Effects of urban living environments on mental health in adults

Jiayuan Xu, Nana Liu, Elli Polemiti, Liliana Garcia-Mondragon, Jie Tang, Xiaoxuan Liu, Tristram A. Lett, Le Yu, Markus M. Nöthen, Jianfeng Feng, Chunshui Yu, André F. Marquand, Günter Schumann, Henrik Walter, Andreas Heinz, Markus Ralser, Sven Twardziok, Nilakshi Vaidya, Emin Serin, Marcel Jentsch, Esther Hitchen, Roland Eils, Ulrike-Helene Taron, Tatjana Schütz, Kerstin Schepanski, Jamie Banks, Tobias Banaschewski, Karina Jansone, Nina Christmann, Andreas Meyer‐Lindenberg, Heike Tost, Nathalie Holz, Emanuel Schwarz, Argyris Stringaris, Maja Neidhart, Frauke Nees, Sebastian Siehl, Ole A. Andreassen, Lars T. Westlye, Dennis van der Meer, Sara Fernández, Rikka Kjelkenes, Helga Ask, Michael A. Rapp, Mira Tschorn, Sarah Jane Böttger, Gaia Novarino, Lena Marr, Mel Slater, Guillem Feixas Viapiana, Francisco José Eiroá‐Orosa, Jaime Gallego, Álvaro Pastor, Andreas J. Forstner, Per Hoffmann, Isabelle Claus, Abbi Miller, Stefanie Heilmann‐Heimbach, Peter Sommer, Mona Boye, Johannes Wilbertz, Karen M. Schmitt, Viktor Jirsa, Spase Petkoski, Séverine Pitel, Lisa Otten, Anastasios-Polykarpos Athanasiadis, Charlie Pearmund, Bernhard Spanlang, Elena Álvarez, Mavi Sanchez, A. Giner, Sören Hese, Paul Renner, Tianye Jia, Yanting Gong, Yunman Xia, Xiao Chang, Vince D. Calhoun, Jingyu Liu, Paul M. Thompson, Nicholas Clinton, Sylvane Desrivières, Allan H. Young, Bernd Carsten Stahl, George OgohNature Medicine 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Urban-living individuals are exposed to many environmental factors that may combine and interact to influence mental health. While individual factors of an urban environment have been investigated in isolation, no attempt has been made to model how complex, real-life exposure to living in the city relates to brain and mental health, and how this is moderated by genetic factors. Using the data of 156,075 participants from the UK Biobank, we carried out sparse canonical correlation analyses to investigate the relationships between urban environments and psychiatric symptoms. We found an environmental profile of social deprivation, air pollution, street network and urban land-use density that was positively correlated with an affective symptom group (r = 0.22, P<sub>perm</sub> < 0.001), mediated by brain volume differences consistent with reward processing, and moderated by genes enriched for stress response, including CRHR1, explaining 2.01% of the variance in brain volume differences. Protective factors such as greenness and generous destination accessibility were negatively correlated with an anxiety symptom group (r = 0.10, P<sub>perm</sub> < 0.001), mediated by brain regions necessary for emotion regulation and moderated by EXD3, explaining 1.65% of the variance. The third urban environmental profile was correlated with an emotional instability symptom group (r = 0.03, P<sub>perm</sub> < 0.001). Our findings suggest that different environmental profiles of urban living may influence specific psychiatric symptom groups through distinct neurobiological pathways.

Introduction

While it is well-established that city dwellers face higher risks of depression and anxiety, most research has historically examined environmental factors—such as noise, air pollution, or green space—in isolation. However, real-world urban exposure is a "cocktail" of interacting physical and socioeconomic conditions. This study addresses the complexity of these exposures by moving from single-factor analyses to multi-dimensional "environmental profiles." Furthermore, it seeks to identify the specific brain regions that mediate the link between the environment and mental health and determine how genetic variations moderate these relationships.

Methods

The study utilized data from 156,075 participants in the UK Biobank (UKB). The discovery sample included 141,087 participants for identifying environmental-symptom correlations and conducting GWAS, while a replication/imaging sample of 14,988 participants provided high-resolution MRI data. Environmental data was sourced from the UKB Urban Morphometric Platform (UKBUMP), providing granular data on land use, street networks, and vegetation indices (NDVI) at participants' home addresses.

Study design and analysis pipeline

The researchers employed a multi-stage statistical pipeline involving Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) to distill 128 raw environmental variables into 53 stable categories. Sparse Canonical Correlation Analysis (sCCA) was then used to identify latent patterns between these categories and 21 psychiatric symptoms. Finally, moderated mediation analysis tested if environmental profiles affect symptoms through brain volume changes and if this relationship is moderated by genetic scores identified via GWAS.

Results

The analysis identified three distinct urban environmental profiles that correlate with specific psychiatric symptom groups.

