Efficient data-driven optimization with noisy data

Bart P. G. Van Parys

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new class of data-driven optimization methods designed to work effectively even when the data used for training is corrupted by noise. These methods offer robust performance guarantees and are shown to be computationally tractable, bridging a critical gap between theoretical ideals and practical applications in decision-making under uncertainty.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world scenarios, decision-makers rely on data to optimize their strategies. However, this data is often imperfect, contaminated by measurement noise. Traditional data-driven optimization methods, which assume clean, noiseless data, can perform poorly when faced with such imperfections. This paper tackles the challenge of developing optimization frameworks that are both statistically robust and computationally efficient in the presence of known noise models. The authors aim to provide a principled way to make optimal decisions when the underlying data generating process is uncertain and the observed data is noisy.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is a novel family of distributionally robust optimization (DRO) formulations. These formulations are designed to be "efficient" in the sense of providing strong out-of-sample guarantees while minimizing conservatism. The authors extend previous work on DRO with noiseless data to a noisy data setting by leveraging:

  • Entropic Divergence and Optimal Transport: The ambiguity sets (sets of plausible underlying distributions) are defined using a combination of entropic divergence (Kullback-Leibler) and entropic optimal transport. These are interpreted as large deviation rate functions.
  • Smoothed Rate Functions: Due to the irregular nature of the rate function in the noisy setting, the authors introduce a smoothed version to ensure tractability.
  • Strassen's Representation Theorem: A key technical innovation is the application of Strassen's theorem to reformulate the problem, particularly the Lévy-Prokhorov distance constraint, into a more tractable form. This allows for efficient solutions, especially when dealing with finite event sets.
  • Dual Representation: The authors derive a dual formulation of the optimization problem, which can often be solved more efficiently than the primal problem, particularly when using specialized convex optimization solvers.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and algorithmic formulation rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Noisy Data Requires Different Tools: The paper highlights that simply applying noiseless data-driven methods to noisy data leads to poor performance. New theoretical frameworks are needed.
  • Entropic Optimal Transport as a Rate Function: The authors show that entropic optimal transport distances can serve as a large deviation rate function in the noisy setting, providing a principled way to define ambiguity sets.
  • The Need for Smoothing: The irregularity of the rate function in the noisy regime necessitates smoothing for tractability, leading to a family of increasingly efficient formulations rather than a single optimal one.
  • Strassen's Theorem is a Game-Changer for Tractability: The novel application of Strassen's representation theorem is crucial for transforming computationally challenging constraints (like Lévy-Prokhorov distance) into manageable ones.
  • Efficiency vs. Conservatism: The paper emphasizes the trade-off between the strength of out-of-sample guarantees and the conservatism of the decision. Their proposed methods aim to strike an optimal balance.

Key Results

  • Feasible and Efficient Formulations: The paper establishes that their proposed family of robust formulations is feasible (i.e., provides strong out-of-sample guarantees) and dominates other regular formulations in terms of efficiency.
  • Tractable Reformulations: Through Strassen's representation and dualization, the authors provide tractable reformulations of these robust optimization problems, making them amenable to modern optimization solvers.
  • Consistency Guarantees: For additive noise models, the paper shows that under certain conditions, their formulations can achieve consistency, meaning the decision converges to the optimal one as more data becomes available.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Identifiability Assumption: The consistency results rely on an identifiability assumption, which may not hold for all observational models (e.g., those with significant information loss).
  • Computational Complexity: While tractable, the computational complexity can still be significant for very large event sets, although the dual formulation offers improvements.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the application of their framework to specific problem domains and investigating extensions to more general noise models and loss functions. They also point to the potential for further algorithmic improvements based on their dual representations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Classical Kullback-Leibler or entropic distances are known to enjoy certain desirable statistical properties in the context of decision-making with noiseless data. However, in most practical situations the data available to a decision maker is subject to a certain amount of measurement noise. We hence study here data-driven prescription problems in which the data is corrupted by a known noise source. We derive efficient data-driven formulations in this noisy regime and indicate that they enjoy an entropic optimal transport interpretation. Finally, we show that these efficient robust formulations are tractable in several interesting settings by exploiting a classical representation result by Strassen.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{parys2024efficient,
  author = {Bart P. G. Van Parys},
  title = {{Efficient data-driven optimization with noisy data}},
  booktitle = {Operations},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.orl.2024.107089},
}
Figure