Enlightenment, Revolution and the periodical press. Edited by Hans-Jürgen Lüsebrink and Jeremy D. Popkin

Péter BalázsStudi 2006 · DOI

The 18th-century periodical press has long been relegated to the sidelines of historical study, often viewed as a secondary record of "greater" literary and political movements. However, a significant volume edited by Hans-Jürgen Lüsebrink and Jeremy D. Popkin, reviewed by Peter Balazs, challenges this marginalization. By positioning the press not merely as a record but as a primary engine of the Enlightenment and the French Revolution, the contributors provide a multi-disciplinary re-evaluation of how information shaped an era.

The Problem of Intermediality

Historically, scholars struggled with the "intermediality" of the 18th century—the messy, overlapping space where oral communication, private letters, and printed journals collided. This collection addresses how the press functioned as a tool for civic education, a weapon for political factions, and a medium for "cultural transfer" across European borders, including France, Sweden, Portugal, Germany, and the United Kingdom. The central inquiry focuses on how the medium of the periodical actually shaped the Enlightenment and the subsequent Revolutionary era rather than just reflecting it.

Methodological Approaches

The contributors employ a diverse array of historical and literary methodologies to dissect the influence of the press:

  • Intermedial Analysis: This involves examining the transition and interaction between manuscript letters and printed journals, notably in the study of Albrecht von Haller’s extensive correspondence.
  • Rhetorical and Semantic Tracking: Researchers investigated the "journalist-orator" persona during the French Revolution, where print was used to create a democratic public space. Quantitative methods were also applied to German immigrant newspapers in Alsace to map the evolution of political ideas.
  • Archival Research: Unearthing "nouvelles à la main" (handwritten newsletters) allowed scholars to understand how information bypassed official state censorship in regions like Portugal.

Key Insights: The Press as a Social Force

The research reveals several critical insights into the function of 18th-century media:

The Shadow Press

In Portugal and France, manuscript newsletters were essential. Because they were not "printed" in the traditional sense, they often escaped the strictest censorship. This allowed for the propagation of military and political news that official gazettes were forced to ignore, creating a parallel information network that functioned alongside official channels.

Journalism as Moral Education

Following the model of the British Spectator, many 18th-century editors did not see themselves as objective reporters. Instead, they acted as "moral magistrates," aiming to educate the public's character and foster a "civic spirit." This pedagogical role was central to the Enlightenment project of creating an informed citizenry.

The Hybridity of Communication

The rise of the press did not signal the death of older communication forms. The "Republic of Letters" survived through a hybrid system where private letters fed journal content, and journals, in turn, sparked further private correspondence. This synergy ensured that the press remained deeply integrated into the social fabric of both the elite and the emerging middle class.

Revolutionary Results and Transnational Impact

The volume highlights a mix of continuity and rupture. While the French Revolution radically changed the content of the press, many rhetorical strategies—such as the "journalist-orator" style—were rooted in the pamphlets and oral traditions of the late Ancien Régime.

Furthermore, the press served as a transnational battleground. In Britain, the "Tory" press (1800–1832) reacted deeply to "French Philosophy," using apocalyptic rhetoric to warn against the spread of revolutionary ideals. Conversely, in Alsace, German "Jacobin" refugees published numerous journals that served as cultural bridges, even if their political opinions were often more eclectic than radical.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the volume is a collection of specific case studies rather than a singular unified theory, it provides a well-documented foundation for future research. Promising directions include further exploration of the "interculturality" of the press—how news was transformed as it crossed linguistic borders—and deeper analysis of the long-term psychological impact of counter-revolutionary journalism on European conservatism. Ultimately, the work demonstrates that to understand the Enlightenment and the Revolution, one must first understand the medium that carried their messages.

Summary updated

Abstract

Depuis quelques années les recherches poursuivies dans le domaine de l’histoire des périodiques ont révélé le rôle extrêmement important que les feuilles, les journaux et les revues ont joué au siècle des Lumières. Les deux éditeurs du présent volume ont sélectionné des articles qui étudient l’implication de la presse périodique dans la politique et dans la culture des pays européens au siècle des Lumières et dans l’ère révolutionnaire. L’introduction de Jeremy D. Popkin et de Jack Censer (So...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{balazs2006enlightenment,
  author = {Péter Balázs},
  title = {{Enlightenment, Revolution and the periodical press. Edited by Hans-Jürgen Lüsebrink and Jeremy D. Popkin}},
  booktitle = {Studi},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.4000/studifrancesi.30286},
}
Figure