Effect of Music Tempo on Long-Distance Driving: Which Tempo Is the Most Effective at Reducing Fatigue?

Rui Li, Yingjie Chen, Linghao Zhangi-Perception 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the impact of music tempo on driver fatigue and attention during long-distance highway driving. They found that medium-tempo music was the most effective at reducing fatigue and maintaining attention over extended periods, offering practical guidance for drivers seeking to improve safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Long-distance driving on monotonous highways is a significant contributor to driver fatigue, drowsiness, and inattention, all of which are major causes of accidents. While listening to music is a common strategy drivers employ to combat boredom and maintain alertness, the specific effects of different music characteristics, particularly tempo, on physiological indicators of fatigue and attention are not fully understood. Existing research has explored various music elements, but a comprehensive, quantitative study on music tempo's impact on real-world driving fatigue and attention was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically examining how different music tempos influence drivers' physiological states during prolonged, monotonous driving.

Methods

The researchers conducted a real-road driving experiment with 16 participants. Each participant completed four driving sessions, each lasting up to 140 minutes. These sessions included four conditions: no music, slow-tempo music, medium-tempo music, and fast-tempo music. To isolate the effect of tempo, a single classical music piece ("Moonlight Over the Spring River") was used, remixed into three distinct tempos.

To measure fatigue and attention, the study employed a combination of physiological and behavioral measures:

  • Electroencephalogram (EEG): Specifically, the R value (calculated from EEG spectrum) was used as an indicator of fatigue. Higher R values indicate increased fatigue.
  • Eye-Tracking: Saccade speed (the speed of eye movements) was measured as an indicator of attention and fatigue. Slower saccade speeds are associated with increased fatigue.
  • Sensorimotor Rhythm (SMR): This EEG-derived measure was used to assess the quality of attention. Higher SMR amplitudes generally indicate better attention.
  • Visual Search Range: Horizontal and vertical eye gaze ranges were recorded to understand how drivers scan their environment, which is also linked to attention levels.

The experiment involved an initial 80-minute driving period without music to induce a baseline level of fatigue, followed by 60 minutes of driving under one of the four music conditions. Data was collected continuously, with specific analysis periods defined as Period 1 (80-110 minutes) and Period 2 (110-140 minutes) to capture changes over time. Statistical analysis involved mixed ANOVA to compare the effects of music conditions and driving periods.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from the participants during the experimental driving sessions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Medium Tempo is the Sweet Spot: The most striking finding is that medium-tempo music appears to strike the optimal balance for long-distance driving. It effectively reduces fatigue and maintains attention for extended periods, unlike slow or fast tempos.
  • Tempo's Dual Nature: Music tempo doesn't have a simple linear effect. While fast music might initially boost arousal and combat fatigue, it can lead to attentional deterioration over time. Conversely, slow music might offer a temporary attention boost but ultimately increases fatigue.
  • Fatigue Progression Matters: The study highlights the importance of the duration of driving. The effects of music tempo change significantly between the first and second halves of the driving period, emphasizing that strategies effective for shorter durations may not be so for prolonged driving.
  • Physiological Correlates of Fatigue and Attention: The study successfully links objective physiological measures (EEG, eye-tracking) to subjective states of fatigue and attention, providing robust data to support their conclusions.
  • Dynamic Model Support: The findings align with and extend existing "dynamic models" of driver alertness, which suggest that music's effect is modulated by the music itself, the driving scenario, and individual driver characteristics.

Key Results

  • Fatigue (R Value): In the initial 80-110 minutes (Period 1), all music tempos (slow, medium, fast) resulted in significantly lower R values (indicating less fatigue) compared to no music. However, in the later 110-140 minutes (Period 2), only medium-tempo music maintained this effect, with slow and fast tempos showing significantly higher R values than no music.
  • Attention (Saccade Speed): During Period 1, all music tempos led to significantly higher saccade speeds (indicating better attention) than no music. In Period 2, medium and fast tempos maintained higher saccade speeds, while slow-tempo music resulted in significantly lower saccade speeds, indicating increased fatigue.
  • Attention Quality (SMR): In Period 1, slow and medium-tempo music showed significantly higher SMR amplitudes (better attention) than no music. In Period 2, medium-tempo music continued to show higher SMR, while slow and fast tempos showed significantly lower SMR than no music.
  • Visual Search Range: Medium-tempo music showed the smallest change in visual search range over time, suggesting a more stable attentional state. Fast tempo music initially enlarged the visual search range but this effect diminished over time.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability of Music Choice: The study used only one classical music piece. While it's a popular piece in China, the findings might not directly generalize to other genres, styles, or instrumental compositions. The authors acknowledge that tempo is just one element among many that influence music's effect.
  • Driver Demographics: The participants were all in their 20s and 30s. The effects of music tempo might differ for older or younger drivers who may have different patience levels or responses to music.
  • Music Duration: The music intervention was limited to 60 minutes after an initial 80 minutes of no-music driving, partly due to equipment battery limitations. Future work could explore longer durations and the entire driving experience from the start.
  • Other Music Elements: The study focused solely on tempo. Future research should investigate the interactions of tempo with other music elements like melody, rhythm, intensity, and lyrics, as well as musical familiarity.
  • Experiment Setting: Future studies could explore different experiment settings, including varied weather conditions, higher speeds, and a broader range of driver ages and driving durations.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigated how music tempo impacted drivers' fatigue and quality of attention in a long-distance monotonous highway environment. Sixteen drivers were enrolled in four sessions of real-road driving tests under the following four music conditions: no music, slow tempo, medium tempo and fast tempo. Specifically, the drivers' electroencephalogram parameters and eye movement parameters were recorded to measure their extent of fatigue and quality of attention, respectively. Of the three tempos, medium-tempo music is the best choice to reduce fatigue and maintain attention for a long-distance driving. Slow-tempo music can temporarily boost the quality of attention, but after a long period of driving, it significantly deteriorates the driver's levels of fatigue and attention. Fast-tempo music helps relieve driver fatigue but significantly deteriorates drivers' attention after an extended driving time. This study offered practical references for drivers regarding the use of music to avoid fatigue, maintain attention and improve their driving safety. Based on previous theories of music and driving, we have explored the underlying mechanism of how music tempo maintains the alertness of drivers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019effect,
  author = {Rui Li and Yingjie Chen and Linghao Zhang},
  title = {{Effect of Music Tempo on Long-Distance Driving: Which Tempo Is the Most Effective at Reducing Fatigue?}},
  booktitle = {i-Perception},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1177/2041669519861982},
}
Figure