Efficient Nonlinear Programming Algorithms for Chemical Process Control and Operations

Lorenz T. Biegler

Introduction

In the chemical industry, efficiency is paramount. Plants producing materials like Low-Density Polyethylene (LDPE) operate under tight margins where minor improvements in energy consumption or waste reduction translate into millions of dollars in savings. Optimizing these processes requires solving complex Nonlinear Programming (NLP) problems. However, two major hurdles persist: the massive scale of models governed by Differential-Algebraic Equations (DAEs) and the "control gap," where optimization takes too long to be useful for real-time plant adjustments.

Methodology

This research presents a framework to bridge the control gap using three core technical pillars:

  • Simultaneous Collocation: Instead of solving physics equations and optimization iteratively, this method discretizes the time horizon into finite elements. It treats the plant state at every time step as a decision variable, transforming a dynamic problem into a large-scale algebraic puzzle that can enforce safety constraints at every point.
  • IPOPT (Interior Point Optimizer): A large-scale software package designed to solve these puzzles using barrier methods and parallel linear algebra, capable of handling millions of variables.
  • Advanced Step NMPC (as-NMPC): This is the key to real-time speed. The controller solves a "background" optimization based on a predicted state. When actual measurements arrive, it uses NLP Sensitivity—a mathematical update—to instantly adjust the pre-calculated solution rather than re-solving from scratch.

Case Study: LDPE Production

The methods were evaluated using a high-fidelity simulation of a commercial-scale LDPE process, which involves complex recycles and a tubular reactor up to 2 km in length.

Schematic of the commercial-scale LDPE process, showing the complexity of the system including high-pressure recycles and the tubular reactor.

The model's accuracy was validated by estimating over 100 kinetic parameters across various operating scenarios. As shown in the reactor temperature profiles, the model closely matches actual plant data for different product grades.

Comparison of scaled reactor temperature profiles for Grade A and Grade B LDPE production, demonstrating the high fidelity of the model compared to plant data.

Key Results

  • Massive Speedup: In grade transition tests, the computation time for a control move was reduced from 351 CPU seconds to just 1.04 seconds using the as-NMPC approach.
  • Waste Reduction: The optimization strategies reduced grade transition times from 5 hours to 2.8 hours, preventing the creation of 23 tons of off-spec waste per transition.
  • Scalability: Parallel implementation allowed the system to handle up to 32 data sets for parameter estimation simultaneously, overcoming the memory limitations of standard serial solvers.

Conclusion and Future Work

While the as-NMPC method provides the speed necessary for real-time operations, its effectiveness depends on the accuracy of background predictions. Future research will focus on explicitly handling model uncertainty and measurement noise, as well as better integrating high-level business planning with low-level process control.

Summary updated

Abstract

Optimization is applied in numerous areas of chemical engineering including the development of process models from experimental data, design of process flowsheets and equipment, planning and scheduling of chemical process operations, and the analysis of chemical processes under uncertainty and adverse conditions. These off-line tasks require the solution of nonlinear programs (NLPs) with detailed, large-scale process models. Recently, these tasks have been complemented by time-critical, on-line optimization problems with differential-algebraic equation (DAE) process models that describe process behavior over a wide range of operating conditions, and must be solved sufficiently quickly. This paper describes recent advances in this area especially with dynamic models. We outline large-scale NLP formulations and algorithms as well as NLP sensitivity for on-line applications, and illustrate these advances on a commercial-scale low density polyethylene (LDPE) process.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{biegler2007efficient,
  author = {Lorenz T. Biegler},
  title = {{Efficient Nonlinear Programming Algorithms for Chemical Process Control and Operations}},
  booktitle = {System Modelling and Optimization},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-04802-9\_2},
}
Figure