Effects of gene dosage on cognitive ability: A function-based association study across brain and non-brain processes

Guillaume Huguet, Thomas Renne, Cécile Poulain, Alma Dubuc, Kuldeep Kumar, Sayeh Kazem, Worrawat Engchuan, Omar Shanta, Élise Douard, Catherine Proulx, Martineau Jean‐Louis, Zohra Saci, Josephine Mollon, Laura M. Schultz, Emma Em Knowles, Simon R. Cox, David J. Porteous, Gail Davies, Paul Redmond, Sarah E. Harris, Günter Schumann, Guillaume Dumas, Aurélie Labbe, Zdenka Pausová, Tomáš Paus, Stephen W. Scherer, Jonathan Sebat, Laura Almasy, David C. Glahn, Sébastien JacquemontbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

Introduction

Genomic Copy Number Variants (CNVs)—deletions or duplications of DNA segments—are well-established risk factors for neurodevelopmental disorders. However, their impact on cognitive ability within the general population is more nuanced. While large CNVs are known to generally impair cognitive function, the rarity of these variants poses a significant statistical challenge. Most CNVs affecting cognition are "ultra-rare," appearing in fewer than 1 in 10,000 individuals, making variant-level associations difficult to establish. Consequently, the specific biological processes sensitive to these "gene dosage" changes have remained largely unmapped. This study utilizes a massive multi-cohort dataset to identify how the loss or gain of genetic material across 6,502 functional gene-sets influences general cognitive ability.

Methods and Data

To overcome the limitations of rare variant analysis, the researchers pooled data from 258,292 individuals across six major population cohorts, including the UK Biobank, Generation Scotland, and the Lothian Birth Cohort. The study employed a two-pronged analytical strategy:

  1. CNV-GWAS: A genome-wide association study focused on identifying specific CNVs linked to cognitive performance.
  2. Functional Burden Analysis: Rather than focusing on individual mutations, the team grouped genes into sets based on tissue-specific expression and Gene Ontology (GO) terms. They then measured the cumulative "burden" of deletions and duplications within these functional groups.
  3. tagDS (Trait-Associated Gene-Dosage Sensitivity): The researchers developed this new normalized metric to quantify whether a biological function is preferentially sensitive to deletions versus duplications.

Results

The Discovery of a Cognitive "Plus" Factor

While the vast majority of large CNVs are detrimental to cognitive performance, the CNV-GWAS identified a novel duplication at 2q12.3 associated with higher cognitive ability. This duplication, found in 36 individuals in the sample, encompasses genes such as EDAR and SEPT10. This finding is a rare exception in genomic literature, where large-scale structural variations are almost exclusively linked to cognitive deficit.

The Divergence of Deletion and Duplication Effects

A central finding of the study is that deletions and duplications do not affect the brain in the same way. The researchers observed a systematic negative correlation between the effect sizes of deletions and duplications across all levels of biological observation. Only 11% of the 864 associated gene-sets showed significant effects for both types of variants. On average, the negative impact of deletions was 2.4 times higher than that of duplications, confirming that losing genetic material is generally more disruptive to the system than gaining it.

Regional and Cellular Sensitivity

The study revealed a distinct spatial and functional map of dosage sensitivity:

  • Duplication Sensitivity: Cognitive ability was preferentially affected by duplications in gene-sets associated with the cerebral cortex and presynaptic processes. These functions appear more vulnerable to "over-expression" or increased dosage.
  • Deletion Sensitivity: Conversely, subcortical regions and post-synaptic processes showed a higher sensitivity to deletions. These systems appear more vulnerable to haploinsufficiency (having only one functional copy of a gene).

Cognition as an Embodied Trait

Interestingly, the analysis identified numerous gene-sets assigned to non-brain organs (such as the heart or liver) that were significantly associated with cognitive ability. This phenomenon was driven by genes with low tissue specificity—highly pleiotropic genes that are active across multiple systems. These genes were found to be particularly sensitive to deletions (haploinsufficiency), suggesting that cognitive health is inextricably linked to the global biological integrity of the organism, rather than being an isolated product of brain-specific genes.

Discussion and Limitations

This research provides a comprehensive map of how gene dosage shapes human intelligence, moving beyond individual variants to functional systems. By demonstrating that most biological functions are sensitive to either deletions or duplications—but rarely both—the study challenges the assumption that all CNVs impact the brain through a single common pathway.

Despite the large sample size, the extreme rarity of many CNVs remains a constraint, limiting the ability to identify every individual gene responsible for these effects. Future research will require even larger datasets to refine these functional maps and determine if the observed dosage-sensitivity patterns apply to other complex human traits and disease susceptibilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Genomic Copy Number Variants (CNVs) that increase risk for neurodevelopmental disorders are also associated with lower cognitive ability in general population cohorts. Studies have focussed on a small set of recurrent CNVs, but burden analyses suggested that the vast majority of CNVs affecting cognitive ability are too rare to reach variant-level association. As a result, the full range of gene-dosage-sensitive biological processes linked to cognitive ability remains unknown. To investigate this issue, we identified all CNVs >50 kilobases in 258k individuals from 6 general population cohorts with assessments of general cognitive abilities. We performed a CNV-GWAS and functional burden analyses, which tested 6502 gene-sets defined by tissue and cell-type transcriptomics as well as gene ontology disrupted by all rare coding CNVs. CNV-GWAS identified a novel duplication at 2q12.3 associated with higher performance in cognitive ability. Among the 864 gene-sets associated with cognitive ability, only 11% showed significant effects for both deletions and duplication. Accordingly, we systematically observed negative correlations between deletion and duplication effect sizes across all levels of biological observations. We quantified the preferential effects of deletions versus duplication using tagDS, a new normalized metric. Cognitive ability was preferentially affected by cortical, presynaptic, and negative-regulation gene-sets when duplicated. In contrast, preferential effects of deletions were observed for subcortical, post-synaptic, and positive-regulation gene-sets. A large proportion of gene-sets assigned to non-brain organs were associated with cognitive ability due to low tissue specificity genes, which were associated with higher sensitive to haploinsufficiency. Overall, most biological functions associated with cognitive ability are divided into those sensitive to either deletion or duplications.
BibTeX
@misc{huguet2024effects,
  author = {Guillaume Huguet and Thomas Renne and Cécile Poulain and Alma Dubuc and Kuldeep Kumar and Sayeh Kazem and Worrawat Engchuan and Omar Shanta and Élise Douard and Catherine Proulx and Martineau Jean‐Louis and Zohra Saci and Josephine Mollon and Laura M. Schultz and Emma EM Knowles and Simon R. Cox and David J. Porteous and Gail Davies and Paul Redmond and Sarah E. Harris and Günter Schumann and Guillaume Dumas and Aurélie Labbe and Zdenka Pausová and Tomáš Paus and Stephen W. Scherer and Jonathan Sebat and Laura Almasy and David C. Glahn and Sébastien Jacquemont},
  title = {{Effects of gene dosage on cognitive ability: A function-based association study across brain and non-brain processes}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.04.16.589618},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure