Abstract The shear shallow water model is an extension of the classical shallow water model to include the effects of vertical shear. It is a system of six non-linear hyperbolic PDE with non-conservative products. We develop a high-order entropy stable finite difference scheme for this model in one dimension and extend it to two dimensions on rectangular grids. The key idea is to rewrite the system so that non-conservative terms do not contribute to the entropy evolution. Then, we first develop an entropy conservative scheme for the conservative part, which is then extended to the complete system using the fact that the non-conservative terms do not contribute to the entropy production. The entropy dissipative scheme, which leads to an entropy inequality, is then obtained by carefully adding dissipative flux terms. The proposed schemes are then tested on several one and two-dimensional problems to demonstrate their stability and accuracy.
Introduction
Numerical modeling of water flows is a cornerstone of civil engineering and environmental science. While the classical Saint-Venant (shallow water) equations have served as the industry standard for decades, they possess a significant limitation: they assume a uniform horizontal velocity throughout the water depth, effectively ignoring vertical shear. In real-world scenarios, water does not move as a uniform block; it exhibits complex sliding and tumbling behaviors.
The Shear Shallow Water (SSW) model, derived by Teshukov, addresses this by incorporating second-order velocity fluctuations. This results in a system of six non-linear hyperbolic partial differential equations (PDEs). However, this increased physical fidelity introduces significant numerical challenges, specifically regarding non-conservative products and numerical stability near shocks.
Methodology
Developing a robust solver for the SSW model requires overcoming the mathematical ambiguity of non-conservative terms, where weak solutions depend on the specific path taken through a jump. The authors propose a high-order entropy stable finite difference framework using a three-step approach:
- Entropy Conservative Flux for the Core: The researchers identified that the conservative portion of the SSW model is mathematically identical to the Ten-moment Gaussian closure model used in gas dynamics. This allowed for the adaptation of existing entropy-conservative fluxes to the SSW core.
- Handling Non-Conservative Terms: A pivotal insight of this work is the proof that gravitational non-conservative terms are "entropy-neutral"—they do not contribute to the entropy evolution equation. This allows the extension of the conservative flux to the full SSW system without compromising entropy consistency.
- Entropy-Scaled Dissipation: To prevent non-physical oscillations (wiggles) near shocks, the authors added dissipative terms based on entropy-scaled eigenvectors. This ensures that the discrete system satisfies the second law of thermodynamics (entropy inequality), where entropy always decays or remains constant at the numerical level.
To achieve high-order spatial accuracy (up to 4th order), the scheme employs Essentially Non-Oscillatory (ENO) reconstructions, paired with Strong Stability Preserving Runge-Kutta (SSP-RK) methods for time integration.
Results and Validation
The proposed schemes were validated through a series of numerical experiments ranging from theoretical convergence tests to physical comparisons:
- Order of Accuracy: Simulations using O2_ES, O3_ES, and O4_ES schemes confirmed theoretical convergence rates. For instance, the 4th-order scheme demonstrated a sixteen-fold error reduction when the grid resolution was doubled.
- Stability and Entropy Decay: Dam break tests confirmed the "entropy stable" property, with total entropy showing monotonic decay over time, even in the presence of strong shocks.
- Roll Wave Capture: The SSW model, powered by these new schemes, was compared against the classic experimental data of Brock (1969, 1970). Unlike classical models that often fail to predict specific surge profiles, the SSW results showed excellent agreement with experimental roll wave steepening and surges.
- 2D Complexity: In two-dimensional simulations, higher-order schemes (O3 and O4) successfully captured intricate flow features, including small-scale turbulent structures in roll waves that were entirely smoothed out by lower-order methods.
Conclusion
This work introduces the first high-order entropy stable schemes for the shear shallow water model. By exploiting the entropy-neutral nature of gravitational terms, the authors have created a solver that is both mathematically rigorous and physically accurate. Future work will focus on extending these properties to unstructured meshes to accommodate the complex geometries of real-world riverbanks and coastlines.
Reference: Yadav, A., Bhoriya, D., Kumar, H., & Chandrashekar, P. (2023). Entropy stable schemes for the shear shallow water model Equations. arXiv:2310.00353v1 [math.NA].
Summary updated