Empirical Analysis of Induced Demand Resulted from LTE Service Launching

Sang‐Woo Lee, Sun-Me Choi, Jun-Seon Park, Myeong-Cheol ParkThe Journal of Korean Institute of Communications and Information Sciences 2012 · DOI

Abstract

스마트폰 도입 이후 국내 무선인터넷 시장은 획기적으로 변화하여 왔다. 이에 따라 무선인터넷시장의 성장은 물론 무선데이터 트래픽 또한 기하급수적으로 증가하고 있다. 이러한 무선인터넷 시장 및 트래픽 증가 현상에 대해 다양한 찬반양론은 있으나, 무선인터넷 서비스 시장의 활성화는 그간 성장이 다소 정체되어 왔던 통신시장의 재도약의 발판을 마련하고 있는 것은 부정할 수 없는 사실이다. 본 연구는 사건연구(Event Study) 방법론을 이용하여 망 전송 속도 및 네트워크 용량 확대에 따라 발생가능한 수요 패턴 중 하나인 유도된 수요(Induced Demand)가 LTE 도입에 따라 실제 통신시장에서도 발생하고 있는 지를 실증적으로 분석하고, 유도된 수요 발생에 따른 문제점 및 정책적 해결 방안을 제시하고자 한다.

Introduction

The introduction of smartphones has revolutionized the Korean mobile internet market, leading to exponential growth in data traffic. While this growth revitalized a stagnant telecommunications sector, it also brought new challenges. This study applies the concept of "Induced Demand"—traditionally used in urban planning to describe how road expansion can lead to more traffic—to the telecommunications sector following the launch of LTE (4G) services in South Korea. The core hypothesis is that LTE wasn't just an incremental upgrade but a behavioral catalyst that fundamentally changed consumer data consumption patterns.

Methodology

To empirically test the occurrence of induced demand, the researchers employed an Event Study methodology, treating the September 2011 LTE launch as the focal event. The research process followed a structured path from data collection to statistical validation.

Research methodology flowchart for analyzing induced demand.

The study evaluated various exponential smoothing models (Holts Linear Trend, Brown’s Linear Exponential Smoothing, and Damped Trend) using 26 months of pre-LTE data (Aug 2009 – Sept 2011). Brown’s Linear Exponential Smoothing was selected as the baseline due to its high R-squared (0.987) and low Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) of 6.06%, providing a robust counterfactual of what traffic would have looked like without LTE.

Data and Analysis

The analysis utilized monthly Average Traffic Per User (ATPU) from major Korean telcos (SKT, KT, and LG U+) between August 2009 and March 2012. A key observation was the dramatic shift in user utility. On 3G networks, high-definition video was often avoided due to latency and buffering. LTE's increased capacity and speed lowered these "time costs," inducing users to consume significantly more data. At the time of the study, LTE users consumed approximately 2,103 MB/month, a staggering 7.3 times more than the 286.56 MB/month consumed by 3G users.

Key Results

The empirical results confirmed a structural break in demand patterns post-LTE launch. The gap between the predicted baseline (based on 3G trends) and actual recorded traffic widened rapidly.

Comparison of actual vs. predicted traffic showing the induced demand gap after LTE commercialization.

By March 2012, just seven months after the launch, actual traffic was 2.2 times higher than the model’s prediction. Statistical validation via t-tests on MAPE values confirmed that the LTE launch significantly altered the demand trajectory, proving that the increased capacity "induced" new consumption rather than just satisfying existing needs.

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The study concludes that induced demand is a real phenomenon in the LTE era. This creates a "supply-side paradox" where infrastructure investment to alleviate congestion inadvertently stimulates more demand. Consequently, the authors argue that traditional flat-rate pricing models are unsustainable. They recommend a shift toward tiered, usage-based pricing and suggest that future policy must address how to fairly distribute the costs of network upgrades among users, telecommunications providers, and content providers to ensure long-term market sustainability.

Summary updated

Abstract

스마트폰 도입 이후 국내 무선인터넷 시장은 획기적으로 변화하여 왔다. 이에 따라 무선인터넷시장의 성장은 물론 무선데이터 트래픽 또한 기하급수적으로 증가하고 있다. 이러한 무선인터넷 시장 및 트래픽 증가 현상에 대해 다양한 찬반양론은 있으나, 무선인터넷 서비스 시장의 활성화는 그간 성장이 다소 정체되어 왔던 통신시장의 재도약의 발판을 마련하고 있는 것은 부정할 수 없는 사실이다. 이에 본 연구는 사건연구(Event Study) 방법론을 이용하여 망 전송 속도 및 네트워크 용량 확대에 따라 발생가능한 수요 패턴 중 하나인 유도된 수요(Induced Demand)가 LTE 도입에 따라 실제 통신시장에서도 발생하고 있는 지를 실증적으로 분석하고, 유도된 수요 발생에 따른 문제점 및 정책적 해결 방안을 제시하고자 한다. Since introduction of smart phone in Korean mobile telecommunication market, mobile internet service market has changed dramatically. Although there have been many heated discussion of pro and cons of recent tremendous growth of mobile traffic, mobile data service market has contributed to re-development of whole telecommunication market. This paper is aimed at empirically test and confirms the occurrence of induced demand resulted from LTE service launching. In conclusion, we suggest the direction of regulation and policy for sustainable development of mobile internet service.
BibTeX
@article{lee2012empirical,
  author = {Sang‐Woo Lee and Sun-Me Choi and Jun-Seon Park and Myeong-Cheol Park},
  title = {{Empirical Analysis of Induced Demand Resulted from LTE Service Launching}},
  journal = {The Journal of Korean Institute of Communications and Information Sciences},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.7840/kics.2012.37c.8.741},
}
Figure