Efficient Searching Top-k Semantic Similar Words

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical challenge of efficiently finding the top-k semantically similar words from a large collection, a task crucial for many NLP applications but hindered by computational cost. The authors propose novel "best-first search" strategies for different similarity measures and a rank aggregation method to significantly speed up this process, achieving over two orders of magnitude improvement in query efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Finding semantically similar words is a fundamental problem in Natural Language Processing (NLP), underpinning applications like query suggestions, machine translation, and document summarization. The core task is, given a query word and a large collection of words, to identify the 'k' words that are most similar in meaning. While existing methods excel at measuring similarity (effectiveness), they struggle with the sheer scale of modern datasets, like the web. The computational cost of calculating similarity scores for every word pair becomes prohibitive. Furthermore, many existing approaches rely on a "threshold-based" framework, where users must manually set a similarity threshold, which is often difficult to tune effectively. This paper directly addresses this efficiency bottleneck, aiming to provide a fast and scalable solution for retrieving the top-k most similar words.

Methods

The paper proposes a framework that combines three representative types of word similarity measures:

  • Knowledge-based Similarity: Utilizes lexical databases like WordNet. The authors adapt a "best-first search" strategy to efficiently navigate WordNet's taxonomy, prioritizing nodes that are likely to lead to the most similar words, thus avoiding exhaustive traversal.
  • Corpus-based Similarity: Leverages large text corpora (like the web) to infer similarity based on word co-occurrence. The key innovation here is a "threshold filtering" lemma that allows for early termination of candidate evaluation by sorting words based on their page counts (a proxy for web presence), significantly reducing the number of similarity calculations needed.
  • String Similarity: Measures similarity based on the syntactic structure of words (e.g., n-grams). While the paper mentions existing efficient strategies like count filtering and length filtering, it focuses on integrating these with the other measures.

These individual similarity scores are then combined using a rank aggregation approach. The authors also introduce the concept of progressiveness, meaning that the top-k results should be output incrementally as they are found, providing immediate feedback to the user.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted on two real-world datasets:

  • Dict: A dataset of approximately 51,000 words, downloaded from the GNU Aspell project.
  • Word: A dataset of approximately 149,000 words, downloaded from WordNet in the US.

For evaluation, a subset of 10,000 words was randomly selected from the Word dataset to form the word collection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Efficiency is Paramount for Scale: The paper convincingly argues that for large-scale applications, computational efficiency is a more pressing concern than marginal gains in effectiveness.
  • Best-First Search for Lexical Databases: Adapting search algorithms to the structure of knowledge bases like WordNet can dramatically prune the search space, avoiding the need to explore every possible path.
  • Leveraging Corpus Statistics for Early Exit: The lemma for corpus-based similarity provides a clever way to bound the search space. By understanding the distribution of word occurrences, we can often determine that no further candidates will meet the top-k criteria without explicit calculation.
  • Progressive Results for User Experience: The idea of outputting results incrementally (progressiveness) is crucial for interactive systems, providing immediate value even if the full top-k set isn't immediately available.
  • Optimization Synergy: The paper demonstrates that optimizing both knowledge-based and corpus-based similarity measures yields the most significant performance improvements, highlighting the complementary nature of these approaches.

Key Results

The proposed BFS-WSM (Best First Search for Word Semantics Measure) algorithm achieved remarkable performance improvements:

  • Speedup: The algorithm demonstrated a speedup of more than two orders of magnitude compared to a naive approach, particularly for finding the top-1 result.
  • Reduced Candidate Access: BFS-WSM accessed significantly fewer candidate words for evaluation, which is the primary driver of its efficiency.
  • Progressiveness: The algorithm successfully outputs results progressively, with the optimization on corpus-based similarity being the dominant factor in query time.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Weighting of Similarity Measures: The paper acknowledges that the weights assigned to different similarity measures are set arbitrarily for simplicity, emphasizing that finding optimal weights is a separate, interesting problem.
  • Generalizability of Optimization: While the proposed strategies are effective, the paper suggests that other similarity measures could be integrated using similar indexing or selection techniques. For instance, information content-based measures could use an index similar to the n-gram list, and path-based measures could benefit from optimally choosing nearest candidates.
  • Future Work: The authors implicitly suggest exploring more sophisticated rank aggregation techniques and investigating methods for automatically learning optimal weights for combining diverse similarity features.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{2011efficient,
  title = {{Efficient Searching Top-k Semantic Similar Words}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2011},
}
Figure