Eliciting the plurality of causal reasoning in social-ecological systems research

Tilman Hertz, Thomas Banitz, Rodrigo Martínez‐Peña, Sonja Radosavljevic, Emilie Lindkvist, Lars‐Göran Johansson, Petri Ylikoski, Maja Schlüter‬Ecology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Understanding causation in social-ecological systems (SES) is indispensable for promoting sustainable outcomes. However, the study of such causal relations is challenging because they are often complex and intertwined, and their analysis involves diverse disciplines. Although there is agreement that no single research approach (RA) can comprehensively explain SES phenomena, there is a lack of ability to deal with this diversity. Underlying this diversity and the challenge of dealing with it are different causal reasonings that are rarely explicit. Awareness of hidden assumptions is essential for understanding how the causal reasoning of an RA is constituted, and for promoting the integration, translation, or juxtaposition of different RAs. We identify the following elements as particularly relevant for understanding causal reasoning: methods, frameworks and theories, accounts of causation, analytical focus, and causal notions. We begin with the idea that one of these elements typically figures as an entry point to an RA. This entry point is particularly important because it generates a path dependence that orients causal reasoning. In a subsequent step, when an approach is applied, causal reasoning concretizes as a result of a particular constellation of the remaining elements. We come to these insights by studying the application of four different RAs to the same social-ecological case (the collapse of Baltic cod stocks in the 1980s). On the basis of our findings we developed a guide for the analysis of causal reasoning by raising awareness of the assumptions, key elements, and the relations between these key elements for a given RA.

Introduction

Social-ecological systems (SES) are notoriously complex. While researchers generally agree that no single discipline possesses all the answers, integrating diverse perspectives remains a significant challenge. In the multidisciplinary world of SES research—where ecologists, sociologists, and mathematicians collaborate—a persistent "communication gap" often leads to conflicting findings about the same phenomenon.

This paper argues that these conflicts arise because each Research Approach (RA) operates on a unique, often unstated, form of causal reasoning. Without understanding the "logic under the hood" of a research study, we risk being biased by its findings without realizing the underlying assumptions. For instance, a study focused on individual fisher behavior will naturally suggest different policy interventions than one focused on ocean salinity. To address this, the authors introduce the CoMap, a conceptual tool designed to "unhide" implicit causal logic.

The CoMap Framework

The authors developed the CoMap (Conceptual Map) to dissect and visualize causal reasoning. This framework identifies six interacting elements that constitute how an approach identifies and analyzes causes:

  1. Analytical Focus: The realm (social vs. ecological), boundaries, and units of analysis.
  2. Frameworks and Theories: The key concepts and rules governing the study.
  3. Methods: The systematic procedures used to identify causes (e.g., simulation, statistics).
  4. Accounts of Causation: The philosophical basis (e.g., is a cause a "mechanism" or a "regularity"?).
  5. Causal Notions: The specific language used (e.g., "leads to," "enables," "necessary condition").
  6. Purpose/Motivation: The research question or goal driving the study.
The CoMap framework illustrating the six interacting elements of causal reasoning.

A central innovation is the concept of the "Entry Point." Most research begins with one of these elements (e.g., a specific method or theory), which creates a path dependency, orienting and constraining all subsequent causal reasoning.

Case Study: The 1980s Baltic Cod Collapse

To demonstrate the framework, the authors applied the CoMap to four distinct research approaches that studied the 1980s collapse of Baltic cod stocks:

  • Analytical Sociology: Focused on agent-based modeling (ABM) of fisher behavior, using "Frameworks and theories" as an entry point.
  • Ecological Modeling: Focused on dynamic simulation of fish stock interactions.
  • Dynamical Systems Analysis: Focused on mathematical feedback loops and stability.
  • Process-Relational Analysis: A philosophical approach focusing on how "social" and "ecological" categories are co-constituted, often starting from "Accounts of causation."
Comparison of causal reasoning entry points for Dynamical Systems Analysis (C) and Process-relational Analysis (D).

The mapping revealed that these approaches lead to vastly different governance interventions. For example, Analytical Sociology identified micro-scale peer influence as a cause, suggesting interventions that change the "opportunity space" for fishers. In contrast, Ecological Modeling identified functional relationships like predation and salinity, pointing toward the management of specific ecosystem factors.

Discussion: Insights on Causal Plurality

The study highlights that causal reasoning is inherently path-dependent. If a researcher starts with Dynamical Systems theory, they are naturally led toward quantifiable variables and structural delays, potentially overlooking non-quantifiable social nuances.

However, this plurality is not a weakness. Different approaches do not just provide different answers; they ask fundamentally different questions. The goal of the CoMap is not to find a single "true" cause, but to understand how these different lenses can be juxtaposed for a more holistic view. A key insight from the process-relational approach is the concept of the "cut"—the way we choose to draw boundaries between "subject" and "object." Defining a problem as purely "ecological" or "social" is itself a causal act that shapes the eventual outcome and dictates the resulting governance strategy.

Limitations and Future Work

While the CoMap is a powerful analytical tool, its operationalization into a "plug-and-play" guide for all researchers is still in progress. Identifying a study's "entry point" can be subjective, and even experts within a field may disagree on which element exerted the most influence on their reasoning. Furthermore, the framework currently focuses on the research approach itself rather than the positionality of the researcher—their personal background, norms, and biases—which also significantly shapes causal reasoning. Future work aims to make the tool more accessible for real-time interdisciplinary collaboration and to support the disclosure of ethical and political dimensions underlying management interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding causation in social-ecological systems (SES) is indispensable for promoting sustainable outcomes. However, the study of such causal relations is challenging because they are often complex and intertwined, and their analysis involves diverse disciplines. Although there is agreement that no single research approach (RA) can comprehensively explain SES phenomena, there is a lack of ability to deal with this diversity. Underlying this diversity and the challenge of dealing with it are different causal reasonings that are rarely explicit. Awareness of hidden assumptions is essential for understanding how the causal reasoning of an RA is constituted, and for promoting the integration, translation, or juxtaposition of different RAs. We identify the following elements as particularly relevant for understanding causal reasoning: methods, frameworks and theories, accounts of causation, analytical focus, and causal notions. We begin with the idea that one of these elements typically figures as an entry point to an RA. This entry point is particularly important because it generates a path dependence that orients causal reasoning. In a subsequent step, when an approach is applied, causal reasoning concretizes as a result of a particular constellation of the remaining elements. We come to these insights by studying the application of four different RAs to the same social-ecological case (the collapse of Baltic cod stocks in the 1980s). On the basis of our findings we developed a guide for the analysis of causal reasoning by raising awareness of the assumptions, key elements, and the relations between these key elements for a given RA. The guide can be used to elicit the causal reasoning of RAs, facilitate interdisciplinary collaboration, and support disclosure of ethical/political dimensions that underlie management/governance interventions that are formulated on the basis of causal findings of research studies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hertz2024eliciting,
  author = {Tilman Hertz and Thomas Banitz and Rodrigo Martínez‐Peña and Sonja Radosavljevic and Emilie Lindkvist and Lars‐Göran Johansson and Petri Ylikoski and Maja Schlüter‬},
  title = {{Eliciting the plurality of causal reasoning in social-ecological systems research}},
  booktitle = {Ecology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.5751/es-14806-290114},
}
Figure