Correlation strengths of urban environmental profiles with psychiatric symptom groups

Affective Symptom Group

This group was positively correlated with a profile characterized by social deprivation, air pollution, and high building density (r = 0.22, P < 0.001). This relationship was mediated by volume reductions in reward-processing brain regions, such as the ventral striatum. Genetic moderation was observed, specifically involving the CRHR1 gene (involved in stress response) and MAPT. Individuals with higher genetic risk scores showed a stronger correlation between adverse environments and reduced brain volume.

Anxiety Symptom Group

This group was negatively correlated with "protective" factors, including greenness and destination accessibility (r = 0.10, P < 0.001). The link was mediated by brain regions necessary for emotion regulation, such as the inferior frontal gyrus, and moderated by the EXD3 gene.

Emotional Instability Group

A third profile, involving high density of education and infrastructure, correlated with emotional instability (r = 0.03, P < 0.001). This relationship was moderated by the IFT74 gene.

Notably, these multi-dimensional environmental profiles explained significantly more variance in mental health (up to 4.71%) than single factors like nighttime light or green space percentage alone.

Discussion

These findings suggest that urbanicity is not a monolithic risk factor. Instead, different environmental profiles influence specific psychiatric symptoms through distinct neurobiological pathways. However, as a cross-sectional study, causality cannot be definitively established; selective migration—where individuals with certain predispositions select into specific environments—remains a possibility. Additionally, the UK Biobank sample is predominantly white and middle-aged, which may limit generalizability to younger populations or diverse global megacities. Future research should utilize longitudinal data to track these relationships over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban-living individuals are exposed to many environmental factors that may combine and interact to influence mental health. While individual factors of an urban environment have been investigated in isolation, no attempt has been made to model how complex, real-life exposure to living in the city relates to brain and mental health, and how this is moderated by genetic factors. Using the data of 156,075 participants from the UK Biobank, we carried out sparse canonical correlation analyses to investigate the relationships between urban environments and psychiatric symptoms. We found an environmental profile of social deprivation, air pollution, street network and urban land-use density that was positively correlated with an affective symptom group (r = 0.22, P<sub>perm</sub> < 0.001), mediated by brain volume differences consistent with reward processing, and moderated by genes enriched for stress response, including CRHR1, explaining 2.01% of the variance in brain volume differences. Protective factors such as greenness and generous destination accessibility were negatively correlated with an anxiety symptom group (r = 0.10, P<sub>perm</sub> < 0.001), mediated by brain regions necessary for emotion regulation and moderated by EXD3, explaining 1.65% of the variance. The third urban environmental profile was correlated with an emotional instability symptom group (r = 0.03, P<sub>perm</sub> < 0.001). Our findings suggest that different environmental profiles of urban living may influence specific psychiatric symptom groups through distinct neurobiological pathways.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2023effects,
  author = {Jiayuan Xu and Nana Liu and Elli Polemiti and Liliana Garcia-Mondragon and Jie Tang and Xiaoxuan Liu and Tristram A. Lett and Le Yu and Markus M. Nöthen and Jianfeng Feng and Chunshui Yu and André F. Marquand and Günter Schumann and Henrik Walter and Andreas Heinz and Markus Ralser and Sven Twardziok and Nilakshi Vaidya and Emin Serin and Marcel Jentsch and Esther Hitchen and Roland Eils and Ulrike-Helene Taron and Tatjana Schütz and Kerstin Schepanski and Jamie Banks and Tobias Banaschewski and Karina Jansone and Nina Christmann and Andreas Meyer‐Lindenberg and Heike Tost and Nathalie Holz and Emanuel Schwarz and Argyris Stringaris and Maja Neidhart and Frauke Nees and Sebastian Siehl and Ole A. Andreassen and Lars T. Westlye and Dennis van der Meer and Sara Fernández and Rikka Kjelkenes and Helga Ask and Michael A. Rapp and Mira Tschorn and Sarah Jane Böttger and Gaia Novarino and Lena Marr and Mel Slater and Guillem Feixas Viapiana and Francisco José Eiroá‐Orosa and Jaime Gallego and Álvaro Pastor and Andreas J. Forstner and Per Hoffmann and Markus M. Nöthen and Andreas J. Forstner and Isabelle Claus and Abbi Miller and Stefanie Heilmann‐Heimbach and Peter Sommer and Mona Boye and Johannes Wilbertz and Karen M. Schmitt and Viktor Jirsa and Spase Petkoski and Séverine Pitel and Lisa Otten and Anastasios-Polykarpos Athanasiadis and Charlie Pearmund and Bernhard Spanlang and Elena Álvarez and Mavi Sanchez and A. Giner and Sören Hese and Paul Renner and Tianye Jia and Yanting Gong and Yunman Xia and Xiao Chang and Vince D. Calhoun and Jingyu Liu and Paul M. Thompson and Nicholas Clinton and Sylvane Desrivières and Allan H. Young and Bernd Carsten Stahl and George Ogoh},
  title = {{Effects of urban living environments on mental health in adults}},
  booktitle = {Nature Medicine},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41591-023-02365-w},
}
Figure