Dynamic Inoperability Input-Output Model, which captures how labor reductions in one sector affect its output and cascade into dependent sectors.
- Telework and Medical Costing: Integration of "teleworkability" data (the fraction of jobs that can transition to WFH) and direct societal burdens based on respiratory treatment costs.
Sector Interdependencies and Economic Cascades
A key insight of the study is the "Value Paradox." Counter-intuitively, labor-intensive sectors like Agriculture and Construction are not always the hardest hit economically. High-value sectors like Professional Services and Finance generate so much value per capita that even a small percentage drop in their labor supply results in massive total dollar losses, even after accounting for telework.
Economic loss is not merely a result of absenteeism; it is driven by "inoperability" that spreads when a sector cannot provide necessary inputs for its neighbors in the supply chain. The model uses 2018 BEA Input-Output tables to map these complex interdependencies across the US economy.
Key Results and Societal Impact
The simulation reveals that the relationship between lockdown duration, compliance, and economic loss is non-linear. For instance, increasing compliance from 60% to 70% might significantly reduce medical costs and absenteeism, potentially lowering total economic loss. However, moving from 80% to 90% may yield diminishing health returns while sharply increasing the economic penalty of staying at home.
- The Unmitigated Baseline: Without interventions, the model estimated over 116 million infections and 117,000 deaths (based on 2020 data), with a total economic hit of $1.15 trillion.
- The Optimized Scenario: A 45-day stay-home order with 90% compliance was identified as highly effective. While it results in a total economic loss of roughly $3.4 trillion, it saves over 110,000 lives compared to the unmitigated case.
- Net Societal Gain: By applying the US government’s "Value of a Statistical Life" ($10M per person), the researchers calculate that mitigation efforts result in a net gain of approximately $1.9 trillion compared to doing nothing.
Limitations and Future Outlook
The model primarily focuses on labor supply shocks and does not account for "demand-side" shocks, such as reduced consumer spending on travel or dining due to behavioral changes. Additionally, the Input-Output model assumes fixed prices, whereas a real economy would see price adjustments in response to scarcity. Future research could integrate the impact of vaccines and more dynamic behavioral responses as individuals react to real-time pandemic risks.
Summary updated