Energy Harvesting Hybrid Acoustic-Optical Underwater Wireless Sensor Networks Localization

Nasir Saeed, Abdulkadir Celik, Tareq Y. Al-Naffouri, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel localization technique for underwater wireless sensor networks (UWSNs) that combines acoustic and optical communication, leveraging the strengths of both for improved data rates and coverage. Crucially, it incorporates energy harvesting to extend network lifetime and a weighted multiple observation approach to enhance localization accuracy in noisy environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Exploring the ocean is vital, but underwater communication faces significant hurdles. Acoustic communication offers long-range connectivity but suffers from low data rates, high latency, and power consumption, with potential negative impacts on marine life. Optical communication provides high data rates but is limited to short distances. Furthermore, underwater sensor nodes are typically battery-powered, making energy consumption and battery replacement a major challenge for long-term deployments. Accurately knowing the location of these sensors is paramount for their data to be useful. This paper tackles the problem of achieving reliable and energy-efficient localization in underwater environments by proposing a hybrid acoustic-optical approach that integrates energy harvesting and a robust localization algorithm.

Methods

The proposed solution, termed AO-UWSN (Acoustic-Optical Underwater Wireless Sensor Network), employs a two-tiered communication strategy:

  • Optical Communication: Used for high-data-rate communication over short distances between nearby nodes.
  • Acoustic Communication: Used for command and control signals over longer distances, where high data rates are not critical.

The core of the localization technique is a hybrid Received Signal Strength (RSS) based approach. It combines noisy RSS measurements from both acoustic and optical links. To mitigate the impact of noise and improve accuracy, a weighted multiple observations paradigm is introduced. This method assigns different weights to various observations, prioritizing more accurate ones. The paper also derives the closed-form solution for the Cramer-Rao Lower Bound (CRLB), providing a theoretical benchmark for the localization accuracy. The optimization problem is solved by decomposing it into two sub-problems: updating the node locations (L) for fixed observation weights and updating the observation weights (Φ(u)) for fixed node locations. Energy harvesting is considered as a means to provide power to the sensor nodes, impacting network lifetime and localization efficiency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulated data generated using MATLAB for performance evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybrid Communication is Key: Combining acoustic and optical communication effectively addresses the trade-offs between range and data rate in underwater environments.
  • Energy Harvesting is Crucial for Longevity: Integrating energy harvesting is not just about powering nodes but directly impacts the efficiency and feasibility of long-term underwater sensor networks.
  • Multiple Observations Enhance Robustness: Leveraging multiple, potentially noisy, range measurements and intelligently weighting them significantly improves localization accuracy, especially in challenging acoustic channels.
  • Theoretical Bounds Inform Design: Deriving the CRLB provides a valuable theoretical limit, guiding the design and evaluation of localization algorithms.

Key Results

The paper presents simulation results demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed AO-UWSN localization technique.

  • Improved Accuracy: The multiple observation approach consistently yields a smaller error function compared to single observation methods, particularly in scenarios with higher noise variance.
  • Efficiency Gains: The efficiency of the localization technique improves with increased energy harvested from ambient underwater sources.
  • Performance Comparison: The proposed technique outperforms existing methods like multidimensional scaling and manifold regularization, especially in noisy conditions. For instance, in one scenario, the mean square error was reduced to $2.3 \times 10^{-6}$ m with multiple observations, compared to values in the order of $10^{-4}$ m for single observations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Line-of-Sight Assumption: The optical ranging model assumes line-of-sight communication, which may not always be feasible in complex underwater environments.
  • Simulation-Based: The results are based on simulations, and real-world deployment may introduce additional complexities.
  • Energy Harvesting Model: While energy harvesting is incorporated, the specific models and their integration with the localization algorithm could be further refined.

The authors suggest future work could explore more advanced energy harvesting techniques and investigate the impact of non-line-of-sight scenarios on the localization performance. Further research into adaptive weighting strategies for the multiple observations could also yield additional improvements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Underwater wireless technologies demand to transmit at higher data rate for ocean exploration. Currently, large coverage is achieved by acoustic sensor networks with low data rate, high cost, high latency, high power consumption, and negative impact on marine mammals. Meanwhile, optical communication for underwater networks has the advantage of the higher data rate albeit for limited communication distances. Moreover, energy consumption is another major problem for underwater sensor networks, due to limited battery power and difficulty in replacing or recharging the battery of a sensor node. The ultimate solution to this problem is to add energy harvesting capability to the acoustic-optical sensor nodes. Localization of underwater sensor networks is of utmost importance because the data collected from underwater sensor nodes is useful only if the location of the nodes is known. Therefore, a novel localization technique for energy harvesting hybrid acoustic-optical underwater wireless sensor networks (AO-UWSNs) is proposed. AO-UWSN employs optical communication for higher data rate at a short transmission distance and employs acoustic communication for low data rate and long transmission distance. A hybrid received signal strength (RSS) based localization technique is proposed to localize the nodes in AO-UWSNs. The proposed technique combines the noisy RSS based measurements from acoustic communication and optical communication and estimates the final locations of acoustic-optical sensor nodes. A weighted multiple observations paradigm is proposed for hybrid estimated distances to suppress the noisy observations and give more importance to the accurate observations. Furthermore, the closed form solution for Cramer-Rao lower bound (CRLB) is derived for localization accuracy of the proposed technique.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{saeed2018energy,
  author = {Nasir Saeed and Abdulkadir Celik and Tareq Y. Al-Naffouri and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Energy Harvesting Hybrid Acoustic-Optical Underwater Wireless Sensor Networks Localization}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=gdOw0lnDxp},
}
Figure