Effects of Different Fertilization Regimes on Crop Yield and Soil Water Use Efficiency of Millet and Soybean

Qiang Liu, Hongwei Xu, Xingmin Mu, Guangju Zhao, Peng Gao, Wenyi SunSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the impact of various nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) fertilization regimes on crop yield and soil water use efficiency (WUE) in the semi-arid Loess Plateau. The findings highlight that combined N and P fertilization, particularly at higher rates (240 kg N/ha and 90 kg P/ha), significantly boosted both crop yield and WUE, offering a crucial scientific basis for sustainable agricultural practices in water-scarce regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agricultural productivity in semi-arid regions like the Loess Plateau is severely constrained by limited soil water and nutrient availability. While fertilizer application is a common strategy to enhance crop yields, inefficient utilization and potential environmental pollution are significant concerns. The Loess Plateau, characterized by scarce irrigation resources and high soil erosion, faces particular challenges in optimizing crop production while conserving water. This paper addresses the critical need to understand how different combinations and rates of N and P fertilization affect not only crop yield but also the crucial aspect of soil water use efficiency, aiming to provide practical guidance for sustainable farming in these challenging environments.

Methods

The researchers conducted a two-year field experiment in the Loess Plateau, China, using nine different fertilization regimes, including a control (no fertilizer), single N or P applications at varying rates, and combined N and P applications. Millet was planted in 2017, and soybeans in 2018. Soil samples were collected to measure soil organic matter (SOM), total nitrogen (TN), and total phosphorus (TP). Crop yield was measured directly, and soil water consumption (ET) was calculated based on changes in soil water storage and precipitation. Soil water use efficiency (WUE) was then determined using the formula WUE = Yield/ET. Statistical analyses, including one-way ANOVA and Pearson's correlation, were employed to assess the significance of the treatments and the relationships between different parameters.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from field experiments conducted over two growing seasons (2017 and 2018) in Ansai County, Shaanxi Province, China. The experimental site provided data on:

  • Soil properties: Soil organic matter (SOM), total nitrogen (TN), and total phosphorus (TP) at a depth of 0-40 cm.
  • Meteorological data: Monthly precipitation data for the study years and a 10-year average.
  • Crop data: Millet yield in 2017 and soybean yield in 2018.
  • Water use data: Soil water consumption (ET) and soil water use efficiency (WUE) for both crops.

No external datasets were used for training or evaluation; the study relied solely on the data generated from its own experimental setup.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic effect of N and P: The most striking finding is the significant positive synergy between nitrogen and phosphorus fertilization. While single nutrient applications showed some benefits, the combined application of both N and P consistently led to the greatest improvements in both crop yield and water use efficiency. This suggests that for optimal crop performance in this region, addressing both macronutrient limitations is crucial.
  • Soil health improvements: Beyond direct crop benefits, combined N and P fertilization significantly improved soil health indicators. Specifically, it led to substantial increases in soil organic matter and total nitrogen content, which are vital for long-term soil fertility and structure. This indicates that the fertilization strategy not only boosts immediate productivity but also contributes to the sustainability of the soil resource.
  • Water consumption increases with fertilization: Interestingly, all fertilization treatments, including single nutrient applications, led to increased soil water consumption. This is likely due to enhanced crop growth and transpiration, which, when coupled with improved WUE, means more crop biomass is produced per unit of water consumed.
  • Positive correlation between WUE and yield: The study confirmed a strong positive correlation between soil water use efficiency and crop yield across both years and crop types. This reinforces the importance of WUE as a key metric for evaluating the effectiveness of agricultural practices in water-limited environments.

Key Results

  • Crop Yield: Combined N and P fertilization significantly increased crop yields compared to the control. In 2017, millet yields increased by 82.5–560.1% across different treatments, with the highest increases seen in combined N and P applications. In 2018, soybean yields saw increases of 55–490.8%, again with combined N and P treatments showing the most substantial gains.
  • Soil Water Use Efficiency (WUE): Fertilization generally led to significant improvements in WUE. In 2017, WUE increased by 79.5% to 515.2% across various treatments compared to the control. In 2018, increases ranged from 234.9% to 458.1%. Combined N and P treatments consistently demonstrated the highest WUE.
  • Soil Nutrients: Combined N and P application significantly increased SOM (27.1–81.3%) and soil total N (301.3–669.2%) over the two-year period compared to the control. Soil total P also showed increases with certain P-containing treatments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single year for each crop: The experiment involved planting millet in one year and soybeans in another. While this addresses crop-specific nutrient needs, a longer-term study with crop rotation would provide a more comprehensive understanding of cumulative effects on soil properties and yield sustainability.
  • Specific region: The findings are specific to the semi-arid conditions of the Loess Plateau. Further research is needed to determine if these fertilization regimes are equally effective in other semi-arid or arid regions with different soil types and climatic conditions.
  • No irrigation: The study was conducted under rain-fed conditions. While this is relevant for the target region, investigating the interaction of these fertilization strategies with irrigation could offer insights for areas with limited irrigation potential.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that combined N and P fertilization, particularly at the higher rates tested (240 kg N/ha and 90 kg P/ha), should be promoted in arid and semi-arid areas to enhance agricultural production. Future research could focus on optimizing these rates further and exploring the long-term impacts on soil health and ecosystem services.

Summary updated

Abstract

Soil water and nutrients are major factors limiting crop productivity. In the present study, soil water use efficiency (WUE) and crop yield of millet and soybean were investigated under nine fertilization regimes (no nitrogen (N) and no phosphorus (P) (CK), 120 kg ha−1 N and no P (N1P0), 240 kg ha−1 N and no P (N2P0), 45 kg ha−1 P and no N (N0P1), 90 kg ha−1 P and no N (N0P2), 120 kg ha−1 N and 45 kg ha−1 P (N1P1), 240 kg ha−1 N and 45 kg ha−1 P (N2P1), 120 kg ha−1 N and 90 kg ha−1 P (N1P2), 240 kg ha−1 N and 90 kg ha−1 P (N2P2)) in the Loess Plateau, China. We conducted fertilization experiments in two cultivation seasons and collected soil nutrient, water use, and crop yield data. Combined N and P fertilization resulted in the greatest increase in crop yield and WUE, followed by the single P fertilizer application, and single N fertilizer application. The control treatment, which consisted of neither P nor N fertilizer application, had the least effect on crop yield. The combined N and P fertilization increased soil organic matter (SOM) and soil total N, while soil water consumption increased in all treatments. SOM and total N content increased significantly when compared to the control conditions, by 27.1–81.3%, and 301.3–669.2%, respectively, only under combined N and P application. The combined N and P application promoted the formation of a favorable soil aggregate structure and improved soil microbial activity, which accelerated fertilizer use, and enhanced the capacity of soil to maintain fertilizer supply. Crop yield increased significantly in all treatments when compared to the control conditions, with soybean and millet yields increasing by 82.5–560.1% and 55–490.8%, respectively. The combined application of N and P fertilizers increased soil water consumption, improved soil WUE, and satisfied crop growth and development requirements. In addition, soil WUE was significantly positively correlated with crop yield. Our results provide a scientific basis for rational crop fertilization in semi-arid areas on the Loess Plateau.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020effects,
  author = {Qiang Liu and Hongwei Xu and Xingmin Mu and Guangju Zhao and Peng Gao and Wenyi Sun},
  title = {{Effects of Different Fertilization Regimes on Crop Yield and Soil Water Use Efficiency of Millet and Soybean}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12104125},
}
Figure