Artistic Expression and Material Limitations

Anne H. Schistad SolbergFormAkademisk 2021 · DOI

Artistic Expression and Material Limitations

Abstract

This paper explores the iterative process of striving for artistic expressivity and developing crafting techniques in a porcelain-making project. The paper is about mitigating the tensions and flaws in porcelain bodies by trying out technical solutions while searching for genuine porcelaneous expressivity in artmaking. The paper presents examples of a working process of material-based art, from the first samples of material collapse to an exhibition of finished works in an art gallery, allowing the reader to see how faults and failures contribute to this development. The paper advocates that craft science and artistic research are closely integrated and intertwined.

Introduction: The Porcelaneous Project

The "Porcelaneous Project" is an artistic research initiative that bridges the gap between craft science and engineering to master the volatile nature of porcelain. Porcelain is a notoriously "fickle" material, characterized by high shrinkage rates and extreme sensitivity to internal tensions during drying and firing. This research documents an iterative process of failure and refinement, demonstrating how material limitations—specifically fracture mechanics and drying tensions—directly shape and define the boundaries of artistic expression.

The Challenge of Scale

A primary technical hurdle addressed in this study is the scaling of porcelain boards. While 30x30 cm tiles are technically manageable, increasing the size to 40x40 cm introduces a "material collapse" threshold. The author chose to pursue these larger dimensions despite the high failure rate because the smaller tiles lacked the desired expressive impact, appearing too much like industrial "bathroom tiles." This highlights a core tenet of artistic research: technical ease is often sacrificed for expressive necessity.

Methodology: The "Inside-In" Approach

The research employs an "inside-in" experimental approach, where the artist acts as the primary researcher, gaining knowledge through direct practice. Key techniques include iterative prototyping, moving through cycles of hand-building, casting, and firing to identify failure points.

The iterative process of the Porcelaneous Project, showing material layering, manual manipulation, and resulting fractures.

The artist utilized traditional Japanese techniques like Nerikomi and Intarsia—layering colored clays to create patterns—while analyzing why these composite structures often lead to delamination and cracking. By applying fracture mechanics and materials science theory to diagnose these artistic failures, the research bridges the gap between studio intuition and formal science.

The paper suggests that the artist must work with the material rather than against it. Through repeated failure, the crafter develops a "bodily feeling" for the limits of the clay—knowing exactly how far a 3D structure can be pushed before it collapses under its own weight during the sintering process. For example, the discovery that edges must be smoothed to avoid "trigger points" for fractures led to a significant shift in the intended aesthetic of the work.

Results: From Collapse to Exhibition

Despite initial total material collapses, the project successfully produced a series of 40x40 cm porcelain boards for exhibition. A key qualitative result was the "Viral Bat" triptych, where the artist deviated from a continuous design to a framed design to prevent edge-to-edge fracture propagation.

A 40x40 cm porcelain board exhibiting severe edge-to-edge fracture propagation during the drying process.

The final works were displayed in custom-engineered steel frames with 0.3 mm wires, emphasizing the "thingness" and weight of the porcelain. In a final subversion of craft perfectionism, the author presented a cracked piece coated in silver—the "Honour of the Unfortunate"—suggesting that material failure itself can be reclaimed as a valid artistic expression.

Conclusion

The "inside-in" perspective allows the artist-researcher to see how faults and failures are not just obstacles, but essential contributors to the development of craft knowledge. While the findings are specific to the ceramic bodies used, the project underscores the necessity of integrating scientific analysis with artistic practice to push the boundaries of material-based art.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper explores the iterative process of striving for artistic expressivity and developing crafting techniques in a porcelain-making project. The paper is about mitigating the tensions and flaws in porcelain bodies by trying out technical solutions while searching for genuine porcelaneous expressivity in artmaking. The paper presents examples of a working process of material-based art, from the first samples of material collapse to an exhibition of finished works in an art gallery, allowing the reader to see how faults and failures contribute to this development. The paper advocates that craft science and artistic research are closely integrated and intertwined.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{solberg2021artistic,
  author = {Anne H. Schistad Solberg},
  title = {{Artistic Expression and Material Limitations}},
  booktitle = {FormAkademisk},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.7577/formakademisk.4192},
}
Figure