This document is an EIC Editorial from the July 2014 issue of IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering (TKDE), written by Editor-in-Chief Jian Pei. Rather than a traditional research paper, it serves as a strategic update and a "changing of the guard" for the journal’s editorial board.
TL;DR
TKDE is launching a new series of "vision and position" articles to provide strategic roadmaps for the rapidly evolving field of knowledge and data engineering. To support this and maintain high peer-review standards, the journal has also overhauled its editorial board, welcoming 11 new associate editors with expertise ranging from machine learning to cloud management.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The field of data engineering is moving at a breakneck pace, often making it difficult for researchers to identify long-term strategic directions amidst a sea of incremental updates. As a flagship journal, TKDE recognized a gap in high-level, authoritative discourse regarding where the field is headed.
The editorial addresses two main challenges:
- Strategic Guidance: The need for "big picture" articles written by leaders to identify phenomenal dynamic challenges and opportunities.
- Editorial Scalability: The necessity of recruiting established, active experts to handle the increasing volume and complexity of submissions in the "wide spectrum" of data engineering.
Methods
As an editorial announcement, this document does not employ experimental methods. Instead, it outlines an editorial strategy:
- Commissioning Vision Papers: The journal will now publish 2–3 "vision and position" articles per year. The first, titled "Federation in Cloud Data Management: Challenges and Opportunities," is introduced in this issue.
- Board Restructuring: The journal rotated out 10 associate editors and appointed 11 new ones to ensure the board remains "established and active."
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper (this is an editorial announcement).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Vision" Initiative: The most significant takeaway is the journal's shift toward becoming a venue for strategic thought leadership, not just technical results. By soliciting vision papers, TKDE aims to set the research agenda for the community.
- Expertise Diversity: The biographies of the 11 new associate editors (including Arindam Banerjee, Larry Holder, and Daxin Jiang) highlight a deliberate move to cover interdisciplinary intersections, such as:
- Climate Science & Ecology: Applying machine learning to complex real-world environmental problems.
- Graph Mining: Focusing on supervised and unsupervised learning in graph streams.
- Web-Scale Mining: Developing search applications using massive log data.
- Community Engagement: The EIC explicitly calls for community feedback on topics and potential contributors, suggesting a more "open-source" approach to editorial planning.
Key Results
- New Series Launch: The formal start of the vision/position article series.
- Editorial Transition:
- Departing: 10 associate editors (including G. Cormode and S. Sudarshan) completed their terms.
- Joining: 11 new associate editors (A. Banerjee, L. Holder, D. Jiang, G. Li, F. Silvestri, W. Wang, J. Xu, S. Yan, J. Ye, X. Zhu, and G. Li) were onboarded.
- Re-enlistment: Notably, Dr. X. Zhu rejoined the board after a previous retirement, signaling a commitment to retaining deep institutional knowledge.
Limitations and Future Work
The editorial is a roadmap rather than a destination. The success of the "vision" initiative depends entirely on the quality of the invited contributors and the community's willingness to engage with these high-level perspectives. The EIC notes that the journal is looking forward to "continuing to serve you to the best in the future," implying that further structural or strategic changes may follow as the data landscape continues to evolve.
Summary updated