Engineering the pore environment of antiparallel stacked covalent organic frameworks for capture of iodine pollutants

Yinghui Xie, Qiuyu Rong, Fengyi Mao, Shi-Yu Wang, You Wu, Xiaolu Liu, Mengjie Hao, Zhongshan Chen, Hui Yang, Geoffrey I. N. Waterhouse, Shengqian Ma, Xiangke WangNature Communications 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have engineered a new class of covalent organic frameworks (COFs) with a unique "antiparallel" stacking geometry that creates highly efficient "nanotraps" for radioactive iodine. These materials (ACOF-1 and its cationic derivative ACOF-1R) demonstrate record-breaking dynamic capture of gaseous iodine and organic iodides, as well as the ability to rapidly decontaminate triiodide-polluted groundwater to drinking levels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nuclear power is a critical low-carbon energy source, but managing its waste—specifically radioactive iodine isotopes like $^{129}$I and $^{131}$I—is a major environmental challenge. These pollutants exist in several difficult-to-capture forms: volatile molecular iodine ($I_2$), organic iodides like methyl iodide ($CH_3I$), and ionic species like triiodide ($I_3^-$) in water.

Current adsorbents often struggle with "dynamic" conditions (where gas or water flows continuously) or lose efficiency in the presence of humidity and competing ions. Furthermore, materials used in nuclear environments must be exceptionally robust, resisting high doses of radiation and harsh chemical conditions (acidic or basic). This paper tackles the need for a versatile, stable, and high-capacity adsorbent that works across all these iodine species.

Methods

The authors synthesized a novel framework called ACOF-1 using a solvothermal reaction between two specific organic building blocks (BTPA and DBTH).

Key Innovations in Design: * Antiparallel Stacking: Unlike traditional COFs where layers stack directly on top of each other (AA stacking), ACOF-1 layers are offset in an "antiparallel" fashion. This prevents binding sites from being "shadowed" by adjacent layers, creating three-dimensional "multi-N nanotrap sites." * Cooperative Binding: The framework combines pyridine-N and hydrazine groups. Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations showed these groups work together to increase the binding affinity for iodine molecules. * Post-Synthetic Modification: To target ionic iodine in water, the researchers used "methylation" to convert the neutral pyridine sites in ACOF-1 into cationic pyridinium sites, creating ACOF-1R. This version uses ion exchange to grab $I_3^-$ ions.

The team used a comprehensive suite of tools to verify the structure, including Powder X-ray Diffraction (PXRD), HRTEM imaging, and advanced X-ray scattering (SAXS/WAXS).

Datasets

As a materials chemistry paper, the "datasets" consist of experimental performance benchmarks compared against state-of-the-art materials:

  • Adsorption Isotherms: Measuring total capacity for $I_2$ and $CH_3I$.
  • Breakthrough Curves: Testing how long the material can filter a continuous stream of polluted gas or water before failing.
  • Stability Tests: Exposure to 400 kGy of $\gamma$-ray radiation and immersion in 12 M $HNO_3$ and 12 M $NaOH$.
  • Comparison Tables: The authors compared their results against dozens of previously reported materials (MOFs, zeolites, and other COFs).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometry Matters: The "aha moment" is that the stacking arrangement of the 2D sheets is just as important as the chemical groups themselves. By shifting the layers (antiparallel stacking), they exposed significantly more nitrogen atoms to the pore environment, creating a "nanotrap" effect.
  • Dual-Purpose Design: The study shows that a single parent framework can be tuned for different phases of waste management: the neutral version for gaseous off-gas streams and the cationic version for aqueous decontamination.
  • Extreme Robustness: The materials maintained their crystalline structure and capture efficiency even after massive radiation doses (400 kGy) and extreme pH conditions, which is a prerequisite for real-world nuclear fuel reprocessing.

Key Results

  • Gaseous Capture (ACOF-1): Achieved a dynamic adsorption capacity of ~2.16 g/g for $I_2$ and ~0.74 g/g for $CH_3I$ at 25 °C. The $CH_3I$ performance is among the best reported to date for any porous material.
  • Aqueous Capture (ACOF-1R): Demonstrated a massive uptake capacity of ~4.46 g/g for $I_3^-$ in column breakthrough tests.
  • Water Purification: ACOF-1R successfully decontaminated $I_3^-$-polluted groundwater to levels safe for drinking, even in the presence of competing ions like $Cl^-$, $SO_4^{2-}$, and $NO_3^-$.
  • Recyclability: The materials could be regenerated and reused for multiple cycles with minimal loss in performance.

Limitations and Future Work

While the performance is exceptional, the paper does not extensively discuss the cost of synthesis at an industrial scale. The organic linkers used (BTPA and DBTH) require multi-step synthesis, which might be more expensive than simpler adsorbents like activated carbon.

Future work could focus on:

  1. Scaling up the production of these "antiparallel" COFs.
  2. Testing performance with "real" complex nuclear waste streams that contain a mixture of many different radionuclides simultaneously.
  3. Exploring if this stacking strategy can be applied to capture other hazardous gases like $CO_2$ or $NO_x$.

Summary updated

Abstract

Radioiodine capture from nuclear fuel waste and contaminated water sources is of enormous environmental importance, but remains technically challenging. Herein, we demonstrate robust covalent organic frameworks (COFs) with antiparallel stacked structures, excellent radiation resistance, and high binding affinities toward I<sub>2</sub>, CH<sub>3</sub>I, and I<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup> under various conditions. A neutral framework (ACOF-1) achieves a high affinity through the cooperative functions of pyridine-N and hydrazine groups from antiparallel stacking layers, resulting in a high capacity of ~2.16 g/g for I<sub>2</sub> and ~0.74 g/g for CH<sub>3</sub>I at 25 °C under dynamic adsorption conditions. Subsequently, post-synthetic methylation of ACOF-1 converted pyridine-N sites to cationic pyridinium moieties, yielding a cationic framework (namely ACOF-1R) with enhanced capacity for triiodide ion capture from contaminated water. ACOF-1R can rapidly decontaminate iodine polluted groundwater to drinking levels with a high uptake capacity of ~4.46 g/g established through column breakthrough tests. The cooperative functions of specific binding moieties make ACOF-1 and ACOF-1R promising adsorbents for radioiodine pollutants treatment under practical conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2024engineering,
  author = {Yinghui Xie and Qiuyu Rong and Fengyi Mao and Shi-Yu Wang and You Wu and Xiaolu Liu and Mengjie Hao and Zhongshan Chen and Hui Yang and Geoffrey I. N. Waterhouse and Shengqian Ma and Xiangke Wang},
  title = {{Engineering the pore environment of antiparallel stacked covalent organic frameworks for capture of iodine pollutants}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-46942-0},
}
Figure