Effectiveness of Combined Smartwatch and Social Media Intervention on Breast Cancer Survivor Health Outcomes: A 10-Week Pilot Randomized Trial

Zachary Pope, Nan Zeng, Rui Zhang, Hee Yun Lee, Zan GaoJournal of Clinical Medicine 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This pilot study investigated whether a combined smartwatch and social media intervention could improve physical activity and health outcomes in breast cancer survivors. While both groups showed similar increases in physical activity, the smartwatch intervention did not confer additional benefits and was found to be difficult to use by some participants, suggesting simpler wearables might be more effective.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Breast cancer survivors often experience poorer physical health, lower quality of life, and increased fatigue compared to women who haven't had cancer. Physical activity is a key recommendation for improving these outcomes. However, developing effective, scalable interventions for this population is challenging. This study addresses the need for accessible and engaging interventions by exploring the potential of combining wearable technology (smartwatches) with social media-delivered health education, grounded in Social Cognitive Theory, to promote physical activity and improve health outcomes in breast cancer survivors.

Methods

This was a 10-week, two-arm parallel randomized pilot trial.

  • Participants: 30 breast cancer survivors were recruited and randomized into two groups.
  • Intervention Group (n=16): Received a Polar M400 smartwatch for daily activity tracking and joined a private Facebook group where they received Social Cognitive Theory-based physical activity tips twice weekly.
  • Comparison Group (n=14): Joined a separate, but content-identical, Facebook group without the smartwatch.
  • Data Collection:
    • Physical Activity: Assessed using ActiGraph GT3X+ accelerometers to measure daily duration of sedentary behavior, light physical activity, moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA), energy expenditure (EE), and steps/day.
  • Physiological Outcomes: Measured height, weight, body fat percentage, and cardiorespiratory fitness (via YMCA 3-min Step Test).
  • Psychosocial Outcomes: Assessed using validated questionnaires for self-efficacy, social support, enjoyment, barriers, and outcome expectancy.
  • Quality of Life: Evaluated using the Patient Reported Outcome Measurement Information System (PROMIS) for physical functioning, anxiety, depression, fatigue, sleep quality, sleep disturbances, social role limitations, and pain.
  • Intervention Use/Acceptability: A post-intervention survey assessed smartwatch usage frequency, enjoyment, and perceived helpfulness of the Facebook tips.
  • Analysis: A per-protocol analysis was conducted due to dropouts. Group differences in changes from baseline to 10 weeks were analyzed using Mann-Whitney U tests for non-normally distributed data (physical activity, quality of life) and independent t-tests for normally distributed data (physiological, psychosocial).

Datasets

Not applicable. This study involved data collection from human participants, not the use of pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Smartwatch Usability is Crucial: The Polar M400, while functional, was perceived as complex and difficult to use by several participants in the experimental group. This suggests that even with training, the technology itself can be a barrier to adherence, potentially negating the benefits of the intervention.
  • Social Media as a Platform: The Facebook group served as a viable platform for delivering health education tips and fostering peer support, with participants in both groups reporting enjoying the health education content.
  • Regression to the Mean: The unexpected finding of the comparison group showing improvements in social support and barriers, while the intervention group did not, might be explained by regression to the mean, especially since the intervention group had slightly higher social support at baseline.
  • No Added Benefit from Smartwatch Alone: The study did not find evidence that the smartwatch provided any additional benefit to physical activity or health outcomes beyond what was achieved through the social media intervention and general health education.

Key Results

  • Physical Activity: Both groups showed similar, statistically non-significant increases in daily MVPA (+5.1 min), light PA (+7.7 min), EE (+25.1 kcals), and steps (+339 steps) from baseline to 10 weeks.
  • Psychosocial Outcomes: The comparison group showed significant improvements in social support (p=0.05) and barriers (p=0.04), while the intervention group showed a slight decrease in social support and no change in barriers.
  • Quality of Life: The experimental group showed decreased social role limitations and sleep disturbances, with improved sleep quality, though these changes were not significantly different from the comparison group.
  • Dropouts: Ten participants dropped out (4 experimental, 6 comparison). Dropouts differed from completers in factors like insurance coverage, duration since diagnosis, income, and baseline physical activity levels.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • Blinding: The study was not blinded, and some participants knew each other, raising concerns about potential contamination between groups.
  • Smartwatch Adherence: The difficulty in using the Polar M400 may have impacted adherence and the study's outcomes.
  • No Dietary Component: The intervention focused solely on physical activity and sedentary behavior, neglecting the role of diet, which is also crucial for health outcomes in this population.
  • Small Sample Size: The pilot nature and small sample size limited statistical power and generalizability.
  • Sample Demographics: The sample was well-educated and of high socioeconomic status, limiting generalizability to broader populations.
  • Future Work:
    • Simpler Smartwatches: Future interventions should utilize simpler, more user-friendly smartwatches that are more mainstream and easier to use, especially for middle-aged populations who may have lower technological literacy.
  • Combined Interventions: Future research should consider interventions that combine physical activity with dietary components for a more holistic approach.
  • Biomarker Measurement: Including biomarker measurements could provide a more objective assessment of intervention effects.
  • Larger, Diverse Samples: Future studies should recruit larger and more diverse samples to increase statistical power and generalizability.
  • Neighborhood Environment: Incorporating the neighborhood environment into research designs could be beneficial, given its role in physical activity and quality of life.

Summary updated

Abstract

Physical activity (PA) among breast cancer survivors (BCS) can improve this population's health and quality of life (QoL). This study evaluated the effectiveness of a combined smartwatch- and social media-based health education intervention on BCS's health outcomes. Thirty BCS ( X ¯ <sub>age</sub> = 52.6 ± 9.3 years; X ¯ <sub>Wt</sub> = 80.2 ± 19.6 kg) participated in this 10-week, 2-arm randomized trial, with BCS randomized into: (1) experimental group (<i>n</i> = 16): received Polar M400 smartwatches for daily PA tracking and joined a Facebook group wherein Social Cognitive Theory-related PA tips were provided twice weekly; and (2) comparison group (<i>n</i> = 14): only joined separate, but content-identical Facebook group. Outcomes included PA, physiological, psychosocial, and QoL variables. Specifically, PA and energy expenditure (EE) was assessed by ActiGraph GT3X+ accelerometers while physiological, psychosocial, and QoL were examined via validated instruments at baseline and post-intervention. No baseline group differences were observed for any variable. Ten BCS dropped out of the study (experimental: 4; comparison: 6). Compared to completers, dropouts differed significantly on several outcomes. Thus, a per-protocol analysis was performed, revealing significant group differences for changes in social support (<i>t</i> = -2.1, <i>p</i> = 0.05) and barriers (<i>t</i> = -2.2, <i>p</i> = 0.04). Interestingly, the comparison group demonstrated improvements for both variables while the intervention group demonstrated slightly decreased social support and no change in barriers. Notably, both groups demonstrated similarly increased daily light PA, moderate-to-vigorous PA, EE, and steps of 7.7 min, 5.1 min, 25.1 kcals, and 339 steps, respectively, over time. Despite extensive user training, several experimental BCS found the Polar M400 use difficult-possibly decreasing intervention adherence. Future interventions should utilize simpler smartwatches to promote PA among middle-aged clinical/non-clinical populations.
BibTeX
@article{pope2018effectiveness,
  author = {Zachary Pope and Nan Zeng and Rui Zhang and Hee Yun Lee and Zan Gao},
  title = {{Effectiveness of Combined Smartwatch and Social Media Intervention on Breast Cancer Survivor Health Outcomes: A 10-Week Pilot Randomized Trial}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm7060140},
}
Figure