Electronic structure of dangling bonds in amorphous silicon studied via a density-matrix functional method

Richard G. Hennig, P. A. Fedders, A. E. CarlssonPhysical 2002 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A structural model of hydrogenated amorphous silicon containing an isolated dangling bond is used to investigate the effects of electron interactions on the electronic level splittings, localization of charge and spin, and fluctuations in charge and spin. These properties are calculated with a recently developed density-matrix correlation-energy functional applied to a generalized Anderson Hamiltonian, consisting of tight-binding one-electron terms parametrizing hydrogenated amorphous silicon plus a local interaction term. The energy level splittings approach an asymptotic value for large values of the electron-interaction parameter U, and for physically relevant values of U are in the range 0.3--0.5 eV. The electron spin is highly localized on the central orbital of the dangling bond while the charge is spread over a larger region surrounding the dangling bond site. These results are consistent with known experimental data and previous density-functional calculations. The spin fluctuations are quite different from those obtained with unrestricted Hartree-Fock theory.

Introduction

Amorphous silicon ($a$-Si) is a cornerstone material in modern electronics and solar cell technology. However, its performance is often limited by "dangling bonds"—intrinsic defects where a silicon atom lacks a fourth neighbor, leaving an unpaired electron. These defects introduce states within the electronic band gap that act as recombination centers.

Historically, a significant discrepancy existed between experimental observations and theoretical models. Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) data indicated that the unpaired electron's spin is highly localized (over 50%) on the central defect atom. Conversely, standard one-electron theoretical models often predicted that if the charge density delocalizes to minimize energy, the spin density must follow. Reconciling these views requires an accurate treatment of electron correlation—the complex way electrons avoid one another due to mutual repulsion.

Methodology

To address these challenges, the researchers utilized a generalized Anderson Hamiltonian. This model incorporates tight-binding "hopping" parameters to describe electron movement between atoms and a local interaction term ($U$) representing the energetic cost of double occupancy at the dangling bond site.

The core of the study lies in the application of a density-matrix functional method employing a second-moment approximation. Unlike the standard Hartree-Fock approach, which approximates electron interactions through an average field, this method accounts for multi-configuration effects and electron correlation more rigorously. The physical system was modeled using a 142-atom supercell (122 Si, 20 H) with a single isolated dangling bond. A recursion method was then used to map this large system onto a computationally efficient "chain" Hamiltonian.

Key Insights and Results

Energy Level Splitting

A critical finding of the study is the behavior of the defect state energy levels as a function of the interaction strength $U$. In traditional Unrestricted Hartree-Fock (UHF) theory, the splitting between these levels increases linearly with $U$, leading to unphysically large gaps. In contrast, the density-matrix functional method demonstrates that the splitting approaches a finite asymptotic limit.

Energy level splitting E as a function of the interaction parameter U, comparing Hartree-Fock and the second-moment approximation.

For physically realistic values of $U$, the calculated splitting ($\Delta\epsilon$) falls within the range of 0.3–0.5 eV, aligning well with experimental photoluminescence and spectroscopy data (typically 0.3–0.4 eV).

Spin-Charge Decoupling and Localization

The research successfully explains the "spin-charge decoupling" observed in experiments. While the electron's charge tends to delocalize over the surrounding atoms to reduce electrostatic repulsion (showing only 10–30% localization), the spin remains significantly more localized.

Spin localization at the dangling bond site versus interaction strength U.

As shown in the figure above, the spin localization $\langle s_0 \rangle$ reaches approximately 60% for realistic interaction strengths, which is consistent with ESR findings of $>50\%$. This decoupling is a direct consequence of correlation effects that allow the system to satisfy magnetic requirements at the defect site while spreading out charge to lower the total energy.

Fluctuations

The study also examined fluctuations in spin and charge. The results for spin fluctuations differed markedly from Hartree-Fock predictions, suggesting that the local magnetic moment at the dangling bond is a dynamic property heavily influenced by correlation, rather than a static feature.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The density-matrix functional method provides a robust framework for understanding the electronic structure of isolated defects in amorphous semiconductors. By accurately capturing correlation effects, it resolves the long-standing tension between localized spin observations and delocalized charge models.

Current limitations include the functional's restriction to single-orbital interactions and the assumption of a static lattice. Future developments aimed at extending this approach to multi-orbital systems (such as transition-metal impurities) and incorporating lattice relaxation effects will further broaden its applicability to complex materials science problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

A structural model of hydrogenated amorphous silicon containing an isolated dangling bond is used to investigate the effects of electron interactions on the electronic level splittings, localization of charge and spin, and fluctuations in charge and spin. These properties are calculated with a recently developed density-matrix correlation-energy functional applied to a generalized Anderson Hamiltonian, consisting of tight-binding one-electron terms parametrizing hydrogenated amorphous silicon plus a local interaction term. The energy level splittings approach an asymptotic value for large values of the electron-interaction parameter U, and for physically relevant values of U are in the range 0.3--0.5 eV. The electron spin is highly localized on the central orbital of the dangling bond while the charge is spread over a larger region surrounding the dangling bond site. These results are consistent with known experimental data and previous density-functional calculations. The spin fluctuations are quite different from those obtained with unrestricted Hartree-Fock theory.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hennig2002electronic,
  author = {Richard G. Hennig and P. A. Fedders and A. E. Carlsson},
  title = {{Electronic structure of dangling bonds in amorphous silicon studied via a density-matrix functional method}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.66.195213},
}
Figure