Abstract
Non-classical two-step nucleation including preordering and crystal nucleation has been widely proposed to challenge the one-step nucleation framework in diverse materials, while what drives preordering has not been explicitly resolved yet. With molecular dynamics simulation, we find that two-step nucleation occurs in polyethylene, during which preordering precedes through the coupling between intrachain conformation and interchain orientation orders. Unexpectedly, preordering is driven by entropy rather than enthalpy, during which the interchain translational entropy gain compensates for the intrachain conformation entropy loss. This entropy-driven mechanism resolves the longstanding puzzle why flexible polymers with high entropy penalty still show high nucleation rate and opens a new perspective for understanding nucleation of synthetic and bio-polymers with conformation and orientation orders.
Introduction
In classical nucleation theory (CNT), a crystal forms from a disordered melt in a single, direct step. However, recent observations in proteins, minerals, and polymers suggest a "non-classical" two-step pathway: the initial formation of a dense or semi-ordered "preorder" cluster, which subsequently matures into a crystalline state.
For flexible polymers like polyethylene (PE), this process presents a thermodynamic paradox. Crystallization requires floppy polymer chains to straighten into rigid segments, a process involving a massive loss in conformational entropy. Theoretically, this "entropy penalty" should create a significant barrier, leading to slow nucleation. Yet, PE nucleates remarkably fast, making it nearly impossible to quench into a purely amorphous glass. This study utilizes molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to identify the hidden driving force that facilitates this rapid nucleation during the preordering stage.
Methodology
The researchers employed Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations to observe the atomic-level early stages of PE crystallization. A refined "united atom" force field was used, treating $CH_2$ and $CH_3$ groups as single particles for computational efficiency. The system comprised 250 chains of 400 carbon atoms (C400), equilibrated at 600 K and then quenched to 300 K to induce crystallization.
To characterize the structural evolution, several order parameters were tracked:
- Intrachain order: Fraction of trans conformations ($C_{tt}$) and the length of continuous trans segments ($L_{tt}$).
- Interchain order: Local density ($\rho$), local orientation ($P_2$), and bond orientation ($q_6$).
The free energy gap ($\Delta f$) was decomposed into enthalpy ($\Delta h$) and entropy ($\Delta s$) components to pinpoint the thermodynamic driving forces.
Results and Discussion
The Two-Step Nucleation Path
Simulation data reveals a clear transition from a disordered melt to a preorder cluster, and finally to a crystal. An induction period of approximately 460 ns was identified, during which preordering occurs before formal crystallization begins (at $t > 560$ ns).
Entropy as the Primary Driver
A key finding is that the first step—preordering—is driven by entropy rather than enthalpy. During this phase, the enthalpy gain is negligible, yet the total free energy decreases. This is explained by a "mutual compensation" mechanism: as chains straighten and lose conformational entropy, they become rod-like. According to Onsager’s lyotropic liquid crystal theory, these rigid segments gain significant translational entropy due to excluded volume effects—they can pack and move more efficiently when aligned.
The researchers found a strong Pearson correlation between chain conformation ($L_{tt}$) and orientation ($P_2$), suggesting that the gain in translational entropy from orientation effectively offsets the loss in conformational entropy from chain straightening. Enthalpy only becomes the dominant driving force during the second step, as the preorder cluster transitions into a final crystalline structure.
Conclusion
This study resolves the mystery of rapid nucleation in flexible polymers by identifying an entropy-driven preordering stage. The coupling between conformational and orientational orders allows the system to bypass the high barriers predicted by classical theory. While this model was developed for polyethylene, it may have broader implications for understanding non-classical nucleation in other complex systems, such as proteins, which also exhibit coupled structural ordering. Future experimental work using advanced X-ray scattering or microscopy will be essential to directly observe these transient, nanometer-scale preorder clusters.
Summary updated