Electronic Health Record Management: Expectations, Issues, and Challenges

Neethu Mathai, Shiratudin Mf, Ferdous SohelJournal of Health & Medical Informatics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reviews the existing literature on Electronic Health Records (EHRs), focusing on the expectations, issues, and challenges faced by both consumers and physicians. It highlights critical areas like privacy, data breaches, and usability that need to be addressed for successful EHR adoption and improved healthcare delivery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the complex landscape of implementing Electronic Health Records (EHRs) within the healthcare system. While EHRs promise significant benefits like improved efficiency, better patient care, and reduced errors, their widespread adoption is hampered by a range of issues. The core problem this paper addresses is the gap between the potential of EHRs and the practical realities of their implementation, specifically by examining the perspectives and concerns of the two primary user groups: patients (consumers) and healthcare providers (physicians). Without understanding and addressing these expectations and challenges, the full potential of EHRs remains unrealized, and trust in digital health records can be eroded.

Methods

This paper employs a comprehensive literature review methodology. The authors systematically explored existing research by examining academic journals, conference proceedings, and articles from expert authors. Data collection involved reviewing health websites and public repositories, with a specific focus on research papers published within the last five years. The collected studies were then analyzed to identify common themes, issues, and expectations related to EHRs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a literature review and does not present new experimental data or datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Consumer Trust is Paramount: Patients are deeply concerned about the privacy and security of their health information. Data breaches and the potential for misuse significantly erode trust, leading to reluctance in sharing information and potentially hindering EHR adoption.
  • Physician Workflow is Key: EHR interfaces are often not intuitive and disrupt established physician workflows, leading to decreased efficiency and productivity. This "low productivity" is a major pain point for physicians.
  • Alert Fatigue is Real: Physicians are overwhelmed by the sheer volume of alerts generated by EHR systems, making it difficult to prioritize critical information and increasing the risk of missing important patient data.
  • Medical Identity Theft is a Growing Threat: The digitization of health records creates new avenues for medical identity theft, where criminals can use stolen personal information to obtain medical services, posing significant risks to victims.
  • Interoperability is Crucial but Lacking: While EHRs aim to facilitate information sharing, challenges remain in achieving seamless interoperability between different systems and with emerging technologies like telehealth.
  • Training and Support are Insufficient: Physicians often receive minimal training for using EHR systems, and there's a lack of adequate support to help them adapt their workflows and leverage the technology effectively.

Key Results

The paper synthesizes findings from various studies, highlighting:

  • Consumer Concerns: Primarily revolve around privacy breaches, data security, and the risk of medical identity theft. Surveys indicate public anxiety regarding the sharing of sensitive health information.
  • Physician Issues: Include low productivity due to poor EHR design and non-intuitive interfaces, overwhelming alert systems, and a general reluctance to adopt systems that interfere with their established routines.
  • Expectations: Consumers expect clear privacy policies and control over their data. Physicians expect systems that enhance, rather than hinder, their workflow and provide comprehensive patient information for better decision-making.
  • Legal and Regulatory Landscape: The paper touches upon the importance of strong cyber health laws and the need for clear definitions of health records as required by regulations like HIPAA.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The paper acknowledges that high-quality studies examining the specific expectations and issues of consumers and physicians in EHR implementation were "severely lacking" prior to its review. * While the paper reviews existing literature, it doesn't present new empirical data or conduct its own surveys.

Future Work: * The authors suggest further public discussion is needed to develop efficient data-sharing arrangements between patients and providers. * They recommend quantitative studies, including large-scale surveys and interviews with both consumers and physicians, to gather more comprehensive data on expectations and challenges. * Developing strong cyber health laws and improving EHR system design to better support physician workflows are also highlighted as crucial future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Health record management is an important and challenging task. Utilization of technologies in health care, particularly the use of Electronic Health Records (EHR) offers a wide variety of benefits. Better healthcare is provided by EHR by improving all aspects of health care. This paper aims to do an extensive review of existing literature on the issues and expectations concerning consumers and physicians in the development of EHR. In this paper, based on the issues, recommendations are made, and future directions explored.
BibTeX
@article{mathai2017electronic,
  author = {Neethu Mathai and Shiratudin MF and Ferdous Sohel},
  title = {{Electronic Health Record Management: Expectations, Issues, and Challenges}},
  journal = {Journal of Health \& Medical Informatics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.4172/2157-7420.1000265},
}
Figure