Enhanced User Grouping and Pairing Schemes for CoMP NOMA based Cellular Networks

Akhileswar Chowdary, Garima Chopra, Abhinav Kumar, Linga Reddy Cenkeramaddi

Introduction

As cellular networks transition toward 6G, they face the conflicting requirements of massive data rates and ubiquitous coverage. Two primary technologies have emerged to address these needs: Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) for high spectral efficiency and Coordinated Multi-Point (CoMP) for improving the reliability of cell-edge users. While NOMA excels at boosting throughput by allowing multiple users to share resources, CoMP enhances coverage by coordinating multiple base stations to serve "weak" users. However, combining these technologies introduces significant mathematical complexity, particularly in user pairing and interference management.

System model of a CoMP-NOMA network with randomly distributed base stations and users.

Proposed Methodology

This paper proposes a novel user grouping and pairing strategy that integrates CoMP and NOMA to achieve a superior trade-off between high-speed throughput and reliable network coverage. The researchers developed a system model based on a Poisson Point Process (PPP) to simulate realistic, random distributions of base stations and users. The proposed scheme follows a three-step process:

  1. User Classification: Users are categorized based on their signal strength. If a user's signal falls below a specific threshold ($\gamma_{th}$), they are designated as a CoMP user. Otherwise, they are classified as a non-CoMP user.
  2. Intra-Group Pairing: To reduce complexity, the scheme restricts NOMA pairing to occur within specific groups. CoMP users are grouped together (G1), while non-CoMP users associated with specific base stations form separate groups (G2b). An Adaptive User Pairing (AUP) algorithm is then applied within these groups based on the Minimum SINR Difference (MSD).
  3. Fair Scheduling: An $\alpha$-fair scheduler is employed to allocate time fractions to these pairs, ensuring balanced resource distribution across the network.

By avoiding cross-group pairing (e.g., pairing a CoMP user with a non-CoMP user), the authors simplify Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) processes while maintaining high performance.

Experimental Evaluation and Results

The performance of the proposed scheme was evaluated using Monte Carlo simulations in MATLAB, covering a 25 $km^2$ area. The scheme was compared against three benchmarks: Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA), CoMP-only, and NOMA-only systems.

Average throughput comparison across different user densities ($\lambda_u$) and base station configurations ($\lambda_b$).

The results demonstrate that the proposed CoMP-NOMA scheme effectively bridges the gap between pure NOMA and pure CoMP technologies:

  • Throughput Performance: The proposed scheme significantly outperformed CoMP-only systems in terms of average throughput, particularly at low to moderate user densities. As shown in the results, the throughput gains are most pronounced when the network is less crowded.
  • Coverage Reliability: The scheme maintained a coverage rate of approximately 99.9% across various signal thresholds. This vastly outperforms NOMA-only systems, which typically suffer from coverage drops as signal requirements become more stringent.
  • Density Sensitivity: The benefits of the grouping strategy are most evident at lower user densities. As user density increases, the time fraction available for non-CoMP users decreases, leading the performance to converge toward that of standard CoMP systems.

Conclusion

The proposed user grouping and pairing strategy provides a "Goldilocks" solution for next-generation networks, offering higher speeds than CoMP and greater reliability than NOMA. While the current study focused on intra-group pairing to manage complexity, future research could explore hybrid pairing (CoMP and non-CoMP users) to further enhance efficiency. Additionally, the integration of Machine Learning could allow for dynamic tuning of signal thresholds and scheduling parameters, enabling real-time network self-optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) has been identified as one of the promising technologies to enhance the spectral efficiency and throughput for the fifth generation (5G) and beyond 5G cellular networks. Alternatively, Coordinated multi-point transmission and reception (CoMP) improves the cell edge users’ coverage. Thus, CoMP and NOMA can be used together to improve the overall coverage and throughput of the users. However, user grouping and pairing for CoMP-NOMA-based cellular networks have not been suitably studied in the existing literature. Motivated by this, we propose a user grouping and pairing scheme for a CoMP-NOMA-based system. Detailed numerical results are presented comparing the proposed scheme with the purely OMA-based benchmark system, NOMA only, and CoMP only systems. We show through simulation results that the proposed scheme offers a trade-off between throughput and coverage as compared to the existing NOMA or CoMP based system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chowdary2022enhanced,
  author = {Akhileswar Chowdary and Garima Chopra and Abhinav Kumar and Linga Reddy Cenkeramaddi},
  title = {{Enhanced User Grouping and Pairing Schemes for CoMP NOMA based Cellular Networks}},
  booktitle = {COMSNETS},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=uZhbz4gdGN},
}
Figure