This study investigates how physical office environments—specifically the presence of windows and the choice between sitting or standing postures—impact motivation and psychological evaluation during meetings. Through controlled simulations with 48 male undergraduate students, researchers examined 2-person and 4-person meeting configurations in both windowed and windowless settings. The findings reveal that the ideal office setup is highly contextual: while windowless rooms fostered better group unity and higher motivation in 4-person meetings, windows were beneficial for 2-person discussions. Furthermore, the effectiveness of standing versus sitting depended heavily on the visual environment and group size.
Introduction
Modern office design often prioritizes "openness" and "standing desks" as universal solutions for creativity and engagement. However, meetings frequently suffer from a lack of concentration or a failure to generate new ideas. This research addresses a gap in architectural studies by examining how the combination of posture (sitting vs. standing) and visual environment (windows vs. no windows) affects the psychological motivation of collaborative groups. The goal is to provide empirical evidence for optimizing intellectual productivity through spatial layout.
Methodology
The researchers conducted a series of simulated meeting experiments in a controlled study workspace measuring 7.87m x 3.60m. The room was equipped with eight desks arranged in an "island type" layout.
Layout of the experimental room showing the island-style desk arrangement and participant groupings.
Participants: 48 male undergraduate students, divided into three groups of eight.
Variables: The study tested two environmental conditions (with windows/blinds open vs. without windows/blinds closed), two postures (sitting vs. standing), and two group sizes (4-person vs. 2-person).
Task: Groups performed 4-minute brainstorming sessions on nature-themed topics, recording keywords on sticky notes.
Metrics: Motivation was assessed via a self-reported 0–100 score and keyword counts. To account for individual differences, a "Modified Score" was calculated (individual score divided by the individual's average across all sessions). Psychological evaluation utilized a 20-item Semantic Differential (SD) scale.
Experimental setup for a 2-person meeting in a standing posture, facing each other.
In 4-person meetings, the absence of windows led to significantly higher motivation. In windowless environments, participants reported a stronger sense of group unity and pleasure, likely due to the lack of external distractions and more equalized indoor lighting. Additionally, sitting subjects reported higher motivation than those who were standing.
2-Person Meetings
For dyads, the results were more nuanced. When sitting, motivation was higher in rooms with windows, as the view provided a "safety valve" to divert eyesight and prevent the intensity of a 1-on-1 meeting from becoming stifling. However, in windowless spaces, standing subjects reported higher motivation than sitting ones. The authors hypothesize that standing allows for greater freedom of movement and a more dynamic perception of the room, compensating for the lack of a view.
Psychological Perception
Interestingly, participants in windowless rooms often rated the space as "brighter" or more "fun" during successful 4-person meetings. This suggests that positive group dynamics can override the physical reality of natural light in psychological evaluations.
Conclusion
The study clarifies that there is no "one-size-fits-all" office layout. For small group collaborations of four people, a focused, windowless environment with traditional seating may be most effective. For one-on-one interactions, a windowed view is preferable for seated meetings, while standing may be a better alternative in enclosed spaces. Future research should explore these effects over longer durations and across more diverse demographic groups to further refine guidelines for intellectual productivity in the workplace.
Summary updated
Abstract
The aim of this study is to clarify the effects of window and posture on the motivation and psychological evaluation during a meeting. A meeting is thought to share personal knowledge and experience, request more stimulation from each other and get more new ideas. But in fact, in a meeting, some problems were found such as lack of concentration, while no ideas came up. The issue is how to arrange the layout of a space to improve motivation in a meeting. To find the effects of window and posture, Simulated experiments are produced in a simulated study space. The room for the experiment is 7.87 meters long, 3.60 meters wide, and 3.15 meters high. 8 desks in island type layout are arranged. Every desk is 1.40 meters long, 0.06 meters wide, and 0.71 meters high, while a mini desk is put on the desk, which is 0.30 meters long, 0.45 meters wide, and 0.19 meters high. Subjects are asked to take a meeting, whose title was already decided. The number of meetings is either 4 people or 2 people. The posture of the meeting is decided as either sitting or standing. Regarding the meeting of 2 people, the posture includes facing each other and shoulder to shoulder. 6 kinds of meeting are asked to be done, that is standing for 4 people, sitting for 2 people facing each other, sitting for 2 people shoulder to shoulder, standing for 2 people facing, standing for 2 people shoulder to shoulder, sitting for 4 people. During the experiment, subjects are asked to speak the key words by a decided theme while writing them down on the sheets for 4 minutes, and to reply to questionnaires regarding to psychological evaluation after they have finished the meeting. They were asked to take the score of the motivation by themselves, taking 100 points as perfection in the questionnaires. 24 subjects as 3 groups (8 people per group) did the case of a space with windows; while 24 subjects did the case of a space without windows. All 48 subjects are male undergraduate students. Analysis contains motivation and psychological evaluation. Motivation is based on the score of personal motivation and number of key words talked by subjects; while psychological evaluation is based on the result of questionnaire. Modified score is defined as the score divided by the average of all scores of the same subject. As a conclusion, the following was clarified. Regarding to meetings of 4 people, firstly, in the space without windows the brightness is more equal, the feeling of unity of the group is stronger, people feel more pleasure, the motivation is higher than in the case with windows. Secondly, the motivation with sitting subjects is higher than with standing subjects. Regarding to meetings of 2 people, firstly, in the case of sitting in a space with windows, the eyesight can divert and the view is wide, the motivation is higher than in the space without windows. Secondly, In a space without windows, the motivation with standing subjects is higher than with sitting subject. It is thought that people can move freely and the surroundings can be seen more in the case of the standing subjects. The issue in future is to study the difference of personal ability of getting new key words and the case of more people in a meeting group.
BibTeX
@article{xu2018effects,
author = {Hua Xu and Kazuhiko NISHIDE and Miho HASEBE},
title = {{EFFECTS OF WINDOWS AND POSTURE ON MOTIVATION AND PSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION DURING A MEETING}},
journal = {Journal of Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ)},
year = {2018},
doi = {10.3130/aija.83.1437},
}