Enigmatic epistemic things

Anne H. Schistad SolbergFormAkademisk 2020 · DOI

Abstract

The aim of this article is to discuss epistemology, focusing on the epistemic role of artwork in research projects. Porcelaneous is the initial phase of a three-year artistic research project with an artistic component comprising the making of porcelain boards. The porcelain boards and the making process in this initial phase are used as examples from practice. At the core of the epistemological discussion is Hans-Jörg Rheinberger’s theory on experimental systems and epistemic things. Rheinberger advocates for an objective and practice-oriented approach rather than a theoretical approach to experimental research. In his setting, epistemic things are material. This article concludes that Rheinberger’s theory is about attitudes rather than research methods and that this attitude to epistemological questions is relevant for artistic research.

Introduction: The Epistemic Status of Art

In the academic landscape, a persistent tension exists between traditional scientific doctorates and the burgeoning field of artistic research. A central point of debate revolves around the "epistemic status" of the artwork: Is the art merely a final result of research, or is the act of making the art a valid method of research in itself?

Author Anne Solberg addresses the challenge of defining how "not-yet-known" knowledge is produced within a studio setting. Artistic expression is inherently "enigmatic" and often resists verbalization, making it difficult to justify under traditional academic rubrics that prioritize linear progress and explicit research questions. This paper seeks a theoretical bridge that respects the material reality of art-making while satisfying the rigors of doctoral-level inquiry.

Theoretical Framework: Rheinberger’s Experimental Systems

The paper adopts Hans-Jörg Rheinberger’s theory of experimental systems as its primary lens. Originally developed to describe laboratory sciences, such as protein synthesis, this theory posits that knowledge is generated through "material interference" rather than purely theoretical reflection.

A key distinction in Rheinberger’s view is between epistemic things and technical objects. An "epistemic thing" is the object of inquiry—the entity that is not yet fully understood and embodies the "not-yet-known." Conversely, a "technical object" is a stable tool, instrument, or mastered method (like a kiln or a proven clay recipe) that provides the conditions for the experiment. These roles are dynamic; once a technique is mastered, it moves from being an epistemic thing to a technical object, clearing the path for new, more complex inquiries.

Case Study: The Porcelaneous Project

Solberg utilizes her own three-year project—creating hand-built porcelain boards—as a "practice field" to test these theories. The research documents an iterative process of material engagement.

The Porcelaneous Project: Documentation of the 'Fracture Series' and the tactile process of hand-building porcelain boards.

The project involved several distinct phases:

  1. Sketching: Using paper as a low-cost "experiment of imagination" to visualize semi-transparent shapes.
  2. Material Testing: Transitioning from small 30x30 cm tiles to larger 40x40 cm boards. This increase in scale introduced significant technical failures, most notably cracking.
  3. Problem-Solving as Research: In this framework, technical hurdles like fractures are not viewed as failures but as critical data points. These "material interferences" refine the experimental system and force the researcher to engage more deeply with the material's limits.
Iterative sketches from the 'Hazy Square' series, serving as experiments of imagination.

Key Insights: Knowledge as a By-product

Innovation in both art and science often arises as a surprise from the "experimental machinery" rather than as a pre-determined goal. Solberg highlights the concept of bifurcations: small experiments often lead to unexpected "off-spring" lines of inquiry. For instance, a failed attempt to achieve a smooth surface led to the exploration of three-dimensional, kneaded textures as a new research direction.

Furthermore, the "non-identity" or "enigmatic" nature of an artwork is precisely what makes it a potent research tool. Its incompleteness leaves room for the "un-thought," allowing the researcher to move beyond what can be easily articulated in words and into the realm of embodied, tacit knowledge.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study successfully demonstrates that Rheinberger’s "experimental systems" provide a fruitful vocabulary for describing small-scale studio practice. A pivotal "aha" moment occurred when Solberg realized that four separate boards functioned as a single, unified narrative installation, redirecting the project toward monumental, multi-part works.

While Solberg acknowledges that studio experiments may seem small compared to the grand research networks Rheinberger originally described, she argues that these minor experiments should be integrated into larger "patchworks of research." This approach increases transparency and knowledge sharing in the arts. As the Porcelaneous Project moves past initial technical problem-solving, subsequent research will explore more complex aesthetic and philosophical expressions of these material "epistemic things."

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of this article is to discuss epistemology, focusing on the epistemic role of artwork in research projects. Porcelaneous is the initial phase of a three-year artistic research project with an artistic component comprising the making of porcelain boards. The porcelain boards and the making process in this initial phase are used as examples from practice. At the core of the epistemological discussion is Hans-Jörg Rheinberger’s theory on experimental systems and epistemic things. Rheinberger advocates for an objective and practice-oriented approach rather than a theoretical approach to experimental research. In his setting, epistemic things are material. This article has concluded that Rheinberger’s theory is about attitudes rather than research methods and that this attitude to epistemological questions is relevant for artistic research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{solberg2020enigmatic,
  author = {Anne H. Schistad Solberg},
  title = {{Enigmatic epistemic things}},
  booktitle = {FormAkademisk},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.7577/formakademisk.3543},
}
Figure