End-to-end Learning, with or without Labels

Corinne Jones, Vincent Roulet, Zaïd HarchaouiarXiv 2019 · arXiv · OpenReview

Abstract

We present an approach for end-to-end learning that allows one to jointly learn a feature representation from unlabeled data (with or without labeled data) and predict labels for unlabeled data. The feature representation is assumed to be specified in a differentiable programming framework, that is, as a parameterized mapping amenable to automatic differentiation. The proposed approach can be used with any amount of labeled and unlabeled data, gracefully adjusting to the amount of supervision. We provide experimental results illustrating the effectiveness of the approach.

Introduction

In machine learning, a fundamental challenge lies in bridging the gap between supervised learning, which requires extensive labeled datasets, and unsupervised learning, which seeks to identify patterns without explicit guidance. Semi-supervised learning occupies the "messy middle," often proving difficult to implement effectively in high-dimensional spaces. Traditional clustering methods like k-means often struggle with complex geometric structures unless features are manually engineered. X-Supervised Discriminative Clustering (XSDC) addresses these issues by providing a unified framework that learns data representations and cluster assignments simultaneously, regardless of the level of supervision.

Methodology

XSDC builds upon the DIFFRAC method, introducing several core innovations to enable differentiable end-to-end learning:

  1. Forward Prediction Objective: Most joint clustering-representation methods utilize "reverse prediction," attempting to reconstruct data from cluster labels. XSDC instead predicts labels from learned features. This "forward" approach is mathematically smoother (possessing better Lipschitz properties), which stabilizes gradient-based optimization.
  2. Differentiable Representation Learning: Rather than relying on fixed kernels, XSDC uses deep "kernel networks" (specifically Nyström approximations). This allows the model to dynamically "warp" the feature space to make clusters more distinct.
  3. Matrix Balancing: Assigning points to clusters is typically an NP-hard discrete problem. XSDC relaxes this using an entropic regularizer, turning the assignment step into a matrix balancing problem solvable via the Sinkhorn-Knopp algorithm. This ensures that clusters do not collapse into a single group.
  4. Constraint Integration: The model operates using an "equivalence matrix" that tracks which points belong together. This structure allows for the easy incorporation of "must-link" or "must-not-link" constraints, even when actual class names are unknown.
The relationship between the assignment matrix Y, the equivalence matrix M, and the normalized equivalence matrix M-tilde.

Key Insights: Supervision as a Spectrum

A significant theoretical contribution of XSDC is the demonstration that supervision is not a binary state but a spectrum. The framework uses the same mathematical objective for unsupervised, semi-supervised, and fully supervised tasks; one simply fixes the known entries in the equivalence matrix M.

The equivalence matrix M under limited supervision, where only specific pairwise relationships are fixed.

Furthermore, the act of seeking well-separated clusters forces the neural network to learn meaningful features even without labels. Visualizations using t-SNE indicate that XSDC creates significantly tighter and more distinct clusters than networks not guided by a clustering objective.

Empirical Evaluation

The researchers evaluated XSDC on four diverse benchmarks: MNIST (handwritten digits), CIFAR-10 (color images), Gisette (high-dimensional vectors), and MAGIC (telescope measurements).

  • Efficiency with Sparse Labels: On MNIST, XSDC achieved nearly 10% higher accuracy than a standard supervised model when using only 50 labeled examples.
  • Superiority in Deep Clustering: XSDC consistently outperformed other popular "self-labeling" methods. On the Gisette dataset, it maintained a 1-5% accuracy advantage over its closest competitors.
  • Handling Imbalance: The framework demonstrated robustness to unbalanced data (where some clusters are much larger than others) by adjusting the bounds in the matrix balancing step.

Conclusion

XSDC provides a principled, unified framework for joint representation learning and clustering. By treating supervision as a continuous variable and utilizing a smooth forward-prediction objective, it achieves state-of-the-art results across various levels of data labeling. Future research will focus on reducing batch size dependency and developing streaming versions of the algorithm for real-time applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present an approach for end-to-end learning that allows one to jointly learn a feature representation from unlabeled data (with or without labeled data) and predict labels for unlabeled data. The feature representation is assumed to be specified in a differentiable programming framework, that is, as a parameterized mapping amenable to automatic differentiation. The proposed approach can be used with any amount of labeled and unlabeled data, gracefully adjusting to the amount of supervision. We provide experimental results illustrating the effectiveness of the approach.
BibTeX
@misc{jones2019end,
  author = {Corinne Jones and Vincent Roulet and Zaïd Harchaoui},
  title = {{End-to-end Learning, with or without Labels}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1912.12979},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1912.12979},
}

Loading related content...

Figure