Effective Modeling of Encoder-Decoder Architecture for Joint Entity and Relation Extraction

Tapas Nayak, Hwee Tou Ng

Abstract

A relation tuple consists of two entities and the relation between them, and often such tuples are found in unstructured text. There may be multiple relation tuples present in a text and they may share one or both entities among them. Extracting such relation tuples from a sentence is a difficult task and sharing of entities or overlapping entities among the tuples makes it more challenging. Most prior work adopted a pipeline approach where entities were identified first followed by finding the relations among them, thus missing the interaction among the relation tuples in a sentence. In this paper, we propose two approaches to use encoder-decoder architecture for jointly extracting entities and relations. In the first approach, we propose a representation scheme for relation tuples which enables the decoder to generate one word at a time like machine translation models and still finds all the tuples present in a sentence with full entity names of different length and with overlapping entities. Next, we propose a pointer network-based decoding approach where an entire tuple is generated at every time step. Experiments on the publicly available New York Times corpus show that our proposed approaches outperform previous work and achieve significantly higher F1 scores.

Introduction

Extracting structured information from unstructured text is a fundamental challenge in Natural Language Processing. Specifically, the task of relation extraction involves identifying pairs of entities and the semantic relationships between them. Traditionally, this has been handled via pipeline architectures: first identifying entities through Named Entity Recognition (NER) and then classifying the relationships between them. However, these methods suffer from significant drawbacks, most notably the propagation of errors from the NER stage to the relation extraction stage and the inability to capture the inherent interactions between multiple relation tuples within a single sentence.

Joint extraction models aim to overcome these limitations by modeling entities and relations simultaneously. Despite their promise, existing joint models often struggle with complex scenarios such as overlapping entities—where a single entity participates in multiple relations—and multi-token entity names. This paper addresses these challenges by proposing two novel encoder-decoder architectures designed for robust and efficient joint extraction.

Proposed Methods

We propose two distinct decoding strategies within a unified encoder-decoder framework. The encoder utilizes a Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory (Bi-LSTM) network to generate context-aware representations of the source sentence tokens.

The proposed encoder-decoder architecture and detailed decoder block for joint extraction.

Word-level Decoding (WDec)

The first approach, WDec, treats the extraction task as a sequence generation problem, similar to neural machine translation. The model generates a linearized sequence of tuples using a specific format: Entity1 ; Entity2 ; Relation | Entity3 ; Entity4 ; Relation .... To handle the challenge of multi-token names and ensure that extracted entities are grounded in the source text, we introduce a masking-based copy mechanism. This mechanism constrains the decoder to only "copy" words that appear in the input sentence, thereby reducing hallucinations and improving the accuracy of entity extraction.

Pointer Network-Based Decoding (PNDec)

The second approach, PNDec, moves beyond word-by-word generation to generate an entire tuple at each decoding step. This is achieved by employing pointer networks that predict the start and end indices of the two entities within the source sentence. Simultaneously, a classification layer identifies the relationship between these entities. PNDec is significantly more efficient than WDec, as it avoids the overhead of generating every word in a name, leading to a 66% reduction in GPU memory usage and a doubling of training speed.

Experimental Setup

The proposed models were evaluated on two versions of the New York Times (NYT) dataset: NYT24 (24 relations) and NYT29 (29 relations). These datasets are particularly challenging as they contain numerous instances of Entity Pair Overlap (EPO) and Single Entity Overlap (SEO), providing a rigorous test for the models' ability to handle complex relational structures.

Results and Discussion

The experimental results demonstrate that our proposed architectures significantly outperform previous state-of-the-art models. On the NYT24 dataset, the WDec model achieved a peak F1 score of 0.817, a substantial improvement over the previous best of 0.776.

Experimental results comparing WDec and PNDec variants on NYT29 and NYT24 datasets.

Our analysis reveals several key insights:

  • Representation Matters: A consistent and simple string representation enables standard Seq2Seq models to effectively manage overlapping entities without the need for complex, task-specific tagging schemes.
  • Attention Optimization: We found that "Single" attention, which focuses on the decoder's hidden state, is most effective for WDec. For PNDec, a "Combo" attention mechanism that incorporates both previous hidden states and previously extracted tuples yielded the best results.
  • Robustness to Complexity: Unlike many previous models that show a sharp decline in performance as the number of tuples per sentence increases, our models remain robust, performing exceptionally well even in sentences with five or more relationships.

Conclusion

This paper introduces two effective encoder-decoder strategies for the joint extraction of entities and relations. By utilizing novel representation schemes and pointer networks, we successfully address the long-standing challenges of overlapping entities and multi-token names. The efficiency of the PNDec model makes it a particularly promising candidate for future research into document-level extraction, where computational scalability is paramount.

Summary updated

Abstract

A relation tuple consists of two entities and the relation between them, and often such tuples are found in unstructured text. There may be multiple relation tuples present in a text and they may share one or both entities among them. Extracting such relation tuples from a sentence is a difficult task and sharing of entities or overlapping entities among the tuples makes it more challenging. Most prior work adopted a pipeline approach where entities were identified first followed by finding the relations among them, thus missing the interaction among the relation tuples in a sentence. In this paper, we propose two approaches to use encoder-decoder architecture for jointly extracting entities and relations. In the first approach, we propose a representation scheme for relation tuples which enables the decoder to generate one word at a time like machine translation models and still finds all the tuples present in a sentence with full entity names of different length and with overlapping entities. Next, we propose a pointer network-based decoding approach where an entire tuple is generated at every time step. Experiments on the publicly available New York Times corpus show that our proposed approaches outperform previous work and achieve significantly higher F1 scores.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nayak2020effective,
  author = {Tapas Nayak and Hwee Tou Ng},
  title = {{Effective Modeling of Encoder-Decoder Architecture for Joint Entity and Relation Extraction}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=KHNj6eRdGkm},
}
Figure